Why such a fuss about extinction?

danmand

Well-known member
Nov 28, 2003
46,971
5,606
113
Why such a fuss about extinction?

What is wrong with extinction? I realise this question is the conservation equivalent of a landmine - or an elephant trap. And that it is likely to ruffle a lot of fur.

But I ask because I am merely wondering whether we sometimes forget a grim reality of the story of life on Earth - that extinction has always been with us.

In fact, it has quite often been good for us.

We are certainly far better off without velociraptors slashing their way through our cities. Our streets are safer with no sabre-toothed tigers. And imagine trying to swat one of those monster prehistoric insects like a vulture-sized dragonfly.

The question of extinction most recently surfaced at the talks on the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species of Wild Fauna and Flora (CITES) - the treaty meant to save endangered species from the devastating effects of trade.

The slaughter of rhino, the decimation of elephant, the forlorn last stand of the tiger - all had their profiles raised as the delegates in Bangkok negotiated their fate.

And anyone hearing the protests and the campaigns, and the shocking statistics about the losses, might be forgiven for thinking that extinction was some new kind of evil that was not invented until rapacious and uncaring mankind came along.

I should state right now that some of the most ghastly examples are indeed entirely the result of man's activities, sometimes unwittingly, sometimes carelessly.

Natural order

However, taking a long view, extinction has been part of the natural order of things throughout Earth's history.

The most famous mass wipe-out was the loss of the dinosaurs. And four other great die-offs have been identified - one of them killing off something like 90% of species.

“
Start Quote
The blunt truth is that the living world is a restless, churning enterprise in which nothing endures forever”
End Quote
But there is so-called "background" extinction as well - species fading out year by year, creatures quietly losing out to others and disappearing. These losses might not be spectacular - in fact, they're routine.

The result is that the average species only lasts a few million years. Mammals do worst, surviving between one and two million years. Clams do better at five to seven million.

A few hardy survivors - the leatherback turtle is a prime example of a sturdy design - cling on for tens of millions of years.

But the blunt truth is that the living world is a restless, churning enterprise in which nothing endures forever. Astonishingly, almost every life form that has ever existed on the planet has died out.

It is worth pausing to absorb what that means. Something like 90% - or even 99%, according to some estimates - of every kind of sea creature or land animal or insect or plant that enjoyed a spell on Earth then vanished into oblivion.

Some remains morphed into fossils and ended up on the shelves of museums. Others have left no trace.

No mourning

Charles Darwin wrote of extinction in his landmark On the Origin of Species.

For him, the process of evolution involved new species gaining ground and others losing out. He certainly did not mourn the passing of the losers.

The leatherback turtle is a great survivor
So, in the clamour to conserve a host of iconic species, is there a case for us to be more realistic about our ability to intervene? Might the awkward fact be that we can't save everything?

It is certainly the case that the creatures with the best chance are those whose looks or adorability or loveable eyes have attracted the strongest support. No-one is fighting to save the tubeworm.

But should the emphasis change if extinctions are our fault? Or, worse than that, if the losses are accelerating because of us - by tearing up habitats or causing pollution or simply slaughtering every member of a species?

There is a long list of animals whose disappearance can be blamed squarely on human actions.

I met one of them on the Galapagos Islands a few years ago - Lonesome George, the last giant tortoise of his species, a lumbering, sad-eyed, endearing creature.

On his home island, the plants that he and his kind depended on had been nibbled away by goats brought by sailors, while their eggs were eaten by rats that jumped from the ships. The tortoises themselves used to be carried on board to serve as living larders.

Clearly attitudes to the natural world change over time - and vary between regions.

For a poor villager in Africa, poaching an elephant for its tusks is easy money. For people in China, ivory and rhino horn are important culturally and - wrongly - medicinally.

Conservation is a fairly new idea - ivory used to be a major staple of British Empire trading.

By contrast, I found the sight of a haul of smuggled tusks in Bangkok Airport profoundly depressing. The stench was intense and a customs officer said the ivory "smelled like death".

Unintended effects
Darwin was unsentimental about extinction
So what are the arguments for resisting extinction? One is purely selfish - economics.

For example, if we fish every last tuna, thousands of people in the fishing industry will lose their jobs. Likewise, if every lion or elephant is shot, the tourist trade will suffer. Extinction can cost in hard cash.

Furthermore, there may be unintended effects from eliminating "keystone" species - the loss of one plant or creature in a food chain may affect a whole web that we depend on in some way that we have not yet understood.

In Thailand, I heard that too few tigers could mean too many deer. In turn, that would mean more destruction of vegetation with a knock-on impact on the birds and monkeys that live in the trees.

Another argument is moral - that as the most powerful species on the planet, we have an obligation not to obliterate others, especially if it is through wanton carelessness.

In other words, a mark of civilisation would be to feel responsibility for the survival of weaker species.

A final point that I find compelling is that we are the first species to have gained the remarkable knowledge that every living thing has its DNA at its heart. We all share that.

We may not like everything - ants, spiders, slugs and snakes - but we are related to them. In an extremely loose sense, they are family. And that casts the threat of extinction - and our role in it - in a very different light.

David Shukman's report What's wrong with extinction? will be broadcast in a new programme, BBC News: The Editors, starting on BBC1 on 25 March at 23:15 GMT.
 
Firstly, all creatures on earth have a right to exist whether they're humans or other species. Secondly with certain species becoming extinct you upset the fragile balance of the eco system. For example I once saw a National Geographic special that said that if birds went extinct the earth would be 6 feet deep covered with insects in 4 days! Think on that.
 
Best quote: Charles Darwin was "unsentimental" when it came to extinction. "He certainly did not mourn the passing of the losers," he says.

LOL, the problem with extinction is we go. Our lives depends on complex interrelationships. Take those apart and we're done. But thankfully we're transitioning to robots, so who cares.
 
Firstly, all creatures on earth have a right to exist whether they're humans or other species. Secondly with certain species becoming extinct you upset the fragile balance of the eco system. For example I once saw a National Geographic special that said that if birds went extinct the earth would be 6 feet deep covered with insects in 4 days! Think on that.

i also heard if we had no bees...the world would go hungry within a week.
 
we need a vibrant ecosystem to keep us all alive. the complex web of animals and plants are essential to our well being. perhaps one species may or may not matter but the passing of a species should give us pause
 
I think we make a fuss out of guilt - when the cause of an animal's extinction is related to human activities.
 
When I read the title, I thought you were referring to us going extinct. That would certainly be of benefit to a lot of species currently on the Earth.
 
Firstly, all creatures on earth have a right to exist whether they're humans or other species. Secondly with certain species becoming extinct you upset the fragile balance of the eco system. For example I once saw a National Geographic special that said that if birds went extinct the earth would be 6 feet deep covered with insects in 4 days! Think on that.

Who says all creatures have a right to exist? I say F#$K the mosquitoes! Who stood up for dinosaur rights? How many bacteria have you personally killed with your antimicrobial hand soap and house cleaners?

Ecosystems aren't as delicate as everyone thinks. An area can be completely wiped out and over time, life will adapt to the new conditions in that area and thrive. Bikini atoll/island has plenty of life on it after getting blasted with atom bombs. Something will evolve to survive and make use of the area around Chernobyl.

What everyone seems to forget is that the environment has been changing since life first appeared on earth. Sometimes the changes were man-made, sometimes they were a product of other forces. Life has always found a way to survive. There have been massive extinctions other than the dinosaurs of 65MBC...life found a way to flourish again.

Another issue is that humans don't know what the best environment should be. Were things better during the Jurassic period when temperatures were much hotter? (There was much more biomass then, just look at all of the oil it led to for us). Would it be better if we were in an ice age again. Some species survived and others didn't. Should things stay the way they are right now because it's comfortable for you? The environment will always change and life will always adapt to it...unless the earth gets hit by a large enough asteroid or alien species wipe everything out with ray guns.

just my $.02
 
Best quote: Charles Darwin was "unsentimental" when it came to extinction. "He certainly did not mourn the passing of the losers," he says.

LOL, the problem with extinction is we go. Our lives depends on complex interrelationships. Take those apart and we're done. But thankfully we're transitioning to robots, so who cares.

You are on the verge of something very central to this argument there.

While some past extinctions, with hindsight, have worked to our advantage, the mechanism that caused those extinctions would be very bad for us know.

If you really think about Darwinism, the key concept is that creatures that are adapted well to their environment will survive better than competitors (the other key concept is decent with modification). So in the past, some extinctions changed the environment that allowed mankind to thrive.

However for at least a 100,000 years or so now, the environment has been such that we can dominate. Each extinction changes the complex, interdependent environment that we thrive in. It is possible that an extinction and the follow on effects from that extinction could change the environment in a way that is very bad for us.

Thus, it is in our best interests as a species to work to preserve the environment that we are clearly so well suited for.
 
Extinction is inevitable, eventually humans will fall into that abyss.

And it will happen sooner than our myopic politicians realize.
 
i also heard if we had no bees...the world would go hungry within a week.


LOL I heard that men can pee straight up, and real men are so strong they can be all finished and walk away before it comes back down. ;)