After endless pages of flaming, defending and offending, very little will change.
A new thread to discuss "Fight Club" will not change the attitudes of guys who believe they gain a little leverage, a little extra service by mentioning TERB. If someone thinks he might get BBBJ instead of CBJ by saying he will give a glowing review, or threatening a negative review, what we think of him is of little to no concern at that time. There are brutes out there, as can be attested to by one lady who was attacked this week. Our little round table will do nothing to persuade those who use TERB as a weapon.
Although there are many respectful men on this board, there are likely an equal or greater number of guys out there who want top service for bottom dollar. There are girls out there forced into giving extras to guys that they would prefer not to, to avoid a negative review. If anyone remembers T-bill's forum, that seemed to be their M.O.
Then there are the guys who take on the "Stockholm Syndrome" and try to ingratiate themselves to the point of the clarity of the review becoming a little out of focus. They like the girl, get along with her, start to think of her as a friend. They want to impress her with their review, and sometimes hope for a little extra next time they see her. Wanting the same thing as the brute, but trying a different approach. A little sugar rather than vinegar.
There was a time in the early days when TERB first arrived on the scene, when there were no ladies on the board. Once they started making their presence known, many of the guys were running around like little school boys, trying to impress them, vying for their attention. Again the line became blurred, the guys seemed to forget that they were paying for a service and started acting like they were dating instead. Of course the ladies loved it, why wouldn't they? Being treated with respect, having the guys acting like infatuated school boys.
At that point, TERB changed from being a stand alone entity to being a mixed function board. Fred realized the $$ value of having the ladies on board as advertising partners (Reviewers weren't paying for his bandwith) and the truly nonpartisan, objective reviews changed too. Some advertisers objected to negative reviews and the reviews were removed. A number of guys left the board in protest. The ladies remained an integral part of the board, and now it is difficult to imagine them not being on TERB.
However, it has become a double edged sword now. The guys realize that the ladies will be able to recognize them from their reviews, and don't want to jeopardize future encounters with the ones they like. They may unconsciously, or consciously, gloss over the weak points to the session, and talk up a regular session to make it sound like a stellar session. Many of the ladies will know a guy is from TERB due to advertising and booking through TERB. For the most part, we can't hide the "fight Club" from them anymore. They are part of it.
All the hand wringing and arguing will not change human nature. You may suggest that guys don't mention TERB to the ladies, but that is not going to stop anyone who sees it as an advantage.
I avoided using the word Shill, because I'm sure the guys involved don't see themselves as such. They are enjoying themselves and relating their encounters honestly. They may be reviewing through rose coloured glasses, but is that is because they are being treated differently as a result of TERB, or because of their positive personalities?
Whichever it is, it's not going to change anytime soon.