WTF is wrong with our laws......

Common senses should prevail in this case...

Fuji, I bet you'll feel differently if you own that store and everyday people just walk in and steal your very livelihood right before your own eyes and you can't do anything about it. Just as you said, everyone has "basic" rights, if you steal from the store and prevent him making a living, his right is violated as well. Does anyone protect him? NO!

I see the whole police system should be in court here. If they are doing their job right, none of this will happen. They feel stupid and frustrated and take it out on the store owner.

I agree w/ your point that the store owner does not get rights to stop anyone or even harrast him. If he's got the wrong guy (eg an innocent guy), he should be charged as in this case, no argument here.

So by stopping anyone, he's risking the charge of been charge of "kidnapping". But if he got the criminal (eg, proven in court), then this changes the whole picture. He is the hero that stops the criminals. I would go as bat-man but in similar spirit.
You are quoting the law as on paper and that's just wrong. You have to put the law in a context and what makes sense. The law is fine. YOu just have to interpret and implement the law with a human mind and no just literally like a computer. Anyone said the store keeper is wrong and the thief is right should have the mind checked.
 
Last edited:
Charging the shopkeeper doesn't surprise me. One of the most powerful unions in Toronto is the Toronto Policy Association. They don't like it when people do union jobs without being in the union.
 
The store owner should have broken the thief's arms, fuck calling the police and fuck a citizens arrest. Time to fight fire with fire or scum will take over, as they are now.
 
Know what this teaches us? CRIMINALS have MORE rights than VICTIMS.

BINGO! It's a cliche that many use, but now we have a real, clear example to support this.

Wow, I knew when I started this thread it might turn into left vs right, and opposing views, and it sure did that, lol. I was curious to read the number of differing opinions and it sure is entertaining. Regardless, it exposes some of the flaws of our so called legal system in our society. I think this law should be revisited, but that won't happen any time soon as it's too much of a hot, political potato.
 
BINGO! It's a cliche that many use, but now we have a real, clear example to support this.

Wow, I knew when I started this thread it might turn into left vs right, and opposing views, and it sure did that, lol. I was curious to read the number of differing opinions and it sure is entertaining. Regardless, it exposes some of the flaws of our so called legal system in our society. I think this law should be revisited, but that won't happen any time soon as it's too much of a hot, political potato.

Yeah, it will never happen. I find the political power people are too interested in taking the easy way out and NEVER take a stand for what's right, just what's politically correct. (and we all know putting poor underpriveledged criminals behind bars is SO not pc).

I don't know, it is almost as if it has become open season on the middle class. Tax us to death, tax our pleasures to death (booze and smokes), tax our homes to death, charge us and imprison us for protecting our property, take our hard earned money and hand it out to the lazy ass low lifes, and give us what? a bullshit home renovation tax credit (which is basically giving us our money back and making us jump through hoops to get it).
 
Man steals your property and you catch him, system says ~ 1 month: Man protects his property by catching you, system says if thief testifies protecting your property will get you possibly 2 years

I'm becoming a professional thief, it's a lot less risky and the pay is much better.:D
 
Just asking - how do bounty hunters stay within the law? They don't seem to have to wait for their quarry to commit a crime before their very eyes -- they just dive in and grab him. Does anybody know how that can be legal?

Why can't the shopkeeper be classed as a bounty hunter, rather than a vigilante?
 
It is of great benefit to every person in society to have this shop keeper made an example of, to have him pillioried to the extent that we can under law, so that no-one, and I mean *no* *one* walks around under the mistaken impression that they can deny another individual their most basic rights.
Why bother with an expensive trial when he has already been convicted by the Supreme Court of fuji? :p

They do want to make an example out of this guy to prevent him from setting a precedent but there is no way he will receive a sentence towards the upper end of the guidelines.

He could probably cut a deal by giving them a minor plea in exchange for a slap on the wrist but he seems to be on a crusade now along with many who are jumping on the cause.
It looks this show will not end soon.
 
They do want to make an example out of this guy to prevent him from setting a precedent but there is no way he will receive a sentence towards the upper end of the guidelines.

My expectation is a suspended sentence, on the grounds that he is (a) guilty and (b) a low risk to re-offend.

A suspended sentence, however, carries with it the clear message that it is in fact an offense. Discharging it, or dropping the charge, would carry the wrong message.

Anyone who cares about freedom should demand that there be a finding of guilt and a sentence of some sort--suspended being good enough to make the point.
 
The shopkeeper had 100% proof that this person was the one who ripped him off. The shopkeeper caught, detained, and handed over the CRIMINAL to the police.

If by that you mean the shop-keeper handed himself over I agree: The shop-keeper is the bigger criminal here. The shoplifer commited a relatively minor crime compared to the egregious crime of violence committed by the shop-keeper.

But go ahead, go on pooh-poohing fundamental rights that we all enjoy, just don't whine when it's your turn to be on the receiving end of a forcible confinement and an assault.
 
If by that you mean the shop-keeper handed himself over I agree: The shop-keeper is the bigger criminal here. The shoplifer commited a relatively minor crime compared to the egregious crime of violence committed by the shop-keeper.

But go ahead, go on pooh-poohing fundamental rights that we all enjoy, just don't whine when it's your turn to be on the receiving end of a forcible confinement and an assault.

No, you won't hear me complaining. Why? Because I know RIGHT from WRONG and if I am caught doing wrong? I won't complain...one BIT.

The thing that you dont' see fuji, and probably never will, that your biggest problem here is that you see the shopkeeper as the criminal. Even though you admit that the thief actually committed a crime (minor or not is 100% irrelevant) and eventually got caught.

So, I am wondering, if the thief resisted arrest, and the police were forced to shoot him, should the police be charged and arrested for murder? I mean hey, it was only a MINOR crime wasn't it?

Now, I don't know if the shopkeeper and his employees:
1) Roughed up the thief (and he IS a thief therefore a criminal)
2) Tied him up excessively tight
3) Kept him in the van for an extended amount of time.

If they "went too far" by doing any of the above? Yeah, they should be spanked for it. But if they didn't and are facing all these charges?

The "law" is telling the criminals that they have free reign. They can commit crimes at will and since we don't have enough police to respond to all calls immediately and investigate small crimes like THEFT that they will get away with it.

Furthermore, what this teaches CRIMINALS is that not only can they get away with their crimes the FIRST time, they can get away with going back to DO IT AGAIN and the VICTIMS cannot do a damn thing about it.

Put it this way: Someone steals your car. You see him do it. You take a photo of him doing it. You report it to the police and your insurance company. Your have to go out and buy a new car. Your rates skyrocket. As soon as you get the new car the SAME guy comes by and starts eyeing your NEW car. What do you do? Call the police and what 3 hrs for them to respond? The guy walks away.

The cops come, he isn't there.

The guy comes back after the police are gone, you see him again, you call the police and they don't respond for 3 more hours. They come, the guy has left.

Do you spend the rest of your life sitting by your car so the thief doesn't do it again or do you let him steal it again?

According to YOU, you let him take it.

So, you have choices: let the criminals do whatever they want and HOPE the police catch them, pay more taxes for more police. What do you choose?

Now there is a LOT about the US that I disagree with. But one thing I agree 100% with? Is a person's right to defend themselves and their property. Now the recent case where the trick or treater got shot for trespassing is taking it a little too far, but the person who did the shooting? got off scott free because he was defending his property.

Now we're jailing shopkeeper for simply grabbing and turning in a thief? And we have people like you not only for it, but adamantly for it?

I certainly hope you experience a crime. Then maybe you will see the other side of the coin.
 
you see the shopkeeper as the criminal

Last I checked forcible confinement was a pretty serious charge.

So, I am wondering, if the thief resisted arrest, and the police were forced to shoot him, should the police be charged and arrested for murder? I mean hey, it was only a MINOR crime wasn't it?

Nope, that's an entirely different situation. The police have the right to arrest someone based on suspicion. Citizens don't.

Now, I don't know if the shopkeeper and his employees:
1) Roughed up the thief (and he IS a thief therefore a criminal)
2) Tied him up excessively tight
3) Kept him in the van for an extended amount of time.

You're missing the point. They had no right to detain him. Period. End of story.

The "law" is telling the criminals that they have free reign. They can commit crimes at will and since we don't have enough police to respond to all calls immediately and investigate small crimes like THEFT that they will get away with it.

Wrong. If the shoplifter guy had actually been committing a crime the shopkeeper would have had every right to detain him. The problem is he wasn't doing anything wrong and yet he was assaulted and forcibly confined.

Furthermore, what this teaches CRIMINALS is that not only can they get away with their crimes the FIRST time, they can get away with going back to DO IT AGAIN and the VICTIMS cannot do a damn thing about it.

Wrong. If the victim of the assault and forcible confinement had actually been doing something illegal there would have been no charge against the shopkeeper.

Now there is a LOT about the US that I disagree with. But one thing I agree 100% with? Is a person's right to defend themselves and their property.

The law in the US is generally the same in this case. Citizens do not have the power to arrest others on mere suspicion. In the US, just exactly like in Canada, you generally have to witness someone in the act of committing a crime right in front of you at that moment in order to perform a citizen's arrest.

Vigilantes are illegal in both Canada and in the United States.
 
The law in the US is generally the same in this case. Citizens do not have the power to arrest others on mere suspicion. In the US, just exactly like in Canada, you generally have to witness someone in the act of committing a crime right in front of you at that moment in order to perform a citizen's arrest.

WRONG. The thief in this case would have been trespassing on the shopkeeper's property therefore he would have been in his right to shoot him.....

The thing you keep glossing over is the fact that the shopkeeper had PROOF 100% that this guy committed a crime against him. Video tape is PROOF.

The "escape clause" that you keep referring to is the "catch them in the act" which (as I've pointed out is nothing but a clause). This does NOT negate the fact that the thief had, and was possibly going to commit, a crime against the shopkeeper. You keep forgetting that fact.

Again, I hope, no I PRAY, that you experience being a victim. Once that happens maybe you will change your tune. I also pray that whomever commits the crime against you gets off on a technicality. As you said about me: then maybe you'd be whining about criminal's rights superceding those of the victims.

THE SHOPKEEPER WAS AND IS ALSO A VICTIM OF THEFT and now the Legal System is making him a victim again! You keep harping on how the thief was the victim. As with the police cases that come up here: who created the situation? The shopkeeper certainly didn't. He was simply trying to earn a living to feed himself and his family. The employees? they too were doing nothing illegal. Then along comes a CRIMINAL who commits a crime against the shopkeeper and then gets caught. Now the SHOPKEEPER has to spend time and money defending himself.

You keep harping on rights. We have the RIGHT to live in a crime free society and have the RIGHT to protect ourselves and our property. Just because we didn't catch the criminal the FIRST time doesn't mean we have to allow ourselves to be victimized again. BTW: I 100% disagree that criminals have the same rights as victims do.
 
WRONG. The thief in this case would have been trespassing on the shopkeeper's property therefore he would have been in his right to shoot him.....

LOL. It's a store open to the public. You can't just shoot anybody who wanders into your open store and call it trespassing.

I really wonder sometimes whether you have all your mental faculties available to you.

The thing you keep glossing over is the fact that the shopkeeper had PROOF 100% that this guy committed a crime against him. Video tape is PROOF.

First, you're wrong. It could have been somebody else on the video tape. Second, only a judge/jury is entitled to determine whether or not it really proves anything--up until that verdict comes down it is evidence. Third, even if it is very strong evidence that is POLICE WORK, private citizens are not allowed to arrest based on suspicion.

Let me repeat that agian in case you missed it:

Private citizens cannot arrest based on suspicion.

Let me put it another way in case you still don't get it:

Only the police are allowed to arrest based on suspicion.

The "escape clause" that you keep referring to is the "catch them in the act" which (as I've pointed out is nothing but a clause). This does NOT negate the fact that the thief had, and was possibly going to commit, a crime against the shopkeeper. You keep forgetting that fact.

You are possibly going to commit a crime against me. I have proof. So I am going to shoot you.

Whoops what? A judge says my proof isn't good enough? OK I will send some flowers to your funeral then.

THE SHOPKEEPER WAS AND IS ALSO A VICTIM OF THEFT

Sure. He is also the perpetrator of a violent crime.

The shoplifter is guilty of shoplifting. He is also the victim of a violent crime.

You keep harping on how the thief was the victim.

He absolutely was. You keep ignoring that there are two different crimes here, a minor one committed by a shoplifter, and a major crime of violence committed against him by the shop keeper.

The crown is correct in focussing their energies on the perpetrator of the more serious one.

who created the situation? The shopkeeper certainly didn't. He was simply trying to earn a living to feed himself and his family.

So what? I imagine the thief could say the same thing. You aren't entitled to break the law. Period. The shopkeeper, whatever his motives, committed a grave crime of violence.

The employees? they too were doing nothing illegal.

You are wrong. They also seem to have engaged in assault, forcible confinement...

Then along comes a CRIMINAL who commits a crime against the shopkeeper and then gets caught.

Again you're ignoring that the shopkeeper is the bigger criminal, who has committed the more serious crime.

You keep harping on rights. We have the RIGHT to live in a crime free society and have the RIGHT to protect ourselves and our property.

Yup, and one of those crimes that we have a right to live free of is being assaulted by idiots who wrongly suspect us of crimes.
 
In Canada you can not be arrested for possibly going to commit a crime. In this case the guy had committed a crime he was on video shoplifting he left and later returned to teh store and did it again. He left the store was chased down and held for the authorities , who up until this point had ignored the issue.

The shop keeper was entirely within his rights to pursue and hold the person for the authorities.

That said if the person turned out to be inocent of the charges the person who held him would be liable both criminally and civily for the abuse. That holds true for both the police and for people performing citizens arrests.

In this case the person has pled guilty to the shoplifting charge and has been sentenced. Any presumption of innocence is long past.

The police should have delt with this long ago, the person is well know to both the police and the local shopkeepers for his actions.

The charging of the shop keeper with an assortment of charges for protecting his property and his livelyhood is nothing more than the police overreacting to being embarased, the crown has already started the process of withdrawing all the charges. The first batch was to see if the public is going to want to keep this issue on the front page. Between this and the masterbating peeping tom they let go in St Catherines the crown has more than enough public relations problems on its plate .

As far as a trial goes I doubt this will ever get before a judge. The charges would be dismmised without the defense saying a word.
 
The shop keeper was entirely within his rights to pursue and hold the person for the authorities.

Incorrect. The shopkeeper did not apprehend him at a time that he was committing a crime, but instead played deputy dodge, and "arrested" him based on prior evidence, in other words, on nothing more than suspicion.

I put "arrested" in quotes because in reality there were no lawful grounds for a citizens arrest and therefore it was actually assault and forcible confinement.

In this case the person has pled guilty to the shoplifting charge and has been sentenced. Any presumption of innocence is long past.

Unrelated. The shoplifting plea related to events at a different time and are irrelevant.
 
LOL. It's a store open to the public. You can't just shoot anybody who wanders into your open store and call it trespassing.

And if someone is asked to leave and they don't? That's trespassing. Because no matter HOW you spin it: the store is privately owned and operated therefore OWNED by the shopkeeper and he has the RIGHT to refuse service and prohibit CRIMINALS from entering his premises.

Landscaper: I didn't now he was back in the store and committed the crime again. Are you sure? If this IS the case then Fuji, you are not only wrong, you are wrong on ALL counts.......

if the prosecutor doesn't dismiss the charges. I'm all for forming a protest calling for his removal from office.

If anyone wants to join pm me......
 
And if someone is asked to leave and they don't? That's trespassing.

He wasn't asked to leave. Even if he was, the only right there is to use whatever force is necessary to remove him from the property, not chase him down the street and then forcibly confine him.

committed the crime again

If that were true then yes the shopkeeper in that case would be entitled to arrest him. The basis of the charge against the shopkeeper is that this was not the case. If the shopkeeper can show that in fact he was in the process of committing a crime that is a valid defense to the charge.

You CAN arrest people you catch committing crimes.

You CANNOT arrest people you suspect committed crimes, no matter how must "proof" you have to back up your suspicion.
 
I am beginning to think Fuji is the shoplifter.