HST, Native peoples, Caledonia, etc

chased the developers away on land they had purchased legaly.

To be fair, whether or not the land was purchased legally is the subject of the dispute.

I don't like the tactics that they are using either, but it is at least worth being clear on the point that the natives do not believe it was a legal purchase, and may have valid grounds for their belief.
 
LOL

I am Native and reading some of the posts, it is just hilarious.



One moron says "there is one law for Natives, and one for whites" ...
soooo ... there is no other people in Ontario or Canada ? Just Natives and whites, eh.
Or is there a law for every back ground ?

The other good one is "they will spend the money on 'stupid' things"

Have no fear, racism is alive and well here in the GTA/Ontario/Canada.



OH, I forgot about the land in which my relatives live on is rich in ... what was it ... resources ? Yeah we are sitting on more oil then they have in the Mid-East, or is it more gold and diamonds then Africa.
So you are saying that the governments gave us this rich land because ....... ?



300 years(you dearly need some re-education) and still whining ?

1960's
Natives would be told to Fuck Off by 95% of lenders(banks et al).
Routinely picked up, arrested in other words, for stupid small shit that no other person is bothered by the law.

1970's
Governments wanting to change deals and still putting a white man in charge of the money given to Natives. He would make bad decision after bad decision. We would be told you have been given money, see the Minister in Charge of Native and Indian Affairs.

WE NEVER CONTROLED THE MONEY ! NEVER !!


1980's
Civilized times right ? Native Schools still in operation in which Native children are taken from their parents and taught how to be white and that the traditional Native ways are wrong.
It was still in practice to sterilize Natives.

Still today Natives, who have had too much to drink, are picked up driven to the middle of no where and released ... during the winter.


All the money we have been given in the past you complain about ?
It was spent by the Minister in Charge, see above, the little we did get ?
When Natives would try and better themselves by taking course, were told do not bother ... you do not qualify.
We did not get access to get the credits to take the courses to better our selves.

Funny how some people only know or choose to research only certain parts of history.

OH by the way we have our idiots as well.
AIM(to name but one US organization) was started by Natives with the best intentions, but it is sometimes used to just cause kaos. Yes we have our idiots.
 
I certainly did not.
Went to HS in the late 70s, early 80s.

Besides I am talking about post secondary.
 
To be fair, whether or not the land was purchased legally is the subject of the dispute.

I don't like the tactics that they are using either, but it is at least worth being clear on the point that the natives do not believe it was a legal purchase, and may have valid grounds for their belief.

Yes, but if someone sells my house to a second party illegally, and the second party sells it to a third party legally, then my rights to the house end at the first legal transaction.

I still have the right to civil damages, however those are capped at 2 years from the initial cause of action, for most suits.

Essentially, what happened at Caledonia totally screws up the entire land registry and civil property ownership system. First nations are threatening new construction projects as far away as Cambridge and Waterloo, by threatening land claim actions. If I had a large farm or valuable piece of land within "x miles" of the Grand River (which is a big river), I would be concerned. The first nations have started mailing out property tax forms to the land owners.

The other issue is that anywhere else in the province, people have a right to enjoy their property. For certain people in Caledonia, if not the entire town, they don't deserve to be living on the front lines in what amounts to an effective war zone / demilitarized area. It would be interesting to see if you can get Title Insurance and Property Insurance on certain pieces of land in Caledonia. To prevent losses, the insurance companies will either refuse to insure or refuse to pay damages.
 
All the money we have been given in the past you complain about ?
It was spent by the Minister in Charge, see above, the little we did get ?

There's a tricky issue here. My own view is that a large part of the problem is corruption in the band councils. I think that the Canadian taxpayer coughs up probably more money than we should, but that very little of it reaches the average native person.

The self governing organizations that bands run, while in theory a good idea perhaps, in reality are broken, rife with corruption, and put the tax dollars they receive into idiotic or self-serving projects that do not make a difference. The Canadian government is afraid to step in and clean it up for fear of being seen as interfering in native self government, but SOMEBODY has to.

In my view what has made the biggest difference for native peoples is that a few natives got law degrees, re-opened the treaty, and lo and behold most of the treaties weren't very well written. These natives-with-law-degrees have done more in a few years than all the previous protests over decades.

Certainly there was a lot of abuse to combat, and the courts are indeed the right place to combat it, and much has been accomplished there.

At the same time I think native groups should acknowledge the sort of blood-sucking sense of entitlement that some natives have: There seems to be this perception that if you are native you are entitled to be bailed out by the government, while contributing nothing in return.

No doubt that sentiment has something to do with being abused by the government for decades, but it can't always be that way.
 
Breaking the cycle requires that Aboriginal students get into postsecondary education and graduate,
but to do so it is usually necessary to complete high school. The failure to complete high school is the
first impediment to increasing PSE attainment. A shocking number of Aboriginal young adults are not completing
high school. This is a gathering storm, which will have huge social and economic costs over the next
decades.

Of course none of them will ever benefit from fre schooling if they cannot even complete high school


Source
 
I said post secondary....

Oops sorry my mistake.

I never finished HS, but my brother got a post secondary education.
I cannot speak to the system as a whole, in his case he had to pay something back.
Remember this thought, I spoke up because of some of the posters on here. I am not the person to ask about specifics.
 
It is also worth noting that any Indian I have met who was well educated, successful and generally a productive member of society usually 1) Didn't live on reserves, or at least go away from them as soon as possible and 2) Usually expressed quite a bit of contempt for those who do live on the reserves and squander all opportunities given to them.

Giving them more land to further isolate them from progressing along with the rest of the society certainly is not the answer.

I also agree whole-heartedly with Fuji on the band councils being corrupt and self serving
 
Yes, but if someone sells my house to a second party illegally, and the second party sells it to a third party legally, then my rights to the house end at the first legal transaction.

No, you are applying the wrong law, that is not true in cases of sovereignty: The dispute is whether or not the Canadian system even has jurisdiction over the land. It's not a question of title--they are not claiming that they own the land, they are claiming that they have sovereignty over the land.

If it is sovereign native land there are no transactions under Canadian law, nor any series of transactions under Canadian law, that can change that: Canadian law, in that case, does not apply.
 
It is also worth noting that any Indian I have met who was well educated, successful and generally a productive member of society usually 1) Didn't live on reserves, or at least go away from them as soon as possible and 2) Usually expressed quite a bit of contempt for those who do live on the reserves and squander all opportunities given to them.

Giving them more land to further isolate them from progressing along with the rest of the society certainly is not the answer.

I also agree whole-heartedly with Fuji on the band councils being corrupt and self serving

No we are not perfect either. Just remember as in anything else ... "corrupt and self serving bands" ... you only hear about the bad ones. The band to which I belong used money in the eighties to build a brick 'town hall' which serves as band center. The leaders now have a central place to work out of which is modern. It also has a small library and gymnasium/gathering hall.
 
It is also worth noting that any Indian I have met who was well educated, successful and generally a productive member of society usually 1) Didn't live on reserves, or at least go away from them as soon as possible and 2) Usually expressed quite a bit of contempt for those who do live on the reserves and squander all opportunities given to them.

Oh yes, this is a very good point. I was raised in this city. I have never lived on a reserve(though I spent some summers there). I look at them and they see me as different. Being on the inside on many things I have a unique perspective, outsider/non-Native see Native Reserves as land given to us, while to the people on these lands, back then, were forced into the "concentration camps". Now it has just become a way of life for the ones who stay or go back after finishing school.
 
No, you are applying the wrong law, that is not true in cases of sovereignty: The dispute is whether or not the Canadian system even has jurisdiction over the land. It's not a question of title--they are not claiming that they own the land, they are claiming that they have sovereignty over the land.

If it is sovereign native land there are no transactions under Canadian law, nor any series of transactions under Canadian law, that can change that: Canadian law, in that case, does not apply.

The problem is that we sort of have jurisdiction over the land. If the Indian tribes were really sovereign, then we would erect border posts at the edge of all the reserves, and treat them as foreigners. Department of Indian Affairs would not give them a penny that wasn't specified in a treaty, and if Canada failed to live up to its international commitments, the Indians would have the same options as every other sovereign country, which is not much unless you want to risk war.

The problem was that the Indians requested wording to the effect of: "that you can ask the Canadian Government to include the original peoples as full participants in the Canadian Parliamentary process and ask the Canadian Government to entrench Indian Treaty and aboriginal rights in Canada's new constitutional arrangements." Effectively, this position makes Indians both sovereign and Canadian at the same time, unless a treaty was signed. If a treaty was signed, the drafters of the treaty could never have envisioned modern Canada, so it is often not obvious how the treaty would apply in modern times.

This was eventually incorporated into the Charter of Rights and Freedoms as:
25. The guarantee in this Charter of certain rights and freedoms shall not be construed as to abrogate or derogate from any aboriginal, treaty or other rights or freedoms that pertain to the aboriginal peoples of Canada including

(a) any rights or freedoms that have been recognized by the Royal Proclamation of October 7, 1763; and
(b) any rights or freedoms that now exist by way of land claims agreements or may be so acquired.

Effectively, this left everything unspecified, and the courts adopted the position that it could only be solved through negotiation. The fact that the federal government has jurisdiction over Indians are under "Indians, and lands reserved for the Indians" just further complicates things. For instance, if Indians are under federal jurisdiction, and health care, welfare, and education are provincial responsibilities then why does the province owe Indians anything? Why is the province involved in Indian Affairs? Why are the OPP even at Caledonia?

Everything that goes near an Indian Land claim is immediately subject to: "All Canadian Laws apply, except when as per the Charter of Rights and Freedoms they don't." The legal grey area is huge, and anyone having any property in or near any litigated zone has a real problem. If the land claim goes past Caledonia, then significant population centres including Cambridge and Waterloo are affected. Shouldn't the government actually know what is going on?
 
The problem is that we sort of have jurisdiction over the land.

Assuming their treaty claim is correct, in a word, no. Not as far as land title is concerned we don't.

If the Indian tribes were really sovereign, then we would erect border posts at the edge of all the reserves, and treat them as foreigners.

I suggest you educate yourself on the status of natives in Canada and the treaties we have with them, so that you don't embarass yourself with this sort of ignorance again. It really would help you to be better informed.

The rest of your post appears to be stuff you made up on your own because it's how you assume things should work, rather than any actual reference to the law and treaties as they exist.

It's true that the treaty drafters never envisioned modern Canada. It's equally true that the natives never envisioned modern Canada when they signed away most of their land.

How should one interpret your position here? Are you saying the treaty should be ignored, and all the land in the entire country returned to the natives? Or are you saying the treaty should be ignored only when it means that the natives lose something?

Why should only the natives suffer from the failure of either side to envision modern Canada at the time the treaty was drafted? Especially given that the treaty as, in most cases, simply forced on them, without their fully understanding it?

After having forced a treaty on them, for us to turn around and say they conned us is a bit much.
 
I suggest you educate yourself on the status of natives in Canada and the treaties we have with them, so that you don't embarass yourself with this sort of ignorance again. It really would help you to be better informed.

If you had land near Caledonia, you would be asking if you owned the land and if anyone knew for sure too. Most of my references are to primary source research material.

It took me a long time to figure out what the issue with Canada and Natives is. Why are there no clear rules?

The quick answer is that natives are both Canadian citizens and have special negotiating rights with the federal government at the same time. In effect, they achieved the "sovereign nation inside a united Canada" status that has so far eluded Quebec. They have a special status afforded by the Canadian constitution, and no one knows the specific consequences. That is what the "resolved through negotiation" means.

My point is this: there are no rules. You might not own that piece of land that the government says you own, or you might, maybe.
 
I worked directly with a guy from Six Nations back a few years ago. He was a very solid guy and very skilled at his job. I have allot of respect for him. He was very active in the band in organizing sports for the kids to keep them focused and out of trouble (his words, not mine). He was a good guy in my books, as were his buddies from the Rez (except one - he was nuts, but there's always one in every bunch.)
 
Rather than ask for another group to be treated like shit,
I would prefer for the government to stop treating me like shit.

A truly brilliant and insightful comment.
 
If you had land near Caledonia, you would be asking if you owned the land and if anyone knew for sure too.

If the natives are correct then once upon a time the govenrment assigned false title for that land to someone, and the problems the developers have today stems from that error. In that case the fault lies with the government, not with the natives.

My point is this: there are no rules. You might not own that piece of land that the government says you own, or you might, maybe.

Which is just another way of saying that the dispute is ongoing and the status of that land has not been resolved.

One point that is not often mentioned is that the developers were well aware of the native claim when they bought the land. They took on the risk that has exploded in their face willingly.

I do think the government should step in and purchase all the disputed land, but given that these guys knew what they were buying, perhaps not at the price they're expecting.
 
Just for some humour before the HST Steamrolls over us: If it wasn't funny enough that Flaherty's for it and signing the 'can't cut it for two-years' deal while his wife and her PC Leader Hudak bitterly denounce it as a baaaad thing, along comes the Two Stoges Sit-In.

Murdoch shows up prepped to pee in a bottle wearing his kilt and orchestrates his own ouster from the Leg. He's then joined by Hillier who ran against Hudak on his record of denouncing—wait for it—illegal sit-ins by First Nations groups, and "why don't the police arrest the sitters who are blocking decent law-abiding citizens". That'd be the Caledonia tie-in.

There hasn't been this much stupid foolishness by Ontario pols since the NDP minister took a lie detector test to keep her job by proving she lied.
 
Last edited: