Younge Offenders Act

Cobster

New member
Apr 29, 2002
10,420
0
0
14 and up, name the fuckheads publicly.
Defending them till their 18 only enables them to do crime and not worry about who knows.
Fuck that shit.
 
Exactly.......there is no such thing as not knowing what you are doing and tghe real consequences of your actions....

If you do not know the difference or are unable to differentiate...then you should be placed in custody and go through therapy until you are 18 and then still have a record........
 
Children killing children. Their names should be released and they should be charged as an adult. My three year old grandson knows what guns can do. ( YES I know its the ppl with the guns, not the guns themselves.) He says bang bang (pointing his finger), papa fall down you got shot!
 
The young offenders act is nothing but a joke. :mad: These assholes should be charged as an adult and get the maximum sentence.
Our gutless gov. needs to reinstate the death penalty so the taxpayer doesn't have to pay to keep these scumbags in prison. The solution is simple, you kill someone, then your going to die too.
 
JessiMae said:
Actually it costs alot more to execute a person. Believe it or not, but think about the amount of appeals and the court costs alone.

I know an attorney in Texas, he tells me that executing someone is much more expensive then keeping them alive due to the millions of dollars spent on manditory appeals. It costs about 30K a year to keep someone alive in a prison.

dare I state my opinion....? Nah....

~jessi


Ah, but we streamline the process first.
 
gramps said:
The young offenders act is nothing but a joke. :mad: These assholes should be charged as an adult and get the maximum sentence.
Our gutless gov. needs to reinstate the death penalty so the taxpayer doesn't have to pay to keep these scumbags in prison. The solution is simple, you kill someone, then your going to die too.

Right. The justice system is never wrong is it?

If we lived by your brand of justice, what would you have said to the family of David Milgaard?
 
Death sentence is alright when there is zero doubt and DNA evidence (or a confession). Otherwise lock them up forever in a 'tent city' jail like that famous sheriff does in Arizonza. Prisoners build it themselves, eat cheap food, and have to work for their up-keep. Very cheaply done from what I understand.

Of course all the bleeding heart liberals will scream about treating those poor misunderstood unfortunate souls like that... :rolleyes:
 
JessiMae said:
Actually it costs alot more to execute a person. Believe it or not, but think about the amount of appeals and the court costs alone.

I know an attorney in Texas, he tells me that executing someone is much more expensive then keeping them alive due to the millions of dollars spent on manditory appeals. It costs about 30K a year to keep someone alive in a prison.

dare I state my opinion....? Nah....

~jessi


was just about to add that... mandatory appeals, red tape...its frikken expensive to kill em off.

I say make jail an unpleasant place to be....its too damn cushy....a lot of offenders repeat offend becuase not only are they animals but they find life in jail much easier to cope with than life as a free man (fucked up as it sounds)
 
Quest4Less said:
Death sentence is alright when there is zero doubt and DNA evidence (or a confession).

This is fine as long as you're prepared to give the justice system a death sentence when the case arises where it's wrong (which will inevitably happen, again).

Execution is a slippery slope. Once we begin to execute imperfections, where does it stop?

Quest4Less said:
Otherwise lock them up forever in a 'tent city' jail like that famous sheriff does in Arizonza. Prisoners build it themselves, eat cheap food, and have to work for their up-keep. Very cheaply done from what I understand.

This makes sense to me. The other advantage to this is that errors in justice can be corrected.
 
JessiMae said:
I disagree with the death penalty on a philosophical level.

On a non-philosophical level I think that the death penalty is an easy way out. Wouldn't you rather be killed then spend 40+ yrs (give or take) in complete and utter misery? Yah, some jails are rather plush and almost like resorts but most of the time they are not places to be. Think about the people you will spend your time with, and how many times you could be raped. Some people BEG to be executed because their prison experience is so fucked up.

I say let them rot in prison. Plus there is a good possibility that another inmate will do society a favour and take the job upon themselves to distroy such unsavoury people.

Either that or line them up execution style and just shoot. Do you really think these people who deserve to die should die humanely? Really, I am not for the death penalty myself, but I always question this when people say they think they should kill people off. Well if they deserve to die, why do they deserve to die like people's pets? A needle in the arm, what they call euthanasia is a painless way to die. Fuck the humane way!

or what about using them for experiments? could be quite helpful
 
Should depend on the seriousness of the crime, motive, and so on I think.

Should a kid have a life-long criminal record for assault for getting into a school yard fight at 15? For shoplifting? Sneaking into the neighbours house? I don't think so. I think kids who do those things may not understand what they're doing, and can be reformed well enough.

On the other hand, hunting someone down with a gun and killing them is in a different class. Seems like an adult crime to me. Treat them as an adult. Selling drugs for profit also seems a bit more adult--profit motive--not just fooling around.

Maybe we should have different ages for when a crime becomes adult, rather than just 18 for all crimes. Treat minor crimes as an adult only after 18, commercial crimes like selling drugs after 16, and serious crimes like pre-meditated murder after 14.
 
Cobster said:
14 and up, name the fuckheads publicly.
Defending them till their 18 only enables them to do crime and not worry about who knows.
Fuck that shit.

I agree, but they should only be named once their conviction holds up.

I don't think anyone regardless of age should be named publically until they are proven guilty. It is too easy to destroy someone's name with a bougus accustaion or wrongly motivated police investigation.

An exception would be if a very violent or habitual offender is released on bail, then the community should be warned. But the accused should have a choice between that option, or remaining in custody anonimously until the legal process is finished.
 
fuji said:
Should depend on the seriousness of the crime, motive, and so on I think.

Should a kid have a life-long criminal record for assault for getting into a school yard fight at 15? For shoplifting? Sneaking into the neighbours house? I don't think so. I think kids who do those things may not understand what they're doing, and can be reformed well enough.

On the other hand, hunting someone down with a gun and killing them is in a different class. Seems like an adult crime to me. Treat them as an adult. Selling drugs for profit also seems a bit more adult--profit motive--not just fooling around.

Maybe we should have different ages for when a crime becomes adult, rather than just 18 for all crimes. Treat minor crimes as an adult only after 18, commercial crimes like selling drugs after 16, and serious crimes like pre-meditated murder after 14.

Excellent point.
 
gramps said:
Our gutless gov. needs to reinstate the death penalty so the taxpayer doesn't have to pay to keep these scumbags in prison. The solution is simple, you kill someone, then your going to die too.

But only if it is mandatory for the jurors, prosecutor and investigating officers to also be executed for murder if an independent review some day the concludes they convicted the wrong person...
 
Mongrel4u said:
or what about using them for experiments? could be quite helpful

Isn't that what they are doing with the youth of today already with thier experimental depression drugs etc... I've been doing a lot of reading about the side effects of these drugs and sometimes I wonder if the effects are not worse than the cure. Maybe sometimes a child does have a serious depression problem mind you but from what I have read in some cases counselling may have worked better, but possibly they seek the quick fix and to push drugs for a large industry.

I wonder if this child was a medicated child or an otherwise seemingly normal individual.

Matters can be so complicated and if someone does kill someone I feel yes they should be dealt with, but no stones should be left unturned. ie... from parenting, to schooling, safely and to what all actions were being taken.

It does appear to me that there is more and more of these problems today and it does make me wonder why.
 
The YOA was drafted so that people under the age of 18 would not have to suffer for the rest of their lives if they made a bad decision once. Like getting caught smoking a joint, or doing a B&E etc.

As for the more serious charges, ie murder, the crown can elect to try the case as if the offender was an adult.

While we are constantly bombarded with media images of the YOA being a failure, the reality is that on balance is is good legislation.

Sure, it has created some problems, but all in all, it is better than have it than to create more professional criminals.
 
The Bandit said:
Rehabilitation, my ass...they know the difference of right and wrong.

Damn f'in right they do.
They should not only kick them in the ass with jail time (if they deserve it).
But take away some rights - ie - no driving for 2 years after you're released from jail. It's petty, but fuck'em.:)