Yzerman or Sakic?

Suprapal

Member
Apr 1, 2017
113
24
18
Career points per game:

Yzerman - 1.16
Sakic - 1.19

Major Awards and Achievements:

Yzerman - one regular season MVP, one playoff MVP, One best defensive forward, ten-time all-star, five time 50 goal-scorer. six times 100 points or more
Sakic - one regular season MVP, one playoff MVP, twelve-time all-star, two-time 50 goal-scorer, six times 100 points or more

Yzerman began his career in the early 80s, Sakic in the late 8os. Because the 80s was an era of offensive fire wagon hockey, Yzerman had the advantage of racking up more points than Sakic. In other words, Stevie Y’s points totals are probably slightly inflated relative to Sakic’s.

I give the edge to Sakic on offense. On defense, however, Yzerman was the better all-around player. Yzerman probably better leader too.

On balance, Yzerman comes out on top. But this is a very close battle. Thoughts?