York Subway extension

In the public sector, 99.5% of the time, low price gets the job. Giving the job to the second bidder invites a lawsuit. The only way low price does not get the job is if the low bidder makes a mistake in his tender document paper work and his tender is declared informal. If a contractor submits a correct tender complete with bid bonds and performance bond, and he is low, he gets awarded the job. End of story, every time.

Budgets increase because of errors in the tender documents, unforeseen complications, scope creep, claims etc. Tender prices are ALWAYS enforced as are deadlines. Every time. However, the second there is a mistake in the design, there will be an extra cost associated with that extra and it costs more. Which is why I said, if you don't have an air tight design, you're in trouble.

The street cars are a bad example my friend. There are 2 sides to that story. The only side the public ever hears is the City's whining. Bbd wisely keeps its mouth SHUT. But the other side of the story is that the spec that the city wanted was almost impossible to achieve. Frist, the new street cars are 100 feet long and then some. The city's street car tracks date from the early 1900's when street cars were 25' long. The new cars had to be designed to turn on turning radii of 30'. So you tell me, how do you get a 100 foot long street car to turn on a radius of 30'? Secondly, the TTC switches have only one switch point instead of 2. So again, how do you get such a massive car to turn without blowing right out of the turn-out? Third, add in 0 height floors, all the other communication requirements of the TTC which were one of a kind. In a nutshell, no-one in the world had a street car that met the TTC's requirements. What you see rumbling down the streets are unique to the TTC and the first of their kind. Fourth, the delivery schedule was IMPOSSIBLE. It was dreaming in technicolour for Santa Claus to give you a zillion dollars. The TTC just said, "we want it our way, we want it on our deadline, and we don't care about whether it's possible or not, that's your problem". I can put out a contract that I want my new house built in 2 weeks, doesn't mean I can realistically get it. BBD signed because if they didn't sign, their competition would sign and you'd still have the same problem. This is how it works.

If you're talking about the street car platforms on St. Clair, they were designed and built to the old street car specification long before they even dreamed up the new ones BBD is making.


The entire RFP process has evolved to be far more sophisticated than going for the lowest bidder. In fact, someone I know was unsuccessful in a bidding process with the City of Toronto recently and came in with the lowest bid.
 
The entire RFP process has evolved to be far more sophisticated than going for the lowest bidder. In fact, someone I know was unsuccessful in a bidding process with the City of Toronto recently and came in with the lowest bid.

No, it's low price gets the job every time. (For public works and infrastructure).

If your friend didn't get the job, he just needs to call the city and ask for a debriefing and they will tell him exactly why. (He may not have had the bonding, he may have submitted an informal (read incorrectly filled out) tender, he may have violated a city policy in his tender documents (like having a former City employee on the payroll involved in the project), he may have missed the closing cut off, he may not have met the fair wage requirement (read thou shalt be unionized). There are many reasons. It's very rare, but it does happen.

But the City and province and any other government body will NEVER EVER go with any other bidder other than the lowest simply because they like the No. 2 or No. 3 bidder better. That simply does not happen.
 
Can anyone tell me why this line even got built vs putting something thru to the end of Scarborough. After all isn`t it called the TTC? Why was a subway built to benefit Vaughn instead of Scarborough? My money is on corrupt politicians in the city and the province looking for votes in Woodbridge, because they could give a rats ass as to what happens in Malvern or Meadowvale in Scarberia. Wouldn't UofT's Scarborough campus benefit from a subway stop too?

Really?

This line got built because Vaughan is rich & Scarborough is ghetto

Part of the deal was to increase density (hence all those shiny new condos close to Vaughan stations)
This new subway is less useful than the last one they opened along Sheppard


Either way I would argue a subway extension from Square 1 (largest mall in ON, one of the largest in Canada) to Kipling would be a far better investment since density is much higher
 
We need a paradigm shift for how we design transit stations. Many TTC and GO stations are in the middle of nowhere that people have to drive to. Then people have to drive away from those stations to do shopping or other activities. They should be building plazas, commercial towers or condos directly above stations or at least above parking lots.
 
Really?

This line got built because Vaughan is rich & Scarborough is ghetto

Part of the deal was to increase density (hence all those shiny new condos close to Vaughan stations)
This new subway is less useful than the last one they opened along Sheppard

Presently York Region is the fastest growing in the GTA. Commuting was a nightmare for people living in Vaughan and beyond going into the city. It was also built at the demand of York University which wanted the same transit set up that U of T enjoys. There are two direct GO links into the York Line, at 407 and Downsview Park.
 
Presently York Region is the fastest growing in the GTA.

Not even close to where the subway is though
All that "York Region" growth can be attributed to MARKHAM which is nowhere near a subway line

Markham & Milton (also in GTA) are by far the fastest growing areas in the GTA
Vaughan is way down the list (behind many smaller places)
 
Markham is part of York Region.

The GTA is currently comprised of five regions: Halton, Peel, York, City of Toronto and Durham. York Region has eight Boroughs, Vaughan, King, Markham, Richmond Hill among them.
 
Markham is part of York Region.

The GTA is currently comprised of five regions: Halton, Peel, York, City of Toronto and Durham. York Region has eight Boroughs, Vaughan, King, Markham, Richmond Hill among them.

What part of "not even close to where the subway is though" did you fail to understand?

BTW York has 9 not 8 Municipalities (borough is a US division of State, not really applicable here?)
 
The new subway extension to Vaughan is a joke. There is no need for those two Vaughan stations,Highway 407 station and Vaughan Metropolitan Centre station. There should of stopped at Pioneer Village station. The only useful station I see is York University Station. The TTC should of helped there own city first than York Region. A small city like Vaughan does not need a subway. Ottawa is three times more populated than Vaughan and Ottawa does not have subway at all. Highway 407 station is a parking lot station. Vaughan Metropolitan Centre station looks like a underdeveloped city that not even finished yet. The TTC should of added more subway stations in Scarborough.
 
Manna from George Clooney's asshole! Some people sure get cranky at Christmas.

Not sure what you're arguing about? If Markham wanted a subway extension they should have paid for it. Large scale civic projects don't come cheap.

https://www.thestar.com/news/gta/transportation/2016/01/15/spadina-subway-extension-could-cost-an-additional-400-million.html

Just so long as we are both clear you threw in the towel and walked away with no actual facts

Your 2 claims were about density & about York having "8 boroughs" (you really forgot what you were arguing about or just want to pretend you did?)

People usually resort to personal insults when they have been shown to be fools
 
Why would I insult you? Do you take everything personally, don't be so sensitive...have no worry, never fear, Santa Claus will soon be here.

Not arguing with anyone, couldn't care less....Merry Christmas.
 
That's funny.

If I recall correctly, the City of Toronto and the Bob Rae government had agreed to build 4 subway segments. Sheppard, Eglinton, a lateral extension to York University, and replacing the Scarborough LRT. They were all on the books when Bob Rae was Premiere.

When Harris got elected round about 1995, he said that you can have 1 line only (there were only 2 choices - Eglinton, or Sheppard). You pick which one.

I remember watching the City Council debate on television. There was a lot of hemming and hawing, but the reality was that the province under Harris was only going to pay for one line.

So on one hand you had Mel Lastman, the powerful and popular mayor of North York pushing and politicing real hard for Sheppard.

On the other hand, you had Frances Nunziata, the newbie Mayor of the City of York (one of the smallest and poorest of the old cities of Metropolitan Toronto) and Doug Holyday, Mayor of Etobicoke (and a Progressive Conservative) and also a Newb.

Who do you think was going to win that fight? That's right. Uncle Mel. Mel was a tough politician who despite his sometimes clownish demeanor truly did know how to get things done and how to out maneuver his opponents. Frannie never had a chance. It was totally illogical to build Sheppard as opposed to Eglinton. But they built Sheppard. So go figure.

Rumor was that Lastman had told all his developer buddies to speculate on Shepppard because they were going to build a subway and their land values would skyrocket. When it looked like Sheppard was going to get shit canned (which would have been logical), supposedly Lastman's same developer buddies literally threatened him with death if Sheppard didn't materialize. It was crazy stupid to have built Sheppard. To this day, I wonder who greased who on council to get that vote to go build Sheppard.

BTW, the Eglinton LRT is being built as an LRT, however, the tunnels and stations are being built so that they can be converted to subway in the future. A subway will eventually replace the LRT on Eglinton.



Did not know that. Amazing what forward thinking can do -- like the Bloor-Viaduct being designed to carry a railway long before a subway was ever built. And eventually.....long after we are gone...future generations get to benefit from it...like we have to thank those who paid for the original Yonge line from Eglinton to Union. Curious if they will ever excavate any of the buried street car lines.....the existing system is about half of what it once was but TTC simply paved over them. And isn't Bay/Yorkville still an interchange station (albeit one that only has the upper level open)?
 
Did not know that. Amazing what forward thinking can do -- like the Bloor-Viaduct being designed to carry a railway long before a subway was ever built. And eventually.....long after we are gone...future generations get to benefit from it...like we have to thank those who paid for the original Yonge line from Eglinton to Union. Curious if they will ever excavate any of the buried street car lines.....the existing system is about half of what it once was but TTC simply paved over them. And isn't Bay/Yorkville still an interchange station (albeit one that only has the upper level open)?

Queen for sure, and possibly Osgoode have another level.
 
The new subway extension to Vaughan is a joke. There is no need for those two Vaughan stations,Highway 407 station and Vaughan Metropolitan Centre station. There should of stopped at Pioneer Village station. The only useful station I see is York University Station. The TTC should of helped there own city first than York Region. A small city like Vaughan does not need a subway. Ottawa is three times more populated than Vaughan and Ottawa does not have subway at all. Highway 407 station is a parking lot station. Vaughan Metropolitan Centre station looks like a underdeveloped city that not even finished yet. The TTC should of added more subway stations in Scarborough.

Political meddling is the reason why we have a subway to a Walmart parking lot in Vaughan and all the other costly mistakes like the Sheppard line. Greg Sorbara who's riding was in Vaughan was the biggest promoter of the extension. Clearly, the line was yet another Liberal vote buying exercise. The funding of the line was basically contingent on having it cross the Toronto / Vaughan border.
 
Did not know that. Amazing what forward thinking can do -- like the Bloor-Viaduct being designed to carry a railway long before a subway was ever built. And eventually.....long after we are gone...future generations get to benefit from it...like we have to thank those who paid for the original Yonge line from Eglinton to Union. Curious if they will ever excavate any of the buried street car lines.....the existing system is about half of what it once was but TTC simply paved over them. And isn't Bay/Yorkville still an interchange station (albeit one that only has the upper level open)?

Bay used to be an interchange station way back when. The idea was that trains would be able to move from the Bloor line to the Yonge line without passengers having to transfer. They close down the Bay lower station since it was confusing. They only use Bay Lower for TTC training, film shoots. It was open to the public during Doors Open.

As for forward thinking, Sheppard-Yonge was way overbuilt. The center platform is not used so the station can handle a lot more people.