Here's a situation I'd like to run by you:
Back in November, my then girlfriend and I had a fantastic weekend together. It started out a bit shaky, since even though things had been going really well by all accounts after two months of dating (the relationship was really intense) she confessed that she still wasn't 100% sure about us being a long term thing. I was a bit surprised to hear that, but we had a long talk and we both felt better afterwards. Then we had sex and went to sleep.
The next morning, everything was fantastic. She started talking about the great Christmas we were going to have together, I was going to meet her parents, she was making long term plans for us for next summer etc.. Naturally, I assumed that she had resolved any qualms / trepidations she may have had about us as a couple. Then on Sunday, she came over to my place - another great time.
Now, she had just come out of the washroom and was getting ready to leave. While she was putting on her shoes, she touched the wall with her still wet hand, which left a mark / smudge on my wall. I didn't say anything since I didn't want to make a big deal about it, and I figured I'd just wipe it off later. Two things:
1) I had just moved into a brand new condo at the time, and the paint was still fresh and not fully cured yet.
2) The paint happened to be eggshell, which caused the smudge to worsen when I tried to wipe it off. I discovered that the only way to fix it would be to paint over it.
Not wanting to have marks all over my walls every time she came over, I decided to say something. I figured I had a bit of leeway here, since she and I were going to be a long term thing. So, the next evening as we were talking on the phone, I casually and very politely brought up the subject about the wall / paint, explained my reasoning and asked her if she could be mindful of it in the future to prevent a recurrence.
Well, she completely flipped. Apparently she had an ex who used to chastise her about such things, and she subsequently accused me of doing the same, which of course was not my intent at all. She ended up not talking to me for a week because of this, and things just went downhill from there, eventually leading to our break up.
Personally, I think she completely over reacted. To qualify the situation, I should add that she suffers from Borderline Personality Disorder. Not sure if that played a part in her reaction or not. So, I'm just wondering, was that really such a bad thing to say to her? I totally was not expecting her to react the way she did.
Thoughts?
Back in November, my then girlfriend and I had a fantastic weekend together. It started out a bit shaky, since even though things had been going really well by all accounts after two months of dating (the relationship was really intense) she confessed that she still wasn't 100% sure about us being a long term thing. I was a bit surprised to hear that, but we had a long talk and we both felt better afterwards. Then we had sex and went to sleep.
The next morning, everything was fantastic. She started talking about the great Christmas we were going to have together, I was going to meet her parents, she was making long term plans for us for next summer etc.. Naturally, I assumed that she had resolved any qualms / trepidations she may have had about us as a couple. Then on Sunday, she came over to my place - another great time.
Now, she had just come out of the washroom and was getting ready to leave. While she was putting on her shoes, she touched the wall with her still wet hand, which left a mark / smudge on my wall. I didn't say anything since I didn't want to make a big deal about it, and I figured I'd just wipe it off later. Two things:
1) I had just moved into a brand new condo at the time, and the paint was still fresh and not fully cured yet.
2) The paint happened to be eggshell, which caused the smudge to worsen when I tried to wipe it off. I discovered that the only way to fix it would be to paint over it.
Not wanting to have marks all over my walls every time she came over, I decided to say something. I figured I had a bit of leeway here, since she and I were going to be a long term thing. So, the next evening as we were talking on the phone, I casually and very politely brought up the subject about the wall / paint, explained my reasoning and asked her if she could be mindful of it in the future to prevent a recurrence.
Well, she completely flipped. Apparently she had an ex who used to chastise her about such things, and she subsequently accused me of doing the same, which of course was not my intent at all. She ended up not talking to me for a week because of this, and things just went downhill from there, eventually leading to our break up.
Personally, I think she completely over reacted. To qualify the situation, I should add that she suffers from Borderline Personality Disorder. Not sure if that played a part in her reaction or not. So, I'm just wondering, was that really such a bad thing to say to her? I totally was not expecting her to react the way she did.
Thoughts?

