"yes, sir" an insult???

petitelover

International User
Jan 14, 2003
860
2
0
Planet Earth
I was speaking with someone and I said "yes, sir" - he said "don't call me sir or we are going to have a problem." My tone was proper (not sarcastic) and I was acknowledging him in a respectful manner. Am I missing something? In my book, "yes, sir" is a sign of respect. I should say the person on the telephone seemed to have lacked higher education. Does that have something to do with it? :confused:
 
It depends on the tone sometimes.

If you're saying it sarcastically, your intention is that you think the other person is pretentious.

In the military, drill instructors will tell you not to say "yes, sir" because "sir" implies that he is an officer, which he is not. He will say "I work for a living," implying that officers are college-educated paper pushers (fat cats).
 
It sounds like the person you were talking to does not like to be referred to as "sir". Is it because of his education? Who knows? Maybe he was just having a bad day. From what you said, it doesn't sound like you have had previous contact with him. Maybe he misread your tone. Or maybe he cringed when he said it and asked himself, "What an ass I am. Why did I say that?" But if you used the term without attitude, then you are right, it is a sign of respect. So don't call him sir anymore, or you'll have a problem.
 
where I grew up "yes, sir" and "yes, ma'am" were and still are common phrases. it doesen't matter if your talking to the gas station attendant or a cop - both work and no offence would be taken.

being up here for the last 25 years i could see how some young adult could take offence to it....maybe he thought you were being sarcastic and talking down to him in a way. who know....

just my .02
 
I would have had a really hard time not saying "no problem...asshole". :D
 
petitelover said:
I was speaking with someone and I said "yes, sir" - he said "don't call me sir or we are going to have a problem." My tone was proper (not sarcastic) and I was acknowledging him in a respectful manner. Am I missing something? In my book, "yes, sir" is a sign of respect. I should say the person on the telephone seemed to have lacked higher education. Does that have something to do with it?

You sure it was a dude? Hard to tell sometimes these days..... :D
 
baci2004 said:
I would have had a really hard time not saying "no problem...asshole". :D
LOL. Baci, you would do really well in sales.

DistantVoyeur said:
You sure it was a dude? Hard to tell sometimes these days.....
Ahh...now that would explain it. I never thought of that.
 
I have herd 'Yes sir' in a tone that could have been 'F@#k you A$$hole' used before. I personally do not trust most people who are overly polite because it seems like they are phony yes men. Genuine people treat you as an equal.
 
Sound like this guy was from a collection agency and they will say anything they can to intimidate you.
You were talking to someone on the phone and they said if you called them sir there would be a problem? what kind of problem is this guy going to cause over the phone??
mabey you could give us more information on the context of this phone conversation.
 
I am not a fan of being called sir either, makes me feel old. Always a challenge to figure the proper salutation though, I know most women detest Mame.

Hard not to use the stand buys like pal, buddy etc. which could also be insulting.
 
petitelover said:
I was speaking with someone and I said "yes, sir" - he said "don't call me sir or we are going to have a problem." My tone was proper (not sarcastic) and I was acknowledging him in a respectful manner. Am I missing something? In my book, "yes, sir" is a sign of respect. I should say the person on the telephone seemed to have lacked higher education. Does that have something to do with it? :confused:
To be blatantly politically incorrect as well as bluntly truthful. Indeed there are some "blue collar types" either by job or up bringing or both who have a "chip on their shoulder" about being called Sir. Ironically they are often the same people who have problems giving proper deference where it is due.
 
ig-88 said:
In the military, drill instructors will tell you not to say "yes, sir" because "sir" implies that he is an officer, which he is not. He will say "I work for a living," implying that officers are college-educated paper pushers (fat cats).
That was always one of my button pushers, as if in the later 20th early 21st centuries Commissioned Officers don’t “work”. NCOs/POs who act like this are stuck in the early 19th Century if it was even all that true then.
 
Sir...It's the proper thing to say when adressing a person of an older generation, a customer, a boss, or someone you are NOT on a first name basis with.
Children sould ONLY address adults with..Mom, Dad, Uncle/Aunt..Mr/Miss/Mrs/Ms.....Sir or Ma'am.

Rude little kids (who have parents who allow it) who call Adults by their Given Names, drive me nuts.
Every one is equal...but some are more equal than others.
 
Ditto!!!

Diode said:
Sir...It's the proper thing to say when adressing a person of an older generation, a customer, a boss, or someone you are NOT on a first name basis with.
Children sould ONLY address adults with..Mom, Dad, Uncle/Aunt..Mr/Miss/Mrs/Ms.....Sir or Ma'am.

Rude little kids (who have parents who allow it) who call Adults by their Given Names, drive me nuts.
Every one is equal...but some are more equal than others.

Man...sometimes we agree so much it is frightening!!

I was taught that someone older than you was Sir / Ma ' am until you knew here name, and then Mr or Mrs. ______ until they gave you permission otherwise. All of my mom's male "friends" through the years (she divorced my step dad pretty young and never remarried) were Mr. _______....including that last one who was around for like 10+ years (literally watched me grow up, and was like a stepdad to me).

My current "friend" has her kids call me by my first name, they call HER by her first name on occassion, and they refer to their very close aunt and uncle by first name as well. On top of that, they swear like sailors all the time, including the dinner table!! Drives me insane!!!

Mind you, they are both unbelievably good kids...the oldest is on all the sports teams at school and is on her way to McGill on a scholarship, the youngest isn't quite as bright but is an A / B student in one of the special programs for bright kids in the public school system (the oldest one goes to one of the most prestigious private schools in the city). Both kids have never been in ANY sort of trouble, are as polite as you could ever expect teenagers to be, help out their mom like crazy while they have been adjusting to their dad bolting on them, etc. Really, just the BEST kids.

But I swear....what she lets them get away with as a "liberal" parent....smh.

Then again, it does make you wonder about the value of such "rules" when two kids can obviously be such sweet hearts and well rounded...my friend says latitude and a lack of dominating control was a purposeful part of their upbringing...hard to argue with the results....
 
petitelover said:
I was speaking with someone and I said "yes, sir" - he said "don't call me sir or we are going to have a problem." My tone was proper (not sarcastic) and I was acknowledging him in a respectful manner. Am I missing something? In my book, "yes, sir" is a sign of respect. I should say the person on the telephone seemed to have lacked higher education. Does that have something to do with it? :confused:

My initial feeling is that you were being sarcastic and/or condensending and hence the comment.

Otherwise it would be an irrational comment from that person.
 
Anderson said:
My initial feeling is that you were being sarcastic and/or condensending and hence the comment.

Otherwise it would be an irrational comment from that person.

Nope, not at all. I generally call men "sir" as a sign of respect and women "ma'am" as a sign of respect. I say it in a VERY respectful manner and never condensending. This has happened on several occasions with men, mostly uneducated.
 
"Sir" and "Ma'am" are polite, respectful terms of address. Others have elaborated on this already, so I won't. (But kids calling mr by my first name bugs me a LOT).

Courtesy and respect go both ways. You were right, and the guy who responded with this bizarre threat "don't call me sir or we are going to have a problem," responded incorrectly and impolitely.
 
DistantVoyeur said:
You sure it was a dude? Hard to tell sometimes these days.....

Tell me about it! I was on the phone once making a business call and got a rep. Towards the end I said something to the effect of "Could you tell me when....... Sir??" The response I received was: "My name is Tina, and I'm not a sir!" :eek: