You go, Wal-Mart!

tboy said:
As for working an 8 hr shift with no breaks, that's illegal under Canada labour law. I can't recall if it is 1 or 2 breaks required in addition to the 30 minute lunch but you are entitled to one at least.

Can't bothered reading any further in this thread but the labour law on breaks is that you are entitled to a 1/2 hour after 5 hours work. (which can be broken up into 2 15-min breaks if both parties agree
 
tboy said:
Hmmm employees having to work long hours w/o pay? So, why should the peons be any different than middle management?

I used to work a job where I averaged 60 - 70 hrs a week and was "paid" for 37.5 of those hours. I did that for years and advanced because of it. The reason I left is because instead of trying to form a project manager's union, I PERSONALLY decided my life was more than just working to get ahead.

This decade for me has been very busy in my trade especially in the energy sector which I prefer to work. I have worked countless 5x10 & 6x10 weeks and quite a few 7x10 as well.

A regular week is Mon-Thurs.

4x10=40

5x10=55

6x10=80

7x10=100

I'll take the cash tboy and you can have the title. Of course your company moved you up the ladder. They recognized (after years of you working for free :rolleyes: ) that they should move you up the ranks and take advantage of you even more than they were.

But congratulations on your title you earned for all the free hours you gave to your employer. I'm sure you were living like a rock star tboy compared to what you were before your advancement.

Now before all the usual ladder climbers and bag lickers in this thread start wagging their finger at me and calling me a greedy union bastard. Getting jealous now that I take home way more money than the majority of you all in this thread listen here. I am not unskilled labour. In our agreement with the power sector (that I am currently working at) all hours worked above 40 hours shall be paid at 2x the regular hourly rate.

This is not meant to reward workers for working overtime but to discourage companies from working us more than 40 hours per week. The high profile corporations (who are the clients of the various contractors that have employed me) would rather pay that premium because it makes more economic sense to get their facilities up an running making their millions sooner.

Most of the corporations that are the clients are free to to reward these multi million dollar contracts to non union contractors but they don't. They want the job done right the first time. They want quality work that the running shoe contractors can't provide. Downtime costs these companies potentially hundreds of thousands to a million per day for OPG if one of their reactors is down.

There is a lot of money floating out there to be had. If you don't take it someone else will.

The choice is yours.

Getting back to Wal-Mart I really couldn't care a less what they do... they're just a glorified dollar store.
 
tboy said:
Sorry, no. WITH unions that IS the story.…edit…
Read the example again: No union in the story. Its logic is pretty elementary, increasing any cost of production—wages in this case—requires an increase in price to keep profits the same. Of course no business is that simple, and as the `big government`s all bad/cut my taxes" folks never tire of repeating: "there`s lots of places to find money by eliminating waste", as just one alternate scenario.

Here`s another: Company`s doing nicely, products well made and selling as well or better than competitors`. Wages in same range as the industry. One day, owner doubles everyone`s wages. Workers overjoyed; productivity rises though not hugely because the plant was already pretty well run. Managers in the field, bankers and the like aghast and full of dire warnings of bankruptcy. Owner says, "Pooh, I`ll get all the best workers and build the best products, furthermore, now my workers will be able to buy them, so I`ll sell more, build a better plant and be even more efficient" Read the full story in any bio of Henry Ford (notoriously anti-union BTW).

Another: Company profitable, workers make $10,000/yr. Company seeks to increase profit by lowering wages. Turmoil on shopfloor, productivity drops, cuts into predicted savings. Prices cut to boost sales to compensate. Competitors match prices, and cut wages to balance. Everyone sells less because few of the reduced wage workers can now by the products. Depression

We all know more than we want about subprime mortgages and defaults these days. Essentially loans that shouldn`t have been made to folks whose real wages hadn`t risen for a decade—that`d be the entire American working class—perhaps having something to do w/ the decline in union membership over the period. Certainly having something to do with businesses competing by lowering wages, typically by offshoring production.

Combine those hungry-for-housing workers with a growing pool of profits accumulated over the same period, because the non-working class did well, some spectacularly so during the same period. Money looking for places to be invested meets mob of people wanting money to invest in homes. Missing? Only the financial alchemist who can convince everyone bad risks can be turned into good. And we got`im: His Philosopher`s stone this time: reinsurance, ABCP, and credit swaps. We`ve seen the outcome.

Longwinded as usual, but it comes down to this: Treating workers like shit and paying them as little as you can is bad business in the end, but works in the short term where most folks—and all the shysters—operate. What`s better for everybody, is treating everybody well. When you spread the wealth it`s a lot harder to make it all shink away at once. Duh!

Unions are just a way for workers to talk to a management that`s deaf to any voice but power. Managers can run a good company without a union, or a bad company with one, but it`s as stupid to blame unions for economic woes as it is to blame "running dog capitalists of the imperialist west". What makes the trouble is , "Me first and fuck the rest of you" and that`s an attitude found on both sides of bargaining tables.
 
Last edited:
dajodo2 said:
I am not unskilled labour. In our agreement with the power sector (that I am currently working at) all hours worked above 40 hours shall be paid at 2x the regular hourly rate.

This is not meant to reward workers for working overtime but to discourage companies from working us more than 40 hours per week. The high profile corporations (who are the clients of the various contractors that have employed me) would rather pay that premium because it makes more economic sense to get their facilities up an running making their millions sooner.
I agree with this and have no issues at all with it. You are right in every aspect. The union negotiated a great deal for you to get fair overtime for the hours that you work. I think that is wonderful. The point remains though that you have the choice whether to work the OT or not. If you do you are compensated accordingly, if you choose not to, no big deal.

You are right as well about your clients. I'm sure it DOES cost less to employ you than to have downtime. The debate here is more about unionizing unskilled labour and stifiling companies. IMO.
 
As for the examples given, and the BS comments about ball licking, there IS such a thing that is missing from the equation: Pride of work. Sure you can make x amount more than the next guy, sure you can brag all you want about your fancy clothes, but to me, I take and TOOK pride in the fact that the projects I was in charge of rarely went off the rails, the customers were overjoyed with the end results and in many cases, told the company that if I wasn't working on their projects, they'd go elsewhere (and in two cases, when I left the company, so did they).

Sure, for what I do now I could probably charge double but the REASON I have been busier than hell this year is because I believe in fair business practises and my client's realize that. See, the difference in my thinking and the union way of thinking is: I give equal work for equal pay. I don't pad my estimates, I don't hose them at every oppurtunity, if my costs come in lower than expected I give them a break in the final price. I also go that little extra step to make sure they are satisfied and in many cases, do a little extra off the clock. What is the result of working an hour or two for nothing? They keep calling me for projects. In many cases for $70.00 worth of time they've paid me $30K in business. PFG investment. Try to get a "union man" to understand that and he has a heart attack when you even mention the word "work without being paid".

In addition, yes, there are many companies who look at someone like me and say "how else can I abuse him to get more work out of him" and when one company started making me pay for my cell air time when I was away on business because the company cell didn't work in the US, I resigned.

I think the big difference between the way I think and the "union" mentality is that I was taught a very strong work ethic when I was young. I got my first job when I was 12. I was taught that one has to work hard to earn what they get and to never expect handouts. Totally opposite of many union people who are taught "work as little as possible for as much as possible".

As for construction trades unions. On all the sites I've worked at I never really had a problem with any of them. I think it was because the rules were very specific and were fair to both parties (me the customer and them the workers). Hours were set and were long enough to allow them to meet the schedule and due to contract, if the schedule wasn't met, the trade had to make up the difference.

The biggest hurdle was getting the various unions to work as a team and even two different companies, having the same union work for them, to get them to work together. For eg: the alarm company used union electricians to run their wiring. Then we had another company who was in charge of running the main wiring. They were constantly butting heads because one would run conduit from the front door to the electrical panel then argue about who was to connect the conduit to the panel...GRRRR Then another ran conduit and installed the quad boxes in the walk in closet and then the main wiring electrican would use that conduit to run the wire for the light, and the alarm guy would run the wires for the smoke detector, then they'd argue about who should put the cover over the quad box...GRRRR.
 
capncrunch said:

The key word in that story is "alleged". Not saying that it wasn't or isn't done, just saying if "it was proven" then that word wouldn't be needed. Makes me think that the settlement wasn't based on actual proof of the practices.

But then again, when I worked for a large Canadian retailer in the stock room there were many times a truck would arrive at a certain time and we'd unload it on our lunch hour, then just grab a sandwich when it was done. I feel that is part of being a dedicated employee.
 
Just cause you didn't care you didn't not get a lunch break doesn't make what the company did right.

Whats all this about unions and no work pride? Just cause a worker might be in a union doesn't mean he or her isn't a hard worker. Unions also make sure their workers obey the law. Down in Ohio, that "Joe the plumber" guy has no plumbers license and is not in any plumbers union. If he tried to join a union he would had first needed to get a plumbers license.

Unions believe in following the law and treating people fair, I see nothing wrong with that line of thinking.
 
Joe, just because I didn't get a lunch break doesn't mean what the company did was wrong either. I didn't suffer severe injury or death, I didn't die of starvation or have my kidney's shut down. I unloaded a truck and took a break afterwards cuz it needed to be done. END OF STORY. The difference between union and non-union mentalities is that in many cases, the non-union worker will actually do what needs to be done. The union worker will bitch and moan about it breaking x number of rules should he do it instead of just doing it (as the Nike ad says). My case in point is the trouble with putting the cover on the quad box is indicative of the situation. They spent more time bickering about who should do it than it would have taken to just do it. I eventually just grabbed a robbie screwdriver out of one's tool pouch, and installed it myself.

As for your plumber scenario, as I said, the trades unions have been pretty good and as for the union worker not having any job pride, in my experience the vast overwelming majority of union workers I've encountered do NOT give a rat's ass about what they are doing. Their only concern is what is best for them and how little they can do to get it.

Yes, I will repeat, I have met union workers who do their job well, and do take pride in their work. BUT, in most cases they were NOT union workers first, they were non-union and became unionized and in the cases in point, they regretted falling for the union spiel (because they told me so directly). Sorry, in my experience with unions, the vast majority of the workers were slackers looking for a free ride.
 
On the same issue....

How many union guys shop at Walmart?

I'll bet lots.

At the end of the day, a very large percentage of people make their purchasing decision solely based on price. Hence why Big Wally has done so well in the market place. I find it ironic that a lot of union types spend most of their shopping dollars at Walmat.

Kind of hypocritical.

You could have 2 IDENTICAL TVs side by side. One, made in North America, the other made in China at half the cost. Most people would buy the made in China one, including the Union Brothers.

Until that kind of behaviour stops (which is never), Walmart will continue to dominate.
 
Keebler Elf said:
And you wouldn't have that had there not been, and continue to be, unions. :rolleyes:

NO! Even though I work in the warehouse, we are open office hours...9-5. Nothing to do with unions!
 
Unions

It looks like you guys are attacking all unions that are manufacturing based but are avoiding the really powerful unions in Canada, teachers, police, fire, city, federal employees, provincial.
 
The Bandit said:
Don't get rediculous now...

Where I work it's 9-5 and get paid for 8 hrs, with 30 min lunch, but no breaks.



Uhhh ... you're joking right??? No breaks?
 
Jiffy Pop said:
It looks like you guys are attacking all unions that are manufacturing based but are avoiding the really powerful unions in Canada, teachers, police, fire, city, federal employees, provincial.

The misconception here is all unions are the same as those public sector unions you mention above. They aren't.

I am personally a member of one of Toronto's construction trade unions. Most of my jobs have been in private sector projects. Most of us are basically temps. We are dispatched from our halls or solicit on our own to contractors on a specific job site. When that job is done if the contractor has other jobs to transfer us to they will if they can (as long as you are deemed an asset also I might add). Most of the time they can't due to lag time between projects so you are layed off and wait for the next call at the hall to another contractor or again seek employment yourself.

There is no laying off by seniority. The good get keeped on 'till the end. The not so good are the first to go.

There is no severance pay, no buy outs. We are entitled to 2 hours notice that our services are no longer needed. The last two hours we go back to the hall and sign out on company time and are either dispatched to another contractor or are placed accordingly on the out of work waiting list.

Myself and most others in my field do put in an honest days work. We get an honest days pay as well. We do take pride in our craft. We have to in order to sell ourselves to clients against the non union sector.

I am compensated very well yes I agree. My work takes a toll on my body as well exposed to the extreme elements of heat and cold. Breathing in all the dust and whatever else is in the air. I work at a nuke plant quite often and I'm exposed to gamma and tritiated air inside the reactor in monitored metered exposures.

Just don't paint all of us with the same brush is all I'm trying to say.
 
Unions

I was not trying to paint all union people with the same brush like some people on here are. I have been on both sides of this and I do think that unions are sometimes good and sometimes the are not. I used to work in High tech and most of the manufacturing jobs ended up in china because because of low costs and the employees we had who built are products had per hour pay between 10 and 14 dollars and there was no union. Even if we cut salaries by a few dollars per hour it was still so much cheaper to produce in China.
 
dajodo2 said:
Just don't paint all of us with the same brush is all I'm trying to say.
Very valid point. Not all unions are created equal and have the same goals, and that does need to be noted. Not all union employees are bad either, most of them are excellent in my experience, do a fair days work for a fair days pay.

The problem being is that 'some of the unions' do not really have a decent grasp of economics, the job market, or finance in general. They exist for the sole reason to increase membership, as that is their way of making money. If a union were able to approach a company without scare tactics, and in a reasonable and logical manner by saying things like...

-We would like to help you reduce costs
-We are working on process improvements that will give your company a competative advantage
-We only want the best people for the job
-We will help in the training
-We are striving for a zero lost time record with our employees
-We understand that good working conditions are as important as pay to employees

If one could present that type of argument, and back it up with proof, a company might be more willing to have an open ear as it would create a win/win situation. The added costs of organization would be offset by the other factors involved. The problem for the time being anyways is that many of the unions still have the thug mentality. Pity really.