WTF is deconstructionism?

Yoga Face

New member
Jun 30, 2009
6,307
19
0
This definition makes me feel dumb




Deconstruction is a literary theory and philosophy of language derived principally from Jacques Derrida's 1967 work Of Grammatology.

The premise of deconstruction is that all of Western literature and philosophy implicitly relies on a metaphysics of presence, where instrinsic meaning is accessible by virtue of pure presence. Deconstruction denies the possibility of a pure presence and thus of essential or instrinsic meaning.

Derrida terms the philosophical commitment to pure presence as a source of self-sufficient meaning logocentrism. Due to the impossibility of pure presence and consequently of instrinsic meaning, any given concept is constituted and comprehended linguistically and in terms of its oppositions, e.g. perception/reason, speech/writing, mind/body, interior/exterior, marginal/central, sensible/intelligible, intuition/signification, nature/culture. Further, Derrida contends that of these dichotomies one member is associated with presence and consequently more highly valued than the other which is associated with absence. Deconstruction reveals the metaphysics of presence in a text by identifying its conceptual binary oppositions and demonstrating the speciousness of their hierarchy by denying the possibility of comprehending the "superior" element of the hierarchy in the absence of its "inferior" counterpart. Denying an absolute and intrinsic meaning to either element of the hierarchy différance is revealed (rather than proposed as an alternative) according to Derrida. Différance is a Derridaean neologism that is the antithesis of logocentrism, it is a perpetual series of interactions between presence and absence—where a concept is constituted, comprehended and identified in terms of what it is not and self-sufficient meaning is never arrived at—and thus a relinquishment of the notions of intrinsic and stable meaning, absolute truth, unmediated access to "reality" and consequently of conceptual hierarchy.

To situate deconstruction within philosophy in general, it is a critique of Idealism and a form of antifoundationalism. In terms of heritage, style and conceptual framework (namely phenomenological), deconstruction is within the Continental—as opposed to analytic—tradition of philosophy.



 
English translation please!
 
in summary, its a form intellectual masterbation.
 
I will give it a go




"The premise of deconstruction is that all of Western literature and philosophy implicitly relies on a metaphysics of presence, where instrinsic meaning is accessible by virtue of pure presence. Deconstruction denies the possibility of a pure presence and thus of essential or instrinsic meaning."


This means the writer is not present (the metaphyics of presence) so it is the reader who gives meaning to the written word so there is no "essential or instrinsic meaning" as the meaning will change from reader to reader (if so why do they not just say it?) . The rest of the blather is about how the reader gives meaning to the written word.

Anyone have something deconstructive to say about the metaphysics of presence in the intrinsic meaning of my comment?
 
the meaning of the text is relative to the reader- i.e. it means what the reader thinks it means not what the writer intended
 
the meaning of the text is relative to the reader- i.e. it means what the reader thinks it means not what the writer intended

that is the understanding i have come to as well
 
It's also a great way to make one look smart when one has completely failed to grasp the intended meaning of the author.
 
It's also a great way to make one look smart when one has completely failed to grasp the intended meaning of the author.
Indeed!

Quite elementary really


according to Derrida we cannot grasp his meaning


that means we have not grasped his meaning


which means we have grasped his meaning

his meaning being we cannot grasp his meaning, which we have grasped

therefore he is completely wrong about grasping meanings

unless, of course, we have not grasped his meaning

in that case ....
 
the meaning of the text is relative to the reader- i.e. it means what the reader thinks it means not what the writer intended

And in particular, that this meaning results from shared cultural experiences, often more from the form and context that a book or work is found in, than in any inherent message the author tried to convey.

It is the ideological basis of things like mashups, where clips are used for their cultural significance rather than their intended meaning.

As such the person experiencing the mashed up with is expected to do so in the context of their own experiences.

People who subscribe to this theory tend to try and promote marginalized cultural experiences of works of art, surfacing perspectives that are normally out of view by exposing the mechanism by which majority cultural interpretations dominate.
 
So the idea being because it is meaningless it has meaning?
 
Rebecca Goldstein defines it as: "In deconstruction, the critic claims there is no meaning to be found in the actual text, but only in the various, often mutually irreconcilable, 'virtual texts' constructed by readers in their search for meaning"

As for myself I begin to think that Bill Cosby's skit "Why is there air" hits the nail on the head.
 
Deconstructionism can be more easily summed up as the act of critical analysis. Its one of many terms (like ideology, discourse etc.) associated with Postmodernism - the movement to describe the era following modernism/modernity (from the Industrial Revolution forward). Perhaps this quote attributed to Anais Nin can explain: "We don't see things as they are, we see them as we are." You can also check this out if you want to know more: http://www.pbs.org/faithandreason/gengloss/postm-body.html

Regardless, I wouldn't start with French philosophers/intellectuals to understand most things unless you want to play some hard core mental gymnastics ;)