Common senses should prevail in this case...
Fuji, I bet you'll feel differently if you own that store and everyday people just walk in and steal your very livelihood right before your own eyes and you can't do anything about it. Just as you said, everyone has "basic" rights, if you steal from the store and prevent him making a living, his right is violated as well. Does anyone protect him? NO!
I see the whole police system should be in court here. If they are doing their job right, none of this will happen. They feel stupid and frustrated and take it out on the store owner.
I agree w/ your point that the store owner does not get rights to stop anyone or even harrast him. If he's got the wrong guy (eg an innocent guy), he should be charged as in this case, no argument here.
So by stopping anyone, he's risking the charge of been charge of "kidnapping". But if he got the criminal (eg, proven in court), then this changes the whole picture. He is the hero that stops the criminals. I would go as bat-man but in similar spirit.
You are quoting the law as on paper and that's just wrong. You have to put the law in a context and what makes sense. The law is fine. YOu just have to interpret and implement the law with a human mind and no just literally like a computer. Anyone said the store keeper is wrong and the thief is right should have the mind checked.
Fuji, I bet you'll feel differently if you own that store and everyday people just walk in and steal your very livelihood right before your own eyes and you can't do anything about it. Just as you said, everyone has "basic" rights, if you steal from the store and prevent him making a living, his right is violated as well. Does anyone protect him? NO!
I see the whole police system should be in court here. If they are doing their job right, none of this will happen. They feel stupid and frustrated and take it out on the store owner.
I agree w/ your point that the store owner does not get rights to stop anyone or even harrast him. If he's got the wrong guy (eg an innocent guy), he should be charged as in this case, no argument here.
So by stopping anyone, he's risking the charge of been charge of "kidnapping". But if he got the criminal (eg, proven in court), then this changes the whole picture. He is the hero that stops the criminals. I would go as bat-man but in similar spirit.
You are quoting the law as on paper and that's just wrong. You have to put the law in a context and what makes sense. The law is fine. YOu just have to interpret and implement the law with a human mind and no just literally like a computer. Anyone said the store keeper is wrong and the thief is right should have the mind checked.
Last edited:

