Why is this not a perpetual motion machine

Yoga Face

New member
Jun 30, 2009
6,307
19
0
The first law of thermodynamics states there is no free lunch: the total energy of an isolated system is constant; energy can be transformed from one form to another, but cannot be created or destroyed. Perpetual motion machines are impossible.

So, why are the unbalanced wheel and overbalanced chain not perpetual motion machines?


 
I found this explanation


A typical application of gravity in a perpetual motion machine is Bhaskara's wheel in the 12th century, whose key idea is itself a recurring theme, often called the overbalanced wheel: moving weights are attached to a wheel in such a way that they fall to a position further from the wheel's center for one half of the wheel's rotation, and closer to the center for the other half. Since weights further from the center apply a greater torque, it was thought that the wheel would rotate forever. However, since the side with weights further from the center has fewer weights than the other side, at that moment, the torque is balanced and perpetual movement is not achieved. The moving weights may be mercury in tubes; the principle is the same.

I do not understand. Does not the wheel and chain keep moving? I did not notice them slowing down
 
Simple answer - friction and air resistance mean the machine loses energy. No matter how small the result, the machine will eventually stop because of it.
 
Simple answer - friction and air resistance mean the machine loses energy. No matter how small the result, the machine will eventually stop because of it.
That is my guess as well.

They are slowing down at such a slow rate they just appear to not be slowing down.
 
It does not work because a siphon requires its output to be lower than the input. That is what I read

I think it means this siphoning process will not last
 
Last edited:
Simple answer - friction and air resistance mean the machine loses energy. No matter how small the result, the machine will eventually stop because of it.

The man is correct,...this is ALWAYS the case.

FAST
 
The man is correct,...this is ALWAYS the case.

FAST

none the less some of our greatest minds from Da Vinci on down tried to build one
 
Simple answer - friction and air resistance mean the machine loses energy. No matter how small the result, the machine will eventually stop because of it.

Friction is a bitch. She will get you every time.

There is no such thing as overunity. I belong to another forum (science based) where the subject is forbidden.
 
And failed

none the less some of our greatest minds from Da Vinci on down tried to build one

One could have a great mind,...but without accepting knowledge that existed at the time,...???

FAST
 
The first law of thermodynamics states there is no free lunch: the total energy of an isolated system is constant; energy can be transformed from one form to another, but cannot be created or destroyed. Perpetual motion machines are impossible.

So, why are the unbalanced wheel and overbalanced chain not perpetual motion machines?
…video omitted…
I'll bite. Because none has continued to operate anything like 'perpetually'? Or even for a very, very long time.

I may be wrong, about that; I'm counting on the well-known Better Mousetrap Effect to have publicized such a 'miracle' enough that we'd have heard of it. Perhaps you have. Do tell.

My bet is that the built machines all stopped when the initial 'surplus' energy input that got them going was inevitably 'consumed' by the friction of air and mechanics.

But the vids and the ideas are fun, and no one should stop asking, experimenting and checking just because a 'law' said something couldn't be done.
 
If plans to unveil such a device came to light, there would be a line up of oil industry players waiting to whack the inventor and their interests. Maybe it has already happened.
 
If plans to unveil such a device came to light, there would be a line up of oil industry players waiting to whack the inventor and their interests. Maybe it has already happened.

Anybody can build a perpetual motion machine, depending of course on how you define the concept.

A solar panel with a battery powering an electric motor is a perpetual motion machine.
 
What about a machine cranked by a human?
There will always be another human to take over, and if there isn't there's nobody to witness the machine stopped so it didn't happen.
 
What about a machine cranked by a human?
There will always be another human to take over, and if there isn't there's nobody to witness the machine stopped so it didn't happen.

That is an inferior perpetual machine to mine.

Remember Arthur C Clarke's 3rd law: "Any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic" and imagine my machine 100 years ago.
 
What about a machine cranked by a human?
There will always be another human to take over, and if there isn't there's nobody to witness the machine stopped so it didn't happen.

Then that is not a perpetual motion machine, because it is feeding off of energy transferred from the body of the cranking humans.
 
ONLY ONE definition,...

Anybody can build a perpetual motion machine, depending of course on how you define the concept.

A solar panel with a battery powering an electric motor is a perpetual motion machine.

"Perpetual motion is motion that continues indefinitely without any external source of energy"

FAST