Why is this not a perpetual motion machine

One could have a great mind,...but without accepting knowledge that existed at the time,...???

FAST

Agreed. But I am somewhat surprised that a total all around genius like Da Vinci never saw through the fallacy of perpetual motion machine
 
Agreed. But I am somewhat surprised that a total all around genius like Da Vinci never saw through the fallacy of perpetual motion machine

Thermodynamics is a relatively new discipline in science, and one that is relatively hard to grasp.
 
Anybody can build a perpetual motion machine, depending of course on how you define the concept.

A solar panel with a battery powering an electric motor is a perpetual motion machine.

I an not talking about solar energy capture, at least not at our current levels which is insufficient for our current energy demand. Did you notice that solar panel companies have abysmal stock market performance for a reason?