Are you religious and why ???

Simple answer: because faith and rationality are from two different (and not exclusionary) metaphysical universes.

Rationality or the desire to "know" requires evidences and certainty. Faith comes from a different place: not from a desire to "know", but rather from a willingness to believe. As such, evidences would actually deny faith: in other words, faith is made possible not "in spite of" the lack of evidences, but through embrassing and accepting the lack of certainty.
Excellent and thoughtful post Gen.
 
Simple answer: because faith and rationality are from two different (and not exclusionary) metaphysical universes.

Rationality or the desire to "know" requires evidences and certainty. Faith comes from a different place: not from a desire to "know", but rather from a willingness to believe. As such, evidences would actually deny faith: in other words, faith is made possible not "in spite of" the lack of evidences, but through embrassing and accepting the lack of certainty.
If it could possibly be put into words, that comes close... 'Uncertainty' is one of the fundamental principals and paradoxes of the quantum world, out of which the known universe, and consciousness, is somehow created. That something is created out of nothing, call it god, or whatever, defies all scientific explanation and remains a mystery ... you can search for empirical evidence until hell freezes over, you won't find it. In other words, there is no rational explanation for the universe, or consciousness, or for why they exist. Nonetheless, whatever they may be, you can't deny their existence.
 
Yet if there is a god why do such bad things happen, like in Haiti ?

Unless god has no control of what goes on.
Also, whether or not supernatural beings exist is a separate question from whether they are nice.

However, I think that Orson Scot Card’s The Worthing Saga does try to explain why a good god might allow bad things to happen. He does this using an SF story involving vastly superior beings (I have always found SF more believable then religious writings). However, you can tell he is basically drawing on his Mormon beliefs. It is a very good read.

However, when it get right down to it, whether supernatural beings exist or not is separate from the question of whether or not they would be nice guys.

If it could possibly be put into words, that comes close... 'Uncertainty' is one of the fundamental principals and paradoxes of the quantum world, out of which the known universe, and consciousness, is somehow created. That something is created out of nothing, call it god, or whatever, defies all scientific explanation and remains a mystery ... you can search for empirical evidence until hell freezes over, you won't find it. In other words, there is no rational explanation for the universe, or consciousness, or for why they exist. Nonetheless, whatever they may be, you can't deny their existence.
Unfortunately, I don’t think whether science eventually solves the first mover problem or not, sheds much light on why people are religious as even religious people must realize that their god had to be created out of nothing at one time.
 
Yet if there is a god why do such bad things happen, like in Haiti ?

Unless god has no control of what goes on.

Do you think that the existence of God is supposed to be some sort of "Immunity idol" against pain and suffering? Or that Faith in God is supposed to protect us from harm and evil? That's utterly absurd.

Yes, bad things happen. And bad things happen to good people. A friend once asked me if God caused wars. No: Sin causes wars. Did God cause sin? No: He gave mankind Free Choice (Free Will), and mankind fell into temptation. After the fall, God promised (and delivered) us a Saviour from our sin, and the Old Testament prophecies were fulfilled in Jesus Christ.

Pain and suffering are with us in this world. But they do also serve to remind us of God's greatness and in Him we find comfort and peace.
 
Do you think that the existence of God is supposed to be some sort of "Immunity idol" against pain and suffering? Or that Faith in God is supposed to protect us from harm and evil? That's utterly absurd.

Not absurd at all!
You must be familiar with the 'Problem of Evil' which is the most devastating argument against god.
That a 'purported' All Good, Loving, Knowing, Powerful and PERFECT god allows evil to exist in the first place IS WHAT IS ABSURD!....:(
 
Not absurd at all!
You must be familiar with the 'Problem of Evil' which is the most devastating argument against god.
That a 'purported' All Good, Loving, Knowing, Powerful and PERFECT god allows evil to exist in the first place IS WHAT IS ABSURD!....:(

It isn't absurd once you know why.
 
Simple answer: because faith and rationality are from two different (and not exclusionary) metaphysical universes.

Rationality or the desire to "know" requires evidences and certainty. Faith comes from a different place: not from a desire to "know", but rather from a willingness to believe. As such, evidences would actually deny faith: in other words, faith is made possible not "in spite of" the lack of evidences, but through embrassing and accepting the lack of certainty.

Yeah, they said you were smart but......

First there are rational paths to enlightenment such as Buddhism which is based on science and they believe in a godhead because of empirical evidence


Second how does irrational belief support Darwinism ?? Why did we evolve to believe in the irrational ???? How does that ensure our survival???

lEven if the prophets are for real humanity has always had a God to worship so some of them must be irrational
 
If it could possibly be put into words, that comes close... 'Uncertainty' is one of the fundamental principals and paradoxes of the quantum world, out of which the known universe, and consciousness, is somehow created. That something is created out of nothing, call it god, or whatever, defies all scientific explanation and remains a mystery ... you can search for empirical evidence until hell freezes over, you won't find it. In other words, there is no rational explanation for the universe, or consciousness, or for why they exist. Nonetheless, whatever they may be, you can't deny their existence.

Excellent point Philosopher

Physicists and astrologers become believers for just this reason
 
Excellent point Philosopher

Physicists and astrologers become believers for just this reason
I think that most Physicists would be very insulted to be included in the same sentence as astrologers. However, if you go back far enough astrology was a religion in the same way as modern religions. However, I have never taken astrology any more or less seriously than modern religions like Christianity, Islam, etc. BTW, few top physicists are theists (e.g. when you look at surveys of the national Academy of science). I don’t’ know about astrologers.
 
Excellent point Philosopher

Physicists and astrologers become believers for just this reason
Lumping physicists with astrologers is quite insulting to physicists many would say! Astrologers should be grouped more with televangelists, charlatans, faith healers and mystics but not physicists....;)
 
Lumping physicists with astrologers is quite insulting to physicists many would say! Astrologers should be grouped more with televangelists, charlatans, faith healers and mystics but not physicists....;)

You've already established yourself to not be ready to understand basic facts, by claiming that religion (to you) is supposed to be some sort of immunity idol.
 
I've been thinking about converting Buddhism. Not there yet. But I really agree with the Four Noble Truths and some parts of The Noble Eightfold Path.
 
I think that most Physicists would be very insulted to be included in the same sentence as astrologers.

I meant astronomers

someone;2947450 BTW said:
Interesting. Einstein thought the universe could only be explained by a God and I thought that was common amongst such intellectuals

Perhaps it depends on how you define Theism

Theism in the broadest sense is the belief in at least one deity.[1][2] In a more specific sense, theism refers to a particular doctrine concerning the nature of a God and his relationship to the universe.[3] Theism, in this specific sense, conceives of a God as personal and active in the governance and organization of the world and the universe. The use of the word theism as indicating a particular doctrine of monotheism arose in the wake of the scientific revolution of the seventeenth century to contrast with the then emerging deism which contended that a God — though transcendent and supreme — did not intervene in the natural world and could be known rationally but not via revelation.[4]
 
Another thought ..........

The universe is so strange that you have to allow for the possibility of Jesus being the son of God but why would he come to earth and intentionally leave no proof after giving us analytical brains that make us question and when we use our brains designed by God we get thrown out of heaven ???????????
 
In a letter a year before he died Einstein dismissed most organized religion as "an incarnation of the most childish superstitions".
Einstein goes on to write:
"The word God is for me nothing more than the expression and product of human weaknesses, the Bible a collection of honourable, but still primitive legends which are nevertheless pretty childish."
http://www.haaretz.com/hasen/spages/983001.html

To Einstein the notion of surviving physical death is concept shared by "feeble souls" operating from a baseline of "fear and absurd egotism."

Other Einstein quotes:
"I do not believe in the God of theology who rewards good and punishes evil. My God created laws that take care of that. His universe is not ruled by wishful thinking, but by immutable laws."

"I cannot conceive of a god who rewards and punishes his creatures or has a will of the kind that we experience in ourselves. Neither can I--nor would I want to-- conceive of an individual that survives his physical death. Let feeble souls, from fear or absurd egotism, cherish such thoughts. I am satisfied with the mystery of the eternity of life and a glimpse of the marvelous structure of the existing world, together with the devoted striving to comprehend a portion, be it ever so tiny, of the Reason that manifests itself in nature."

http://ldolphin.org/einstein.html

http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,355323,00.html
 
Great quotes Kilgore

Einstein changes his views on God throughout his life

But these quotes seem to deny only the Anthropomorphism of God IMHO
 
I meant astronomers
Interesting. Einstein thought the universe could only be explained by a God and I thought that was common amongst such intellectuals
Einstein was not a theist by any stretch of the imagination. As he wrote "The word god is for me nothing more than the expression and product of human weaknesses, the Bible a collection of honorable, but still primitive legends which are nevertheless pretty childish. No interpretation no matter how subtle can (for me) change this." See for example: http://www.guardian.co.uk/science/2008/may/12/peopleinscience.religion
Whether he was or was not a deist could be argued depending on whether you think some of his other references to god were metaphorical or literal references to a supernatural being. I have never seen much practical difference between a deist and an nonbeliever as a deist has no reason to alter his real world behavior to please a mythical god given that he does not think that behavior would matter to the god.
If you do a search, you will find a couple of well known surveys of both the American National Academy of Sciences and the UK’s Royal Society that finds very few of either group believe in religious superstitions but a significant minority are open to the idea of a deist god.

Edit: for a second hand discussion of some of the surveys see, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Relati...ence#The_scientific_community.27s_perspective

To quote:
“According to a 1996 survey, belief in a god that is "in intellectual and affective communication with humankind" and belief in "personal immortality" are most popular among mathematicians[specify] and least popular among biologists.[specify] In total, 60% of scientists in the United States expressed disbelief or agnosticism toward a personal god who answers prayer.[61] This compared with 58% in 1914 and 67% in 1933. Among leading scientists — defined as members of the National Academy of Sciences — 72.2% expressed disbelief and another 20% were agnostic concerning the existence of a personal god who answers prayer. [62]
A survey conducted between 2005 and 2007 by Elaine Ecklund of University at Buffalo, The State University of New York and funded by the Templeton Foundation found that over 60% of natural and social science professors are atheists or agnostics. When asked whether they believed in God, nearly 34% answered "I do not believe in God" and about 30% answering "I do not know if there is a God and there is no way to find out,"[63] According to the same survey, "[m]any scientists see themselves as having a spirituality not attached to a particular religious tradition."[64] In further analysis, published in 2007, Ecklund and Christopher Scheitle conclude that "the assumption that becoming a scientist necessarily leads to loss of religion is untenable" and that "t appears that those from non-religious backgrounds disproportionately self-select into scientific professions. This may reflect the fact that there is tension between the religious tenets of some groups and the theories and methods of particular sciences and it contributes to the large number of non-religious scientists."[65]”
 
Thanx someone it seems I had misconceptions


http://www.ctmu.org/

Here the world's smartest man explains why there is a God

I am struggling to read it and have to go look up some words but he seems to try to make it as simple as can be done