"World Champions"

spankingman

Well-known member
Dec 7, 2008
3,639
321
83
I hate it when the Super Bowl ,World Series winners are declared "WORLD CHAMPIONS!"!!!!!!!! What a load of crap. They are NATIONAL Champions at best. Who won the recent WORLD BASEBALL CLASSIC CHAMPIONSHIP the only REAL World type Championship of baseball? It was JAPAN beating KOREA!!!!
 
Look at it this way. Yankees pay top dollar for talent from around the world. Many countries represented on that team.
 
Look at it this way. Yankees pay top dollar for talent from around the world. Many countries represented on that team.

That's how the announcers tried to explain it on FOX during the Fall Classic last week too (I refuse to call it the "World" Series), and that's a nice argument, but it doesn't change the fact that the "World Series" crowns a champion of professional club baseball in the United States (and Canada too). That's it. If the series champion went on to play in a tournament against the champions of all the other pro baseball leagues from around the world, then the winner of that tournament would truly be the World Champions, at least at the club level. (The other level being teams representing countries, like the World Cup of soccer, which is truly a world championship.)

But the fact remains that they don't. So they aren't. World champions that is. And thanks to baseball's hubris in naming their pro league championship the "World Series", that arrogance rubbed off on the NFL and NBA, where their winners immediately and routinely refer to themselves as "world champions".

God ... could you imagine the Stanley Cup winning team's captain being interviewed right after the Cup ceremony and him declaring his team the "world champions of hockey"? He'd be laughed out of the building and derided for months afterwards!!! So why don't they do that in baseball, NFL football, and basketball???
 
are you people seriously saying that a team in Japan, Korea or Venezuela could beat the Yankees?? the best team in those leagues is maybe as good as a really good AA team on this side of the world :D
 
Great point Spankingman; Keyra you are right on as well.

I am a life long Yankees fan (that is viewed as a flaw in my family) and I am thrilled they won the series. But I believe they have achieved the championship of MLB and nothing more. Are they the best in the world? Perhaps, but we will never know until they are tested by non-MLB teams. But lacking the test it is a stertch to call them "World Champions". The same holds for NBA; NFL is probably safe in their claim for now since only the US and Canada play this brand of football as far as I know.
 
are you people seriously saying that a team in Japan, Korea or Venezuela could beat the Yankees?? the best team in those leagues is maybe as good as a really good AA team on this side of the world :-D

Not saying that at all, Scouser. Their league champions are clearly AAA teams over here (I'm not going to say all the way down to AA like you did, but I agree with you in principle). The Yankees (or any other Series champion in the past) would likely slaughter those teams. But that's *not the point*.

The point is, you simply can't set up a league in one country (or in the case of baseball in the U.S., two separate leagues whose champions compete against each other at the end of the season), then crown a champion in that league and declare that one club team to be the WORLD CHAMPION, when dozens of other professional leagues operate in dozens of other countries all over the world. It's arrogant and hubris in its worst form. But that's the American attitude for you - the whole world is contained within their borders. Or at least the whole world that counts to them. People around the world laugh at Americans referring to the "World Series" and NBA teams calling themselves the "world champions" when they win the NBA title. They are *LEAGUE CHAMPIONS*, not fucking "world" champions.

Again, could you just imagine the reaction if an NHL team, after winning the Stanley Cup, went around calling itself the "world champions"?

Edit to add:

Thanks for the compliment jrc0331. :) And you took the words right out of my mouth, about baseball and NBA. I pretty much agree with your take on the NFL too, since there aren't world-wide leagues of that brand of football.
 
From Wikipedia:


In spite of its name, the World Series remains solely the championship of the major-league baseball teams in the United States and Canada, although MLB, its players, and the media sometimes informally refer to World Series winners as "world champions" of baseball. The United States, Canada and Mexico (Liga Méxicana de Béisbol, established 1925) were the only professional baseball countries until a few decades into the 20th century. The first Japanese professional baseball efforts began in 1920. The current Japanese leagues date from the late 1940s (after World War II). Various Latin American leagues also formed around that time.
By the 1990s, baseball was played at a highly-skilled level in many countries, giving a strong international flavor to the Series. Many of the best players from Latin America, the Caribbean, the Pacific Rim, and elsewhere now play on Major League rosters. The notable exceptions are Cuban citizens, because of the political tensions between the USA and Cuba since 1959 (however, a number of Cuba's finest ballplayers have still managed to defect to the United States over the past half-century to play in the American professional leagues). Players from the Japanese Leagues also have a more difficult time coming to the Major Leagues because they must first play ten years in Japan before becoming free agents, unless they are posted by their Japanese teams for bids from MLB teams. Reaching the high-income Major Leagues tends to be the goal of many of the best players around the world.
 
No one who states what they believe and supports the statement(s) with objective evidence is a hypocrite. A hypocrite is "a person who pretends to have virtues, moral or religious beliefs, principles, etc., that he or she does not actually possess, esp. a person whose actions belie stated beliefs". The point is no one can rightfully lay claim to be the champion of a wide population (world) in a sport that has limited participation by the population mentioned in the title. If a team wants to rigthfully declare they are "World Champions" then simply invite other league champions to compete to see who is indeed the best team.

And the title "World Champions of Baseball" was voiced in the trophy presentation. Nothing at all informal about that.
 
In the immortal words of Chase Utley, circa 2008 :

"World F***ing Champions!"

It's what the WS champs have always been called. Let someone put together a team and beat the WS champs if they disagree. Actually a latin/carribean based team of all stars would give em quite a run. But it'll never happen.

The Super Bowl champs get the same designation as do the NBA champs.

I guess until someone does something about it, that's the way it is. But you're right, just because they say it doesn't make it true. And you don't have to believe it if you don't want to.

You go up to Ryan Howard and tell him they weren't the World F**ing Champs last year!
 
You go up to Ryan Howard and tell him they weren't the World F**ing Champs last year!

Give me an hour alone with Ryan Howard, and I'm pretty sure afterwards he'd say anything I wanted him to. ;)
 
Spend an hour with me and I will say anything you want. Does that make me a hypocrite? Nah - just a lucky guy.
 
It is a US thing. So often they make statements that presume the US is the whole world. A Canadian would say "last year in Canada 45 people got their heads stuck in dishwashers". But in the US they would say "last year 4,050 people got their heads stuck in dishwashers". It is a US stat, but that is just presumed, and the rest of the world does not really matter. So for them, if you are US champion, the world and universe are a throw in.
 
Spend an hour with me and I will say anything you want. Does that make me a hypocrite? Nah - just a lucky guy.

LOL! Sure hon - so when are we getting together for that hour? And I have a "first-timer special" where the first time a hobbyist sees me, he gets a free half-hour added to his time, so you'd actually be getting 1.5 hrs with me! I wonder what you'll be saying after the extended time! ;)
 
They're world champions because the best players in the world play in North America(MLB). That world baseball classic is a joke.
 
I hate it when the Super Bowl ,World Series winners are declared "WORLD CHAMPIONS!"!!!!!!!! What a load of crap. They are NATIONAL Champions at best. Who won the recent WORLD BASEBALL CLASSIC CHAMPIONSHIP the only REAL World type Championship of baseball? It was JAPAN beating KOREA!!!!

It's been a bug of mine for years and when I saw a banner at a Chicoago Bulls game claim the same thing (also seen one at Celtics game), I get miffed. I've even sent e-mail to networks commenting on this exact thing when their commentators say the same thing. they comment, meh! It was a stronger argument when the US basketball teams weren't World or Olympic champs, but not as effective now.
 
The arrogance of Americans ... what are you going to do ?



I would not argue the NFL Super Bowl Champions as World Champions. That is a no brainer, no other country on the planet plays football like they do in the US.

In baseball you think there may be an argument ? I do not.
Do you think there is a team that could beat the Yankees, the Phillies or any of the top four or five MLB teams ? I am talking regular teams not all star teams.

Is there a basketball team outside of the NBA that could stay with a top NBA team for a game ? Not in my opinion.


Now if you want to talk national/all star teams I think if the players took it seriously and they could manage to gather a true national team the Americans would likely win the World Title in any of those three sports.
 
The arrogance of Americans ... what are you going to do ?

I would not argue the NFL Super Bowl Champions as World Champions. That is a no brainer, no other country on the planet plays football like they do in the US.

In baseball you think there may be an argument ? I do not.
Do you think there is a team that could beat the Yankees, the Phillies or any of the top four or five MLB teams ? I am talking regular teams not all star teams.

Is there a basketball team outside of the NBA that could stay with a top NBA team for a game ? Not in my opinion.


Now if you want to talk national/all star teams I think if the players took it seriously and they could manage to gather a true national team the Americans would likely win the World Title in any of those three sports.

I have no doubt that an NFL champion team would bet the arse off any other club in the world, hands down.

It would be interesting to see a European championship team play a NBA team or an Asian champion play an MLB team. Don't know for sure what would happen but it might be interesting.
 
I have no doubt that an NFL champion team would bet the arse off any other club in the world, hands down.

It would be interesting to see a European championship team play a NBA team or an Asian champion play an MLB team. Don't know for sure what would happen but it might be interesting.

In a one game showdown, anything might be possible. Though, it's still highly unlikely a championship club team from any other country could beat the same from one of the major league teams, as we know it. In a multi game series, the low odds would have to drop even more against another country's championship team.

It's not simply about the best players from around the world playing in these North American leagues... it's about the depth of players within the leagues... on every single team.

A good example... A pitcher like Dice-K, is no different from the dominating juggernaut that he was in Japan. He still gets a ton of K's but his innings pitched drops significantly because he has to face quality hitters from 1-9, on a consistent basis. There are no easy outs, which makes him have to work so much harder.

Even in hockey, K, I'm sorry to say, the best NHL team is the best team in the world. Other than promoting the league, the games played at the beginning of the season overseas, are really proving to be embarrassing for the European teams.

Team play can win games. Team play and talent wins championships. Team play, talent and the best players usually equals THE best team in the world.

Soccer is the only sport where the original poster's logic has a basis in truth. And, in the end, they get to play a tourney to figure that one out, as well.

#11