Will someone explain single malt scotch to me!

Ceiling Cat

Well-known member
Feb 25, 2009
30,289
2,695
113
I cross border shop and always bring back Chivas Regal scotch. So far I scored 2 bottles of 1 liter Chivas Regals this year @ ( $47.25 exch. rate in/ ea. ) vs. LCBO $70.60. Most people enjoy the same cigarettes and the same beer all the time, why would jumping around from single malt scotch to single malt scotch be so enjoyable, How much better can it be to a blended scotch that has all the best attributes of a several scotches.
Are single malt drinkers paying double, triple and more just for the privileged of having their scotch exclusively come from one distiller and made from one batch of scotch?

Are single malts that much better than blended scotch? Can a single malt be had for the same price or close to a blend? Headed down to the US on Wednesday to take advantages of the Fathers day sales, if someone can suggest a single malt that is close in price to a blend, I will use one of my two exemptions and purchase a bottle.
 
I cross border shop and always bring back Chivas Regal scotch. So far I scored 2 bottles of 1 liter Chivas Regals this year @ ( $47.25 exch. rate in/ ea. ) vs. LCBO $70.60. Most people enjoy the same cigarettes and the same beer all the time, why would jumping around from single malt scotch to single malt scotch be so enjoyable, How much better can it be to a blended scotch that has all the best attributes of a several scotches.
Are single malt drinkers paying double, triple and more just for the privileged of having their scotch exclusively come from one distiller and made from one batch of scotch?

Are single malts that much better than blended scotch? Can a single malt be had for the same price or close to a blend? Headed down to the US on Wednesday to take advantages of the Fathers day sales, if someone can suggest a single malt that is close in price to a blend, I will use one of my two exemptions and purchase a bottle.

Considering some of your past threads and posts, I'm shocked you'd actually have to ask this question. The question is not one of 'better', as some people simply don't like the taste of a particular brand, single malt or blended. It's more a question of more rare and to a certain degree difficult to make consistently as the errors of process and flaws in the various annual crops are harder mask.

Price differences between the US is as much a question of market/country pricing as the usual culprits. charges what you think/know what the market will bare. Some whiskeys are cheaper in Canada than the US.
 
I know what I like, so I have stayed with Chivas Regal 12 or 18. Occasionally I have a dram from my Chivas Royal Salute and then re-seal it with wax. I have not often ventured out of my usual brands, except when bottles are given to me as gifts. I had a bottle of Johnny Walker Blue gifted to me and found it too smokey for my taste.

So what you are saying is that I may pay more and not get something that is to my liking.
 
I know what I like, so I have stayed with Chivas Regal 12 or 18. Occasionally I have a dram from my Chivas Royal Salute and then re-seal it with wax. I have not often ventured out of my usual brands, except when bottles are given to me as gifts. I had a bottle of Johnny Walker Blue gifted to me and found it too smokey for my taste.

So what you are saying is that I may pay more and not get something that is to my liking.

If you like Chivas then stay with it, but if you try something new there always is a chance you won't like it. It's no different in beef steaks, mens suits, holiday tour companies, or in the spirit of TERB, MPAs and SPs, Explore, TOFT, and find something/someone new and you may be surprised.

One of my real pleasant discoveries in Scotches was Glen Orde, a circular green label for those who can't read well, a very inexpensive single malt I discovered at a whiskey tasting near Kingston.

I remember one distillery, whose name escapes me, but Allegra Restaurante near Sherway is one place that has the collection, who offered special bottling of their brand, made from the house recipes over consecutive years. Surprisingly the differences are very noticeable, if you compare them hand in hand, but you would be hard pressed to try one and say it was not what you know.


I've said in a number of threads, older doesn't necessarilty make it better, just more rare.
 
I've heard that this city has establishments called bars, pubs and restaurants, where for $10-15 one would be allowed to sample this mysterious single malt drink and figure out if one likes it or not.
 
Some whiskeys are cheaper in Canada than the US.

what would they be? The taxes in Canada compared to the US make that almost impossible
 
Some whiskeys are cheaper in Canada than the US.

what would they be? The taxes in Canada compared to the US make that almost impossible


It's been a while since i've done a comparison shop, and there are literally 100's of labels to compare, but the prices even differ between provinces, so no surprise.

Pick a liquor retailers website in the US and compare the prices with the LCBO prices. Aloooooooooooooong time ago, you can tell by the price, I purchased a bottle IN Scotland of The MaCallan 25 years old Anniversary, having not seen it here before, and I like the wooden box thing. I paid the equivalent of $150. After returning to Canada, some months later I saw it listed in the LCBO for $120. CHEAPER ffs!!! For special events, the last dram was enjoyed with a good friend at a time when the bottle sold at the LCBO for $700. Today the 25 Anniversary sells for ~$2500 in Britain. Today its offsprings sells for $1000 here. I have not bought a second bottle. I have my limits.
 
Prices are all over the place, generally they are cheaper in the US. There are many factors that determine the price of a bottle. Quantity purchases is one reason for lower price and the other main reason are taxes. In California, a bottle of Chivas Regal 750ml. can be had for about $23. Here in Ontario it is $53, in NY state where I get my scotch $33. ( I buy the 1 liter bottle for $43. ) Where you might get a bargain is in lesser known but highly rated ( in reviews ) bottles.
My brother likes scotch as well as cognac, he introduced me to Gaston Lagrange X.O. cognac that can be had in Quebec for $110 a bottle. I enjoy it very much and prefer it to Courvoisier X.O. at double the price. This is an example where you can have a cognac that is just as good if not better without the brand recognition.
 
Last edited:
California is the Wild West when it comes to booze. You can find the same bottle of booze for $125 at Costco, $150 at a grocery store and $200 at a liquor store.



Back on topic - is there a scotch blend that tastes like Lagavulin or Laphraoig?
 
Back on topic - is there a scotch blend that tastes like Lagavulin or Laphraoig?

A blend might be tough to find due to the unique nature of the Islay single malts. If they are too peaty for you maybe you could try Bunnhabhain or Bruichladdach that are a lot more lightly peated. Bowmore is another medium peated Islay whisky.

Unfortunately no guarantee that our illustrious LCBO will actually carry these bottles of liquid heaven.
 
I just got back yesterday from the USA, I went and took advantage of the mens clothing sales that happens every year for Fathers Day. I brought back my usual allotment of 2 bottles of duty exempt alcohol. My usual would be the 1 liter bottle of Chivas 12 or 750 ml. of Chivas 18 scotch. I consulted the results of the San Francisco Spirit Tasting competition and chose the Glenmorangie 10 Yr Highland Single Malt Scotch Whiskey and Glenmorangie Nectar D'Or 12 Yr Highland Single Malt Scotch Whisky. It just so happens that both of these choices and my regular Chivas 12 and 18 are double gold winners at the SF spirit Tasting Competition. So I guess I can not go wrong. One tasting will not convince me, I will experiment several times and see if single malts are worth the premium paid.
 
You, alone, are only entitled to bring back 1.14L of spirits duty free (after a stay of at least 48 hours), not 2 bottles.

thats why I try to buy 1L bottles, but even when I bring two 750mls back (yes, declared) I've never had trouble.
 
thats why I try to buy 1L bottles, but even when I bring two 750mls back (yes, declared) I've never had trouble.

I was allowed 2 exemptions ( 2 x $800 with 2 x 1.14 liter alcohol exemption ) because were were 2 people. If I am buying Chivas Regal 12, I buy the 1 liter bottle, the Chivas 18 only comes in the 750 ml. bottles as does the Glenmorangie. It is a shame that we can not buy in the 1.14 liter format to take full advantage of the exemptions, or even better be able to bring back the 1.75 liter bottles. ( Chivas 12 is available in this format )
 
In the interest of science! I been sperimenting, in fact I am sperimenting now. How is the Glenmorangie compared to my usual Chivas 12 or Chivas 18? It is quite good, but is it good enough to switch? It is like this. Imagine if you go to your favorite Chinese restaurant and it is closed for renovation, but it is OK because someone told you about a really good Chinese restaurant 10 minutes away from your usual place. So you try it out and it is good, Your favorite dishes are prepared a little different, the change is nice and you might go back another time. Your regular place re-opens after the renovation and a year passes and you find that you returned every time to your favorite because it is good, convenient and familiar. So for now I am a Chivas man.

Sláinte!

 
If you like Chivas Regal scotch, then it would interest you to know that there are several well known brands that go into the making of this brand. Ballantine's scotch the lower of these brands, but still is a fine drink. Chivas Regal is the prestige blended scotch, some of the blend comes from Glenlivet as well as their lesser known single malt Aberlour. If you want to try the single malt version of Chivas Regal, then try Aberlour. This is the basis for Chivas.
 
I was given grief by a border guard for bringing back 2 x 750mL bottles last week. but then this was in Nexus (I declared them)

Why bother declaring? I've been shopping across the border for years and always bring back stuff undeclared. Yes I'm taking a chance but I just can't stand the outrageous taxes we pay here.
 
I love Glenmorangie and Glenrothes Scotch This whole discussion to me is like trying to explain why some guys like backpages, some men like terb reviews and some men like women on the street. Different guys have different tastes. Period. You may be happy with chivas while another prefers blue label. Myself I think blue label Johnnie Walker takes like gasoline.