Woman Driver - Argh

The driver of that 5th wheel sued the owner of that gas station I hope.

That canopy seemed to come down a little too easy.
 
thetree1 said:
I can't imagine someone coming out of that one unscathed! :eek:

According to CHCH last night during the six o'lclock news guy and his 10 year old son just had some scrapes and bruises.
 
dajodo2 said:
The driver of that 5th wheel sued the owner of that gas station I hope.

That canopy seemed to come down a little too easy.

LOL dude, please........I bet you said the same thing about the world trade center too?
 
tboy said:
LOL dude, please........I bet you said the same thing about the world trade center too?


The gas station canopy did seem to come down VERY easy. We don't know all the conditions, speed of the truck etc, but to compare that to WTC, in my opinion is a little bad form Tboy. You are a smart guy, you could have come up with something else less tragic to compare it too. :(
 
Jesus, gimme a break ok? There's not too many building collapses to choose from!

(and a LOT of people complained about the towers coming down so easily).

As for the canopy: you have to realize (and I was involved with CTCs) they aren't held up by much: typically 4 posts and some trusses, remove 25% of it's support, shift the COG and anything will come down.

Have you seen those things in Florida during hurricanes? They're the first to go.
 
tboy said:
(and a LOT of people complained about the towers coming down so easily).


They had a plane crash into them! I don't know many buildings that would hold up to that.

I am just saying that in my opinion, you could have picked another building, set of buildings as your example instead ones involving such a traumatic event in so many people's lives.

That is all I am saying.
 
tboy said:
As for the canopy: you have to realize (and I was involved with CTCs) they aren't held up by much: typically 4 posts and some trusses, remove 25% of it's support, shift the COG and anything will come down.

Have you seen those things in Florida during hurricanes? They're the first to go.

tboy has just proved my point. The canopy collapsed in part to shoddy, unsubstantial, and flimsy construction practices.

You may be summoned for your expert testimony that you yourself knew these canopy's are death traps waiting to happen.

When I'm at Wendy's (Mesley) condo this weekend banging her I will suggest she do an investigative report on Marketplace this fall to warn people of these time bombs.

She will want to interview you for the episode tboy so don't skip town and keep your phone line open.

http://www.cbc.ca/marketplace/
 
dajodo2 said:
tboy has just proved my point. The canopy collapsed in part to shoddy, unsubstantial, and flimsy construction practices.

You may be summoned for your expert testimony that you yourself knew these canopy's are death traps waiting to happen.

When I'm at Wendy's (Mesley) condo this weekend banging her I will suggest she do an investigative report on Marketplace this fall to warn people of these time bombs.

She will want to interview you for the episode tboy so don't skip town and keep your phone line open.

http://www.cbc.ca/marketplace/

LOL wendy's, dude, ROnald McDOnald was there LONG before you were.....remember to lick up his "special" sauce while you're down there...I know you do enjoy that.....

As for "shoddy", since you know so much about engineering and building codes, I should think your opinion would be the only one that mattered if any interview is req'd.

However, since you DO know about engineering, load dispersal, and structural integrity you would know that remove 25% of the support for load or shift that load more than 10% off balance and no matter what you build, will come down.
 
tboy said:
I should think your opinion would be the only one that mattered if any interview is req'd.


You mean someone else's opnion can actually mean more then yours for once?????

LOL - Sorry couldn't resist! :p
 
My dad bought a camper that you put on your pickup. He had only had it for a couple of months and hadn't driven it very much. We were going on a 6 week trip across the east coast. We we all in the truck, waving goodbye. Dad backs up to turn out of the L shaped driveway, backs right into a balcony and destroys the bathroom. LMAO! Still left that day.
 
dajodo2 said:
The canopy collapsed in part to shoddy, unsubstantial, and flimsy construction practices.
You must be a lawyer itching for a client. It comes down to what is the purpose of the column in question? Is the purpose of the column to hold up a canopy, that adds to the enjoyment of clients filling up their tank at a gas bar. Or, is the purpose of the column to hold up against a poor driver that will slam into it with a 2000 tonne car at more than 5km/hr on a fequent basis? I think most structural engineers would agree it was built for it's intended use. Most lawyers wouldn't and that's why engineering has gone to the dogs.
 
KWI said:
They had a plane crash into them! I don't know many buildings that would hold up to that.

I am just saying that in my opinion, you could have picked another building, set of buildings as your example instead ones involving such a traumatic event in so many people's lives.

That is all I am saying.

Actually (IIRC) a documentary on the towers commented that they were designed to withstand being run into by a plane. Unfortunately the planes at that time weren't jumbo jets full of fuel.
 
dajodo2 said:
tboy has just proved my point. The canopy collapsed in part to shoddy, unsubstantial, and flimsy construction practices.


While it is true that they could be designed stronger, where do you stop? Strong enough to have 25% of supports removed? 50%? Do we make them strong enough to withstand a pickup/camper impact, transport truck, crashing airplane?

As with everything, there has to be a compromise between the degree of safety desired and the cost. Given that the papers aren't full of collapsing pump shelters I think it is reasonable to assume that they are acceptably safe.
 
Moraff said:
Actually (IIRC) a documentary on the towers commented that they were designed to withstand being run into by a plane. Unfortunately the planes at that time weren't jumbo jets full of fuel.

Unfortunately they weren't designed to withstand dynamite that had been planted at key structural points either.

A controlled implosion brought them down not the planes.
 
dajodo2 said:
Unfortunately they weren't designed to withstand dynamite that had been planted at key structural points either.

A controlled implosion brought them down not the planes.

Interesting theory, but unverified so far as I know.