You seem a bit more technical than me...
dreamblade said:
Um, isn't the battery only replaceable by Apple? so how could they be user serviceable? The battery BETTER be more sturdy, considering the price you have to pay to replace it.
Weather you're on BIS or BES, the fact that emails go through RIM's network isn't an issue, it's an asset. For one, it's more secure, second it's faster, third it's cheaper on your dataplan.
The Iphone will have Exchange support, which is a definite plus, but there have not been any conclusive tests about its security (probably on par with Windows, Palm, and Symbian), but as an wireless IT expert, I would hesitate to allow sensitive company data on it.
Furthermore, Apple has been weird about releasing the Iphone's SDK so that apps can be created. Now they've announced apps will be sold, but through the Apple online store. On the plus side, it means less crap programs (see Palm apps that crash the system), but it will also mean less programmers willing to create them.
Sorry, the Iphone is, for now, still lumped with the rest of Apple products in my mind: Decent, but way overhyped and underpromising.
...but as someone who is also on the "inside" and has been a part of these very discussion between the people who are making these decisions, you are pretty dead on.
The iPhone is a wow gee whiz CONSUMER device....whose only edge over other products is the wow gee wiz factor.
It does what it does well. It does NOT do what a RIM BB device does.
Like others have pointed out...simple things like the user interface are the hurdles. Great for impressing chicks at the club...USELESS FOR ACTUALLY TYPING ON.
Apple ROCKS at creating "killer app" consumer devices. The iPod...the iPhone...
But they have never...in their entire existence...created a successful Enterprise / Commercial product....in part because they design their products for the consumer first.
Many a IT Director / VP / CIO is passionate about Apple in their personal life. But they know that an Apple PC is useless in the corporate environment unless that environments business is driven by the things that the Apple does particularly well (like graphics and design).
It will be the same with the iPhone...again, I am sure many, many IT leaders, being the techie types they are...own an iPhone. Love the iPhone.
They are smart enough to know that it is no substitute for the RIM BB....and for what it is worth...I am something of a RIM hater (I know a bit more about their products, functionality, and relationships with their customers than most....suffice to say that users love them, but there is a reason why carriers keep pushing other devices....). They are smart enough to know that their businesses depend on functionality first...functionality and reliability. And they are smart enough to not put their jobs at risk making the change over.
RIM will adopt what makes sense in the iPhone (such as the touch screen for switching apps and functions) and leave behind what doesn't (such as the lack of an actual tactile keyboard for users who have already adopted a manner for communicating in the fashion 70+ years ago with the invention of the typewriter). They will also not adopt Apple iPhone function follows form mistakes (the battery issue, just as one example).
Truth be told, and I've told this to people who have paid me for my opinion...I am surprised there are so many who give Apple so much of a chance to do well in this segment / space. RIM has proven to be an INCREDIBLY strong, smart and agile competitor...one that is absolutely positioned to dominate its market, and has demonstrated an absolute will and wherewithal to do so. Companies that know A LOT MORE about making phones...especially making phones for the Enterprise / Commercial space than Apple have tried to take RIM down...and failed. Miserably. They have failed even though carriers would LOVE LOVE LOVE to see a true RIM alternative be adopted by their customers in numbers that will allow them (the carriers) to then change the dynamics of their relationship with RIM.
It ain't happened yet, and Apple ain't positioned to do it. Wrong product from the wrong people with the wrong background for the job.