Canada's International Reputation

As for Fuji's statement that the Germans treated our soldiers better than we treat the Afghans

You Sir ARE FULL OF SHIT

Prove it. Provide a citation indicating that the Germans systematically mistreated Canadian POW's. I am willing to back up my claim with historical citations, are you?

Note CANADIAN. It's well known that the Germans mistreated Soviet POWs.

Afghans POW's captured by Canada are beaten and/or tortured and generally denied the protections of the GC, a fate that never befell Canadian POW's captured by Germany.
 
The Germans perceived that the Soviets weren't following the GC with their soldiers, and so they reciprocated.
You, I believe will find that in fact the Germans acted first in this regard.

I defy you to find a credible source that alleges gross systematic mistreatment of Western POW's in WW2.
Although I'm not going to bother spending my time looking it up, I believe that again you will find that British, Canadian and American treatment of German POW's was
better than that of German treatment of ours. Simply antidotally I don't know of allied POW's who moved heaven and earth to be able to move to West Germany. Nor of many allied POW's who have taken their entire families on vacation to see where they were held.
 
Prove it. Provide a citation indicating that the Germans systematically mistreated Canadian POW's. I am willing to back up my claim with historical citations, are you?

Note CANADIAN. It's well known that the Germans mistreated Soviet POWs.

Afghans POW's captured by Canada are beaten and/or tortured and generally denied the protections of the GC, a fate that never befell Canadian POW's captured by Germany.

We will start with the execution of a large number of escapers during the great escape.

And we can follow it up with the battle records of any of the regiments that were involved in WWII , that would be all of them . And go from there to the records of the Royal airforce and other commentwealth airforces with regard to shot down airmen.

There are more , many more, perhaps you should do some research of our own prior to making indefensible claims
 
Soviet POW's in Germany, on the other hand, were not treated in accordance with the Geneva Conventions and in fact over a million of them died. The Germans perceived that the Soviets weren't following the GC with their soldiers, and so they reciprocated.

There was also the factor that many Germans regarded Russians as a sub-human species not worthy of decent humane treatment. That 'Master Race' sentiment played a role in how Russians were mistreated in WWII. This was one of the reasons Eisenhower pulled back his final assault on Berlin and allowed the Russians to do the final honors of taking Berlin. This was also the reason many German officers then committed suicide in the end, rather than being taken prisoner by the Russians. Those German officers knew they would not be treated well and expected the Russians to take full revenge on them for their massive war crimes against Mother Russia.
 
We will start with the execution of a large number of escapers during the great escape.

And we can follow it up with the battle records of any of the regiments that were involved in WWII , that would be all of them . And go from there to the records of the Royal airforce and other commentwealth airforces with regard to shot down airmen.

There are more , many more, perhaps you should do some research of our own prior to making indefensible claims

I await your citation.
 
The Germans treated captured Canadian soldiers better than we're treating the Afghans.

Boy you really pulled that one out of your ass. Where did you get your information from - that guy who denies the holocost? The Germans in WWII were so bad that today's Germans say "Those weren't Germans, they were Nazis."

The only bad international reputation Canadians have is one of being very very bad tippers.
 
Boy you really pulled that one out of your ass. Where did you get your information from - that guy who denies the holocost? The Germans in WWII were so bad that today's Germans say "Those weren't Germans, they were Nazis."

POW's were not sent to concentration camps.

Well for clarificaiton *Western* POW's weren't. The Germans treated Soviet POW's horribly.
 
The above is a direct quote.

Yes. I stand by that quote. Transferring prisoners to the Afghans when you know that they will be beaten and/or tortured is in fact a war crime. Absolutely.

How did you come to the utter bullshit misrepresentation of my position that I am "equating" Canadian treatment of Afghan POWs with German treatment of Soviet POWs? What I said is that the Germans treated Canadian POW's better than we are treating Afghan POW's, and that is true. The Germans did not systematically beat and torture Canadian POW's, nor did the Germans send Canadians to an ally to be beaten or tortured.

The crime committed against the Afghans is the equivalent of a charge of systematic, serial assault and battery, by analogy to domestic law. The Germans were guilty of mass murder with respect to their Soviet POW's.

Is it your view that assault and murder are equal charges? It certainly isn't my view, and I find your attempt to misrepresent my position to be in quite poor taste.
 
Not if they were prisoners of the Japanese during World War II.

You are absolutely correct. Around 50% of allied prisoners in Japanese custody died as a result of war crimes committed by the Japanese on POW's. Japan neither signed nor abided by the terms of the Geneva Conventions on warfare.

You are no doubt well enough able to read that you can see I was clearly and plainly talking about the German treatment of Western POW's.

This is as opposed to Japanese treatment of POW's, which was criminal, and German treatment of Soviet POW's, which was also criminal. Japan ignored the GC, and Germany (wrongly) claimed it did not apply to Soviet prisoners due to the Soviets not having signed the convention.
 
You are absolutely correct. Around 50% of allied prisoners in Japanese custody died as a result of war crimes committed by the Japanese on POW's. Japan neither signed nor abided by the terms of the Geneva Conventions on warfare.

You are no doubt well enough able to read that you can see I was clearly and plainly talking about the German treatment of Western POW's.

Actually at the time you were referring the the international community as a whole , no mention of Germany had been made at that point in the discussion.
 
Clearly Canada has a reputation for world class hockey and curling teams.....

I'm looking forward to the Winter Games in Canada....

OTB
 
Fuji, I'm curious.......are you a bubble-boy? Do you live your life inside a protective cocoon? Or are you a paid poster, based on your ability to go on endlessly in multipage threads over issues that are beyond your control?

Just having some fun with you, Fuji. Consider me your "natural ally", like Israel and Iran (I'll be Israel!!) :D
 
How did you come to the utter bullshit misrepresentation of my position that I am "equating" Canadian treatment of Afghan POWs with German treatment of Soviet POWs?

Thanks for clarifying that not all "war crimes" are equal. I would think that the "war crime" of handing an AFGHAN pow to the AFGHAN authorities rank pretty low in the hierarchy of "war crimes".

The crime committed against the Afghans is the equivalent of a charge of systematic, serial assault and battery, by analogy to domestic law.

Since when does domestic law apply in a theatre of war or in a hockey game for that matter? (The question of whether anyone was tortured or beaten or had his hairdo messed up is still open for debate.)
 
Something to ponder. This appeared around Rememberance Day.

British newspaper salutes Canada . . . this is a good read.
It is funny how it took someone in England to put it into words... Sunday Telegraph Article From today's UK wires:

Salute to a brave and modest nation - Kevin Myers, 'The Sunday Telegraph' LONDON :

Until the deaths of Canadian soldiers killed in Afghanistan , probably almost no one outside their home country had been aware that Canadian troops are deployed in the region.

And as always, Canada will bury its dead, just as the rest of the world, as always will forget its sacrifice, just as it always forgets nearly everything Canada ever does.. It seems that Canada 's historic mission is to come to the selfless aid both of its friends and of complete strangers, and then, once the crisis is over, to be well and truly ignored..

Canada is the perpetual wallflower that stands on the edge of the hall, waiting for someone to come and ask her for a dance. A fire breaks out, she risks life and limb to rescue her fellow dance-goers, and suffers serious injuries. But when the hall is repaired and the dancing resumes, there is Canada, the wallflower still, while those she once helped Glamorously cavort across the floor, blithely neglecting her yet again.

That is the price Canada pays for sharing the North American continent with the United States , and for being a selfless friend of Britain in two global conflicts.

For much of the 20th century, Canada was torn in two different directions: It seemed to be a part of the old world, yet had an address in the new one, and that divided identity ensured that it never fully got the gratitude it deserved.

Yet it's purely voluntary contribution to the cause of freedom in two world wars was perhaps the greatest of any democracy. Almost 10% of Canada 's entire population of seven million people served in the armed forces during the First World War, and nearly 60,000 died. The great Allied victories of 1918 were spearheaded by Canadian troops, perhaps the most capable soldiers in the entire British order of battle.

Canada was repaid for its enormous sacrifice by downright neglect, it's unique contribution to victory being absorbed into the popular Memory as somehow or other the work of the 'British.'

The Second World War provided a re-run. The Canadian navy began the war with a half dozen vessels, and ended up policing nearly half of the Atlantic against U-boat attack. More than 120 Canadian warships participated in the Normandy landings, during which 15,000 Canadian soldiers went ashore on D-Day alone.

Canada finished the war with the third-largest navy and the fourth largest air force in the world. The world thanked Canada with the same sublime indifference as it had the previous time.

Canadian participation in the war was acknowledged in film only if it was necessary to give an American actor a part in a campaign in which the United States had clearly not participated - a touching scrupulousness which, of course, Hollywood has since abandoned, as it has any notion of a separate Canadian identity.

So it is a general rule that actors and filmmakers arriving in Hollywood keep their nationality - unless, that is, they are Canadian. Thus Mary Pickford, Walter Huston, Donald Sutherland, Michael J. Fox, William Shatner, Norman Jewison, David Cronenberg, Alex Trebek, Art Linkletter and Dan Aykroyd have in the popular perception become American, and Christopher Plummer, British.

It is as if, in the very act of becoming famous, a Canadian ceases to be Canadian, unless she is Margaret Atwood, who is as unshakably Canadian as a moose, or Celine Dion, for whom Canada has proved quite unable to find any takers.

Moreover, Canada is every bit as queru lou sly alert to the achievements of its sons and daughters as the rest of the world is completely unaware of them. The Canadians proudly say of themselves - and are unheard by anyone else - that 1% of the world's population has provided 10% of the world's peacekeeping forces.

Canadian soldiers in the past half century have been the greatest peacekeepers on Earth - in 39 missions on UN mandates, and six on non-UN peacekeeping duties, from Vietnam to East Timor, from Sinai to Bosnia.

Yet the only foreign engagement that has entered the popular non-Canadian imagination was the sorry affair in Somalia , in which out-of-control paratroopers murdered two Somali infiltrators. Their regiment was then disbanded in disgrace - a uniquely Canadian act of self-abasement for which, naturally, the Canadians received no international credit.

So who today in the United States knows about the stoic and selfless friendship its northern neighbour has given it in Afghanistan ?

Rather like Cyrano de Bergerac , Canada repeatedly does honourable things for honourable motives, but instead of being thanked for it, it remains something of a figure of fun. It is the Canadian way, for which Canadians should be proud, yet such honour comes at a high cost. This past year more grieving Canadian families knew that cost all too tragically well.

Lest we forget.