tboy said:
Sorry, no. WITH unions that IS the story.…edit…
Read the example again: No union in the story. Its logic is pretty elementary, increasing any cost of production—wages in this case—requires an increase in price to keep profits the same. Of course no business is that simple, and as the `big government`s all bad/cut my taxes" folks never tire of repeating: "there`s lots of places to find money by eliminating waste", as just one alternate scenario.
Here`s another: Company`s doing nicely, products well made and selling as well or better than competitors`. Wages in same range as the industry. One day, owner doubles everyone`s wages. Workers overjoyed; productivity rises though not hugely because the plant was already pretty well run. Managers in the field, bankers and the like aghast and full of dire warnings of bankruptcy. Owner says, "Pooh, I`ll get all the best workers and build the best products, furthermore, now my workers will be able to buy them, so I`ll sell more, build a better plant and be even more efficient" Read the full story in any bio of Henry Ford (notoriously anti-union BTW).
Another: Company profitable, workers make $10,000/yr. Company seeks to increase profit by lowering wages. Turmoil on shopfloor, productivity drops, cuts into predicted savings. Prices cut to boost sales to compensate. Competitors match prices, and cut wages to balance. Everyone sells less because few of the reduced wage workers can now by the products. Depression
We all know more than we want about subprime mortgages and defaults these days. Essentially loans that shouldn`t have been made to folks whose real wages hadn`t risen for a decade—that`d be the entire American working class—perhaps having something to do w/ the decline in union membership over the period. Certainly having something to do with businesses competing by lowering wages, typically by offshoring production.
Combine those hungry-for-housing workers with a growing pool of profits accumulated over the same period, because the non-working class did well, some spectacularly so during the same period. Money looking for places to be invested meets mob of people wanting money to invest in homes. Missing? Only the financial alchemist who can convince everyone bad risks can be turned into good. And we got`im: His Philosopher`s stone this time: reinsurance, ABCP, and credit swaps. We`ve seen the outcome.
Longwinded as usual, but it comes down to this: Treating workers like shit and paying them as little as you can is bad business in the end, but works in the short term where most folks—and
all the shysters—operate. What`s better for everybody, is treating everybody well. When you spread the wealth it`s a lot harder to make it all shink away at once. Duh!
Unions are just a way for workers to talk to a management that`s deaf to any voice but power. Managers can run a good company without a union, or a bad company with one, but it`s as stupid to blame unions for economic woes as it is to blame "running dog capitalists of the imperialist west". What makes the trouble is ,
"Me first and fuck the rest of you" and that`s an attitude found on both sides of bargaining tables.