Canada's International Reputation

Please read up on what happened to captured American uniformed soldiers at the Battle of the Bulge.

This goes on in all wars by all sides in the past.
Some are more blatant at it.
 
Fuji,

You really impress me. Unlike most blathering idiots on the web (no offense to the blathering idiots, but surely, to the extent you see it in others, you must see it in yourselves), you actually take the time to argue your points largely without relying on ad hominem attacks and reason.

You're not always 100% correct (as I too know of some German attrocities committed against Canuck troops during the battle of the Falaise Gap, but I can't find a cite because it will not be on the web almost certainly, but I do recall the event from my paper done on that battle in my military history course at the uni), but you argue rationally, honestly (unlike so many here, fuck you're people's quoting of what Fuji said is downright political... Of course, I shouldn't be surprised given the forum... What are all you? A bunch of fucking elected democratic politicians? You don't even get paid to lie and twist words like those fuckers! Give it up already! SHeesh!).

I applaud you for your dedication to your points...

In the meantime, carry on to entertain and enlighten me. I need more of that this Saturday a.m.

:D
 
You're not always 100% correct (as I too know of some German attrocities committed against Canuck troops during the battle of the Falaise Gap, but I can't find a cite because it will not be on the web almost certainly, but I do recall the event from my paper done on that battle in my military history course at the uni)
Perhaps this is what you're referring to http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kurt_Meyer_(Panzermeyer)#Final_battles_in_Normandy_-_Falaise_pocket.
(about a screen or two below where the links takes you to the war crimes convictions)
 
Please read up on what happened to captured American uniformed soldiers at the Battle of the Bulge.

Sure, and you can find other isolated incidents as well. There were isolated cases of Allied commanders doing similar things. Overall, though, the Allies treated German POW's according to the GC, and the Germans reciprocated.

In short, the Germans treated Canadian POW's better than Canadians are treating Afghan POW's.

I think it's time you conceded that point.
 
Sure, and you can find other isolated incidents as well. There were isolated cases of Allied commanders doing similar things. Overall, though, the Allies treated German POW's according to the GC, and the Germans reciprocated.

Exactly how many "incidents" have to occur before it's no longer considered "isolated" ?
 
In short, the Germans treated Canadian POW's better than Canadians are treating Afghan POW's.
I think it's time you conceded that point.

Tell you what, I'll consider conceding that point if and when those two famous Canada bashers Bob Rae and Jack Layton:( and the Red Cross agrees with your statement.
 
Tell you what, I'll consider conceding that point if and when those two famous Canada bashers Bob Rae and Jack Layton:( and the Red Cross agrees with your statement.

The Red Cross has already agreed with my statements, it published reports on the treatment of POW's throughout the war. The RC is in fact one of the primary documentary sources of evidence for the claim that Germany treated POW's reasonably.

The Red Cross had regular, routine access to POW's in Germany. RC medical staff monitored their health, and the RC was also permitted to bring in additional food.

Canada has repeatedly frustrated attempts by the Red Cross to do the same for Afghan POW's captured by Canada. Access has been spotty, not routine as in Germany, and in many cases delayed or outright denied in illegal ways.

As for you needing some politician to speak up before you will acknowledge the point--I think you are wriggling and squirming but you now know that the point is correct:

Canadian POW's in Germany were treated much better than we are treating Afghan POW's.
 
As for you needing some politician to speak up before you will acknowledge the point--

Bob Rae and Jack Layton are not just "some politician", they are leading the charge on this Afghan prisoner issue. But, their complaints are about event(s) that occurred in 2006. Are they also complaining about the situation now as well?
 
the Germans treated Canadian POW's better than Canadians are treating Afghan POW's.

Would you at least concede that no Afghan POW's were intentionally murdered (unlike some German WW II POW's) while in Canadian custody?
 
Sure, and you can find other isolated incidents as well. There were isolated cases of Allied commanders doing similar things. Overall, though, the Allies treated German POW's according to the GC, and the Germans reciprocated.

In short, the Germans treated Canadian POW's better than Canadians are treating Afghan POW's.

I think it's time you conceded that point.

You have lost your mark here. The Germans killed a couple hundred Canadian prisoners. Murdered them. Yet you dismiss this as "isolated incidents" because overall they ran a PW system that abided by the Geneva Conventions.

Canadians have murdered no prisoners in Afghanistan and so far there is evidence that only one prisoner was beaten by the Afghans after being handed over by Canadians (who later rescued the guy). Yet, you are willing to assume prisoner torture was rampant and to declare Canadians as war criminals. Surely you see the lack of logic in your two stances?

You should have conceded the point about the German mistreatment and murder of Allied prisoners. Instead you went down a rabbit hole and have caused the other posters in here to discredit your arguments.
 
Would you at least concede that no Afghan POW's were intentionally murdered (unlike some German WW II POW's) while in Canadian custody?

No, we did not murder any Afghan POW's in our custody. We did that in Somalia, but not (to my knowledge) yet in Afghanistan. Furthermore I agree that any abuses of Afghans while in Canadian custody were the isolated acts of individuals and contrary to Canadian policy.

I will furthermore go on record and say that the murder of prisoners in Somalia by Canadians was an isolated incident and not the result of Canadian government policy, just as the murder of some Canadians by an individual German commander was an isolated incident that was contrary to German policy.
 
just as the murder of some Canadians by an individual German commander was an isolated incident that was contrary to German policy.
So you are saying that Hitler's orders to execute commandos (including documented cases of Canadian commandos being executed) did not qualify as German government policy or are you saying it was not murder? :confused:
 
A thought, why hasn't anyone mentioned NATO's role in this, after all, Canadian troops came under Nato's Command in 2006.
 
So you are saying that Hitler's orders to execute commandos did not qualify as German government policy or are you saying it was not murder? :confused:

Sure, that was illegal, just as was the US decision to execute Germans infiltrators captured on US soil. It was not, however, the fate of the overwhelming majority of POW's on either side.

Overall Germany treated Canadian POW's better than Canada treated Afghan POW's. I don't think anyone is disputing that point any longer, which is what was to be demonstrated.
 
Overall Germany treated Canadian POW's better than Canada treated Afghan POW's. I don't think anyone is disputing that point any longer, which is what was to be demonstrated.
I think you are the only one that thinks it has been demonstrated. However, I know that you will never admit your wrong about anything, so I am not going to bother arguing.
 
Sure, that was illegal, just as was the US decision to execute Germans infiltrators captured on US soil. It was not, however, the fate of the overwhelming majority of POW's on either side.

Overall Germany treated Canadian POW's better than Canada treated Afghan POW's. I don't think anyone is disputing that point any longer, which is what was to be demonstrated.

Seeing as how Canadian Soldiers were outright murdered, and there is no evidence of a single Afghan prisoner being mishandled in anyway by Canadian soldiers, you are completely wrong.

In summary

- You have summarily dismissed the lives of Canadians soldiers killed as being "isolated"

- You have failed to provide any proof and afghan prisoners being mistreated while in Canadian Custody.

- In fact I have yet to see any "proof" of the afghans systematically torturing their prisoners , and if they have beaten up one or two, and killed some, well as you would put it, it's merely "isolated"

- You don't seem to comprehend the fact people ARE disputing afghan combatants were mistreated by Canadian soldiers.
 
Seeing as how Canadian Soldiers were outright murdered, and there is no evidence of a single Afghan prisoner being mishandled in anyway by Canadian soldiers, you are completely wrong.

Are you a fool? It's well documented that they were handed over by Canadians to people the Canadian government had, in Peter MacKay's words, "credible evidence" that they would be tortured.

That is in fact mishandling them, and is in fact a war crime.

Nowhere have I claimed that Canadian soldiers directly beat or tortured anyone. Maybe it is your opinion that they were, but it has never been my opinion. If there were such cases I would agree that they were isolated incidents--individual soldiers making decisions contrary to Canadian policy.

However you are a fool if you think handing someone over to a torturer is not mishandling, it plainly is, and it is plainly a crime.

You have summarily dismissed the lives of Canadians soldiers killed as being "isolated"

Yes, as it's true. The overwhelming majority of Canadians were well treated. Some were not. In those cases it was generally as a result of local decisions by field commanders in contravention to national policy. This was true on both sides.

An exception would be the treatment of people who were considered "spies" or "sabateurs" by both sides, the policy on both sides was, at a national level, to execute such people. Controversially Germany extended this to "commandos" who were dropped behind enemy lines, even when they remained in uniform. Regular front line soldiers--the overwhelming majority of POW's--were overwhelmingly treated as required by the GC, a fact documented by the Red Cross.

- You have failed to provide any proof and afghan prisoners being mistreated while in Canadian Custody.

I have never claimed it, other than, of course, the mistreatment and crime of being handed over to a torturer, which is well documented, and admitted by all sides in the debate.

- In fact I have yet to see any "proof" of the afghans systematically torturing their prisoners , and if they have beaten up one or two, and killed some, well as you would put it, it's merely "isolated"

You are now in disagreement with even Peter MacKay, with your absurd position, which is contrary to everything that has been published on the matter. I refer you to the Colvin report, and to Peter MacKay's reaction to it, in which MacKay described the evidence that there was systematic torture as "credible".