WTF is wrong with our laws......

Doesn't this kind of encourage theft? The message our legal system is sending out right now is "If you run fast enough, the stuff is yours."
 
Thanks Hadrian, although we may argue on who's the best guitarist.

I must say though, in a former guitar thread, I forgot to mention that my brother has to be my favourite guitarist. He has had more than his 15 minutes of fame. I have to ask him though about your fave Dime.

My 15 minutes is coming brother....God knows I`ve worked hard enough...;)
 
You don't believe in the rule of law, then?

So you support vigilante justice?
I believe very much in the rule of law. And this was not vigilantism: the shopkeeper did not form a posse and go hunt down this criminal. He stopped the criminal in what may very well have been the commission of yet another offense.

At the very least, this criminal was trespassing at the time of the citizen's arrest.
 
If any1 tries to rob me on my own home he is lucky to be a live or cripple..
 
Ironically, the store is just one block away from the police station (52 Division). I remember an interview with another shop owner in the area, saying shoplifting is common and when they complained to the police. They were told it was low priority. Shoplifters know this, so they basically steal without any consequence.
 
Ironically, the store is just one block away from the police station (52 Division). when they complained to the police. They were told it was low priority. .

Thanks Gar, you said it best for me. I have a neighbour 4 doors down who drives without a lic. and insurance in a stolen car with stolen plates. Called the cops and made a report in early March 09. Called again this week and was told that they have the report on file but its low priority.

Sitting in "Timmy's" is fucking low priority. Just makes me shake.
 
the " suspect is well knoiwn to police and the local merchants repeat shopper so to speak.

The police put a very low priority on this type of thing ( the shop lifting) but really don't like to be embarrased as they were by the shop keeper who basically said I have had enough.

Unfortunatly the police and the crown had their say the final say is comming next summert
 
To be fair, the police have shown some presence in Chinatown, they'll roust the elderly ladies trying to sell vegetables on makeshift tables trying to supplement their income. Supposely, the old ladies are a front for organized crime. Yeah right.
The only other time you'll see police in Chinatown, weekdays 4pm when parking is illegal on Dundas. Ticket and tow.
 
OK what the shop owner did does not consitute the legal definition of citizens arrest. But the thief is notorious in that area for stealing many other stores and the police have done nothing to stop him. The shop owner has proof on camera that this guy stole from him earlier and was back to steal again. He chased the guy, tied him up and detained him until police arrived. He (or someone associated with him) called the cops. The thief was arrested, charged and convicted of the crime. But it doesn't end there.

Now the cops want to go after the shop keeper have him tried and convicted of two felony offences and possibly spend time in prison. It's going to cost the taxpayers to prosecute this individual. It's going to cost this individual legal defense costs not to mention lost time from his store. For what? Because he may have gone a little overboard in protecting his property, his livelihood.

Does it serve the public anything positive to try and convict this guy? I can't think of one reason. Have him plead guilty to a misdemeanor and promise not to do it again. This is ridiculous.
 
So what did the store owner do wrong here ?

He had the audacity to apprehend a criminal...the bastard!

Should be exported, flogged, jailed for LIFE....

Oh, and the criminal should be awarded $1,000,000.00 of taxpayer's money, given a new home on the Bridal Path, and a job at City Hall in charge of the unions........
 
I believe very much in the rule of law.

Plainly you don't. The law is very, very clear here.

And this was not vigilantism: the shopkeeper did not form a posse and go hunt down this criminal. He stopped the criminal in what may very well have been the commission of yet another offense.

Wrong. If dude had been in the commission of an offence there would have been no arrest. It was precisely because the guy was *not* doing anything illegal at the time that the shopkeeper was arrested.

At the very least, this criminal was trespassing at the time of the citizen's arrest.

I can't see how the criminal here, namely the shopkeeper, was trespassing?

The shopkeeper's victim was suspected of a crime. The difference between "suspected" and "guity" is a matter for the police, the crown, and the courts. When individual citizens take that matter into their own hands we have a word for it: vigilante.

Citizens are only entitled to arrest other citizens when the offense is committed before their eyes.

Citizens are not entitled to conduct investigations, collect evidence, and then arrest.

You plainly (a) do not understand the law, and (b) do not respect the law.
 
I'll tell you a worse story. A friend and neighbour of mine is a landscaper and general contractor. Keeps all of his equipment in a garage sized shed on his home proprty. 13 years ago the shed was broken and entered, and the goods stolen. 2 Lawn tractors, 2 snow throwers, several lawn mowers, weed trimmers, and lots of power tools. The thief had to hault this stuff away in a moving van. How he managed to do this undetected was beyond my friend. His insurance replaced the goods, but to get a favorable rate he had to install surveillance equipment. This was 13 years ago, so equipment was expensive. He installed it. 3 Months later, same thing happens at 4:30am. All caught on video. Perp's face captured on camera -- clear as day. And the friend knew him. Police were apprised.

Their response, was to lay no charge. After all my friend knew the man. How did the police know if this was theft or simply a willing loan of equipment followed by using the police to enforce a change of heart? The police felt it best not to get involved with squabbles between friends.

:eek:
 
Ironically, the store is just one block away from the police station (52 Division). I remember an interview with another shop owner in the area, saying shoplifting is common and when they complained to the police. They were told it was low priority. Shoplifters know this, so they basically steal without any consequence.

In your mind does that entitle you to ignore the law? Is it your view that if the police fail to react appropriately that you are entitled to break the law with abandon?

That apparently is the view of supporters of this criminal shopkeeper. Apparently whether the rule of law applies in Canada is supposed to depend on public opinion.
 
I believe very much in the rule of law. And this was not vigilantism: the shopkeeper did not form a posse and go hunt down this criminal. He stopped the criminal in what may very well have been the commission of yet another offense.

A vigilante is a self-appointed doer of justice, and does not require a posse to be one. The problem is that he acted too soon. Had he given the perp a chance to grab some plants there would have been no problem with his actions (assuming he didn't apply too much force of course)

You can't do a citizen's arrest because someone "might do something". If I'm caught by police as I walk along with a firearm in hand they don't charge me with murder, or even illegal discharge of a firearm (think that's the term), they charge me with carrying a gun.

At the very least, this criminal was trespassing at the time of the citizen's arrest.

Trespassing? Had the owner previously told the person he wasn't allowed in the store? Was there a sign at the door saying "Hey Mr. Plant
Thief You aren't allowed in!" Can't be tresspassing if you haven't been told you can't pass the tress. :)

I agree that it's crazy that the guy is known to be a thief yet the cops haven't done anything and I sympathize with the store owner. Hopefully with all the publicity, once it gets to the judge the owner will receive a suspended sentence.

But even kids know better..... "They always catch the one who hits back first"
 
Does it serve the public anything positive to try and convict this guy?

Yes. Absolutely. Yes.

What freedom do you have that is greater than the freedom of security of person? The right to move about as you please? The right to go where you want, and do what you want?

That right was removed from the victim in this case by a shopkeeper who felt that his mere suspicion was adequate to deny another individual their *most* fundamental freedom.

Those of us in Canada who love our freedom insist that such rights be infringed only through due process of law.

Even the police cannot stop me from walking down a street unless they have probable cause to stop me. Even the highest court in this country cannot impose such a sentence on me without serious deliberation.

The notion that some random, uneducated shop keeper can remove my most fundamental freedoms merely because of his inept, ill informed, inferior, ignorant, and flawed thought processes--just because he himself subjectively believed that I might in some way be a criminal, without recourse to any judge or any jury--to take away the most fundamental freedom anybody has--wow.

If that's what a shop-keeper can do, what sort of absolute power are you proposing to grant to the government?

Do you *really* support that?

I find it incredulous that anyone who cared about individual freedom could support a system that entitles one individual to forcibly confine another over nothing more than mere suspicion.

It is of great benefit to every person in society to have this shop keeper made an example of, to have him pillioried to the extent that we can under law, so that no-one, and I mean *no* *one* walks around under the mistaken impression that they can deny another individual their most basic rights.
 
Plainly you don't. The law is very, very clear here.



Wrong. If dude had been in the commission of an offence there would have been no arrest. It was precisely because the guy was *not* doing anything illegal at the time that the shopkeeper was arrested.



I can't see how the criminal here, namely the shopkeeper, was trespassing?

The shopkeeper's victim was suspected of a crime. The difference between "suspected" and "guity" is a matter for the police, the crown, and the courts. When individual citizens take that matter into their own hands we have a word for it: vigilante.

Citizens are only entitled to arrest other citizens when the offense is committed before their eyes.

Citizens are not entitled to conduct investigations, collect evidence, and then arrest.

You plainly (a) do not understand the law, and (b) do not respect the law.

and you would make a great lawyer Fuji, which is why I say we no longer have a justice system, we have a legal system. No longer are guilty people jailed for an appropriate length of time, no longer are innocent people protected always. Guilty go free, victims get penalized, all you need is $$$ and you'll get off (unless of course the blue bloods decide you didn't play by their rules then they (like wolves) will eat their own.....).

The facts are: the shopkeeper was ripped off by someone. The shopkeeper saw the person return to his store. The shopkeeper had 100% proof that this person was the one who ripped him off. The shopkeeper caught, detained, and handed over the CRIMINAL to the police.

What should have happened is the CRIMINAL be charged, stood trial, then fined or jailed for an APPROPRIATE length of time. Instead? The VICTIM is being charged.

Know what this teaches us? CRIMINALS have MORE rights than VICTIMS.

The "idea" of the law is that regular citizens can arrest and detain criminals. The "idea" of the law is to limit just how far a citizen can go (in other words, not beat the fuck out of the criminal).
 
I guess fuji liked the ending of Dark Knight. :D
Yeah, this case is a true test of whether people believe in the "strict" rule of law. I guess, even though I might have done what the shop keeper did in the heat of the moment, I have to agree with fuji. You just don't want people to be out there thinking that they are crime fighters and can capture "criminals" on their own.