Yet another questionable police shooting

nottyboi

Well-known member
May 14, 2008
27,814
5,492
113
http://thestar.com/news/gta/article/703910

Ok so the police did not write their notes until they consulted a lawyer. Shouldn't the law society review the various versions to ensure the lawyer was not suborning perjury.... also no mention if the suspect was armed. If he was not armed, the officers should at the very least be charged with excessive use of force and they should face cross examination. What woeful lack of oversight.
 
You love getting all indignant about percieved police misbehaviour, don't you?
 
You love getting all indignant about percieved police misbehaviour, don't you?

"Percieved police misbehaviour"? You are friggin' kidding me, right?
Not writing your incident notes until your lawyer reviews and approves them?
I'm no lawyer, but if the victim survived and there was a trial, an indescretion like that would probably have resulted in dismissal of any charges.
 
And then some try to make people feel guilty about not answering the police questions without a lawyer with them :rolleyes:
 
And then some try to make people feel guilty about not answering the police questions without a lawyer with them :rolleyes:


Lets not confuse people with police, people generally don't walk around with loaded firearm nor do they have the authority to lay criminal charges. Police killed this man and are not prepared to give an honest account to the public and his family about why their father/brother/son is dead. IMHO this is really a compelling reason to make police wear personal video/audio recorders with shoulder mounted cams. Cams would be mounted on the favored arm for firearm usage. This would protect the public AND honest officers.
 
You love getting all indignant about percieved police misbehaviour, don't you?


No I hate it, but it surprises me how many people are perfectly comfortable to see their civil liberties be stripped away. Even more surprised when it is on a forum to discuss paid sex which is in a very grey area legally. How would you feel if some vigilante cop beat you to a pulp having found you in an incall. I suppose that would be ok with you??..I know you won't report it and so do they....
 
I don't blame the cop for consulting a lawyer first. Every thing they do these days is scrutinized every which way. And I don't believe cops are out for thrill kills.
 
You love getting all indignant about percieved police misbehaviour, don't you?
Not only that Notty accuses the Lawyer for the Ontario Provincial Police Association of suborning perjury and of violation of the cannon of ethics. There are many times when it is a great thing that this is an anonymous board.
 
I'm not saying they don't have to answer for this, they should. But knowing that someone died and that fingers will be pointed, I don't blame them for consulting a lawyer. They too have to protect themselves from legal career killing lawyers looking for payouts any way they can get them.
 
No I hate it, but it surprises me how many people are perfectly comfortable to see their civil liberties be stripped away. Even more surprised when it is on a forum to discuss paid sex which is in a very grey area legally. How would you feel if some vigilante cop beat you to a pulp having found you in an incall. I suppose that would be ok with you??..I know you won't report it and so do they....

Man, you sure are a drama queen. D oyou really think your civil liberties are being 'stripped away'?
 
Man, you sure are a drama queen. D oyou really think your civil liberties are being 'stripped away'?

Are you really that idiotic? Of course they are. I suppose you'll be ok about being killed and having your death covered up?
 
make police wear personal video/audio recorders with shoulder mounted cams. Cams would be mounted on the favored arm for firearm usage. This would protect the public AND honest officers.


Ha, we can't even get every police car to have dashboard cameras. In Detroit less than 50% of the cars have them. (and the ones that do might not be working)

In the US police shootings are far more common and when they do shoot its 10 rounds or more. Not sure of the numer of people kill by police every year but it is up there.

This is were in Europe its far better, many officers don't even carry a gun.
 
Published on Sunday, April 29, 2001 in the New York Times

When the Police Shoot, Who's Counting?

by Fox Butterfield

WE like to think we live in the information age, when daily or even second-by-second statistics on such fare as stock prices and the annual number of homicides are at our fingertips. For all the careful accounting, however, there are two figures Americans don't have: the precise number of people killed by the police, and the number of times police use excessive force.

Despite widespread public interest and a provision in the 1994 Crime Control Act requiring the Attorney General to collect the data and publish an annual report on them, statistics on police shootings and use of nondeadly force continue to be piecemeal products of spotty collection, and are dependent on the cooperation of local police departments. No comprehensive accounting for all of the nation's 17,000 police department exists.


The lack of good data is a national scandal.


This lack of accurate statistics makes it virtually impossible, experts say, to draw meaningful, big-picture conclusions about deadly encounters between the police and the civilian population, including the fatal shooting earlier this month of an unarmed black man in Cincinnati, an incident that incited days of violent protests and vandalism. Without a national barometer, there is no conclusive way to determine whether this or other incidents around the country like those involving Amadou Diallo in New York and Rodney King in Los Angeles represent racially based police misconduct, or any kind of trend at all.

The major reasons for the vacuum, the experts agree, are twofold. The lack of information on police shootings is attributable to the failure of police departments in many cities to keep and report accurate figures that distinguish between what the police see as "justifiable" shootings those in which the suspect posed a serious threat and incidents where an officer may have unlawfully fired at an unarmed civilian.

The International Chiefs of Police, a police organization, tried in the 1980's to collect such information, but "the figures were very embarrassing to a lot of police departments," said James Fyfe, a professor of criminal justice at Temple University who is a former New York City police lieutenant. The results, he said, varied wildly. New Orleans had 10 times as many shootings per 100 officers as Newark. Long Beach had twice as many as neighboring Los Angeles, which in turn had three times more than New York.

Some cities did not provide data at all, Professor Fyfe said, but the results, such as they were, showed that "the rates of deadly force are all over the lot," meaning that some cities appear to be much better and some much worse at managing their police forces.

As for the lack of figures on the use of nondeadly force, the situation is even murkier because there are no uniform definitions of force and no standard reporting requirements from one police department to another.

The Bureau of Justice Statistics, the statistical arm of the Justice Department, has tried to fill in some of the blanks on police behavior, issuing a number of surveys and reports on the topic. Most recently, the bureau quietly released a report, "Policing and Homicide, 1976- 1998." But the report itself underscores the continued problems in knowing what is really happening.

On its cover, for example, the report refers to all the victims of police shootings as "felons justifiably killed by police," a categorization that Samuel Walker, a professor of criminal justice at the University of Nebraska at Omaha, termed "deeply offensive and legally incorrect." In fact, a Justice Department official said the bureau was so embarrassed by the term, and the lack of distinction between justifiable police shootings and murders, that it did not send out its usual promotional material announcing the report.

BUT, the official said, the bureau was trapped because it depends on local police departments to report their figures on police shootings to the Federal Bureau of Investigation, and "felons" is the term that police departments insist on using when they do so.

Making matters worse, some police departments fail to report their shootings at all, and for some years, figures from entire states are missing. Although the 1994 crime act ordered the Justice Department to collect such data, there is no law requiring local police departments to provide it, Janet Reno, the former attorney general, acknowledged in a 1999 speech.

Based on the data available, this most recent report suggests that the number of "justifiable" police killings has not increased since 1976, averaging 373 a year, despite a growth in both the population and the number of police officers. And while the rate at which blacks are killed by the police still far surpasses the rate at which whites are shot and killed, it has dropped to four times the white rate in 1998 compared to eight times in 1976.

But the report also acknowledges its own limitations. "One statistic that is impossible to obtain" from the Justice Department's database, it said, "or from any other currently existing database, is the number of murders by police," because in reporting their shooting figures, the police don't distinguish between justified and unjustified killings. The report also fails to break down the number of police shootings by city, unlike other Justice Department reports on crime, making it impossible to compare police performance.

The lack of good data "is a national scandal," said Geoffrey Alpert, a professor of criminology and criminal justice at the University of South Carolina and a leading authority on police use of force. "It's a scandal in the sense that these are public servants who work for us and are paid to protect us."
 
So let's imagine the police did nothing wrong after the incident, and that any citizen accused of shooting an unarmed man could do the same—have a two-days at liberty while they consult with their lawyer to write and re-write their version of what happened. What kind of justice system would that make for?

Or let's imagine that the poice did nothing wrong but only the police get to behave that way—shoot an unarmed man and refuse to answer any and all questions from investigaters for two days until they and their lawyer have written and re-writen their story. What kind of law enforcement would have that SOP?

Either way this one stinks. It isn't about taking apples from a fruit stand; it's someone being killed by our sworn peace officers and how we deal with it. If those cops are that fearful of being investigated (and have so little trust in the justice system), they should take the old advice about getting out of the kitchen and find other work.
 
Are you really that idiotic? Of course they are. I suppose you'll be ok about being killed and having your death covered up?

My civil liberties are doing quite nicely; I was exercising them the other day! Your life must be very exciting, with all the secret police coming to kill you and such. How I envy your passion. Fight the power, dude!!

Or, you may just be a giant drama queen who takes things to ridiculous conclusions.
 
Hangman so far you're the drama queen inventing secret police fantasies and all. If you think the story as we know it is fine and dandy—the union lawyer being first to get the facts and our sworn investigators only getting what she chooses to reveal—please do tell us how we keep our cops on the staright and narrow.

Simple outline, no creative writing required.

BTW: isn't it surprising the anti-union TERBoids aren't all over this one?
 
I just don't think it's such a big deal. The officers in question have the right to legal counsel. If there is sufficient cause to charge them, they will be charged. Then, under oath they can be questioned. IF they lie, they go to jail. If they are guilty, they go to jail.

What I object to is the shrill demands by armchair quarterbacks that these police and all involved (lawyers, etc) be punished prior to the establishment of guilt. I also object to nottyboi's assumption thatI am an idiot becase I don't subscribe to his paranoid fantasies. Did you actually read all the posts, oldjones? Nottyboi sugested that I would be killed by the police and my death covered up. That's where the drama-queen hysterics started. I think his life must be very exciting, because he sees this conspiracy and such everywhere he goes. How fun!!

My life is boring by comparison. I think the system works pretty good. I'm going to go exercise my civil rights today, and I have no fear that the police will interfere. NONE.

There are several layers of oversight on the police in this country, both on the police service itself and independent review panels. I find it highly unlikely that the are all involved in a coverup conspiracy.

You guys who just like to stir it up and assume the worst of the police are free to carry on, but I'm finished. Let me know next time there's an outrage miscarriage of justice, and I'll be glad to help out if the courts fail.
 
Only people who think they have committed a criminal act seek a lawyer before saying something, it's that simple.

You really think that? Wow.

I think that people who think that they may require legal representation in a complex jurisprudence system consult a lawyer.
 
you guys need to think about this

the Police are not gangstas!!! They do not go out intending to 'kill' anyone.


I am sure when you shoot somone, expecially the Police who have a sense of decency and a conscience, it is a very traumatic experience.


I want them to wait and write accurate notes. I want them to get over the 'shock' and trauma of KILLING someone.


I would not think notes, which the OP believes should have been written at the scene, would have a whole lotta validity to them..the guy I would think WOULD BE IN SHOCK!!
 
Or let's imagine that the poice did nothing wrong but only the police get to behave that way—shoot an unarmed man and refuse to answer any and all questions from investigaters for two days until they and their lawyer have written and re-writen their story. What kind of law enforcement would have that SOP?
.

Gee I read the story and no where in there does it say that the man was unarmed when he was shot. Jumping to "creative" conclusions just to suit your point of view again? You are the only one making things up so far so its comical that you accuse hangman of this. Hangman has a legitimate point.

BTW: isn't it surprising the anti-union TERBoids aren't all over this one?

Why do you say that ? Did they shoot someone for saying they had too many sick days ? Interesting that your mind went to this angle. Unlike the the pro-union group the rest of us don't regard everything in a pre-conceived manner.

They may very well be guilty but the facts aren't known. Certainly not by anyone here. You have only heard one part of one side of the story yet you find it convenient to declare guilt.

Predictible.