WW II - What Ifs?

SkyRider

Banned
Mar 31, 2009
17,546
2
0
The History Channel is running a series of programs on WW II leading up to Remembrance Day. For the history buffs on the board, here are some what ifs questions?

1) What if the escape from Dunkirk was an unmitigated disaster?

2) What if the Russian Winter arrived later and less brutal than usual in 1941?

3) What if the Americans lost the Battle of Midway?

4) What if the Greeks were unable to delay the Nazi invasion of Russia with their resistance?

5) What if Truman decided not to drop the a-bombs? What if Germany or Japan developed the a-bomb first?

6) What if the U.S. had spotted the Japanese Pearl harbor attack fleet in advance of the attack?
 
What if Cluas Van Stauffenberg’s attempt to assassinate Hilter succeeded?
 
5) What if Truman decided not to drop the a-bombs?

Russia would invade Japan first. Dropping the A-bomb was
more humane than to let Stalin did the dirty work of pacifying
the Japanese with an army comprising of 'the scums of Russia'
uncle joe had assembled for the occupation of Sapporo.
 
The History Channel is running a series of programs on WW II leading up to Remembrance Day.
What what what?

What do they think this is, the 90s? History better stop showing endless crappy pseudo-documentaries on WWII and Hitler and get back to showing endless even crappier pseudo-documentaries on Aliens and rednecks.
 
The big one would be:

What if the Germans never double crossed the Russians and invaded Russia?

Russia stays neutral and Germany could have concentrated it's efforts on Britain?

(not a pleasant scenario)
 
What if Britain lost the Battle of Britain and the RAF was indeed knocked out?

The Germans then proceed with crossing the channel and trying to invade the UK.
 
I've just started reading Karl-Heinz Friser's "The Blitzkrieg Legend" which has the central thesis that Germany pretty much lucked into the blitzkrieg operational mode of making war and that the defeat of France was a lucky fluke. It has a chapter on Dunkirk that I haven't read yet. When I get there, I will try and respond to point #1.

Re point #2, it was less a matter of climate and more the case that the Wehrmacht and Luftwaffe were attrited and over-extended in late 1941. When Stalin scraped up new units from Siberia, he could hit the Germans hard at a time when they had little to hit back with. Hence the Moscow counter-offensive.

Re point #3, the US would have killed Japan sooner or later in any event. The only issue was whether the US would fight back after Pearl, as opposed to just shrugging and deciding the Pacific wasn't worth the effort and allowing Japan to win The USA was vastly stronger in economic terms.
 
I think that American would have still bounced back, but it would have taken longer - depending on how many ships they lost of course. Japan would have also acquired more territory while the US was recovering.
The Americans were lucky (or was it planned?) their aircraft carriers were out at sea and not at Pearl Harbor on December 7, 1941. These same carriers won the day 6 months later at the Battle of Midway. Also, the Japanese were unable to destroy the maintenance shops and it was amazing how quickly the damaged ships were re-built (except the U.S.S. Arizona, R.I.P.).
 
I've just started reading Karl-Heinz Friser's "The Blitzkrieg Legend" which has the central thesis that Germany pretty much lucked into the blitzkrieg operational mode of making war and that the defeat of France was a lucky fluke. It has a chapter on Dunkirk that I haven't read yet. When I get there, I will try and respond to point #1.
Apparently, General Charles DeGaulle(sp) warned the French about the weakness of stationary warfare. The Nazis simply went around the Maginot(sp) Line.

Dunkirk should be an interesting read. Apparently, the French Army sacrificed themselves protecting the British retreat.
 
Here is another "what if". What if bad weather delayed the Normany landings for another 2-3 days. What if the "General Patton" ruse did not work and Hitler did not concentrate his troops around Calais?

BTW: Despite Stalin's complaints about the allies delay in landing in Europe, the very threat of such a landing tied up 1 million German soldiers in the west that might have been freed to the eastern front.
 
What if Hitler never existed?

Would the hardcore liberals of the 20th century never had the excuse to go as far as they have and relentlessly try to flood ALL European based countries with massive and uncontrolled immigration and promote miscegenation on a scale the likes of which the world has never seen?
 
What if the Germans never double crossed the Russians and invaded Russia?

I read a book sometime ago written by German generals. They were unable to convince Hitler to wait until England had capitulated.

I think the big 'what if's' should centre around 'What if the Allies didn't break both the Japanese and Nazi top military codes ?' Midway happened because the US knew where that Japanese were going to be. The Allies could intercept the German fighters because they knew the targets. According to Intrepid - Churchill knew Coventry was going to leveled but could not evacuate the city for fear it would tip the Germans off about Enigma.
 
]The German air force were very limited in it's ability to take out naval targets. The Germans had limited ability to transport by sea. A lot of the barges could be swamped by just running a destroyer really fast near them. If they did try it seems the concensis opinion is that the Royal Navy could still have crushed the invasion damn the lossesleaving anything that got past isolated. Sure there is airdrop but the JU52 fleet got hammered in the invasion of France and by the time the RAF would have been taken out the UK ground forces would have been able to take out whatever the Germans could bring across the channel.[/COLOR]

I agree that the RN would have had something to say about any potential invasion of Britain by sea. But I'm sure that the Germans would have had more options if the RAF had of been taken out.

That said, thank heaven for Neville Chamberlain and his government signing off on the design of the Huricane and the Spitfire (and the Mustang). Without them, Churchill would not have been able to claim the victory.
 
All I can say is this.


Even if the Germans had the A-Bomb, would they have had enough of them to win the war? (Don't forget that the Americans killed more Japanese with conventional ordinance and phosphorus bombs).

If Hitler was killed early in the war, some say that the remaining Nazi brass may have made different military decisions which might have prolonged the war or assure more success.
 
All I can say is this.


Even if the Germans had the A-Bomb, would they have had enough of them to win the war? (Don't forget that the Americans killed more Japanese with conventional ordinance and phosphorus bombs).

If Hitler was killed early in the war, some say that the remaining Nazi brass may have made different military decisions which might have prolonged the war or assure more success.

And what would Germany winning the war actually have entailed? Each year as Remembrance Day approaches, you hear such things as "we would be speaking German right now if not for those who fought and died". Would we really? Could Germany have actually taken over North America? I can't see how that could have happened. Would the Americans have ever walked away from Europe?
 
The big one would be:

What if the Germans never double crossed the Russians and invaded Russia?

Russia stays neutral and Germany could have concentrated it's efforts on Britain?

(not a pleasant scenario)

I agree that is an interesting question because it is based on a simple decision that could easily have been different.

I read a WWI speculative fiction based on Germany not invading through Belgium. Without that act, the Brits might not have declared war (which would mean no unrestricted naval campaign which would likely have kept the US out of it). Germany and allies vs. France and an already crumbling Russia wouldn't have been as long a war.