Why good husbands have affairs

alexmst

New member
Dec 27, 2004
6,939
1
0
http://women.timesonline.co.uk/tol/life_and_style/women/relationships/article4114326.ece

The American counsellor, Mira Kirshenbaum, has written a book called When Good People Have Affairs. It has caused a huge fuss by daring to suggest that long term affairs can be the salvation of a relationship. Kirshenbaum's challenge is that, whatever we say at the altar, there is no finite right or wrong in relationships, just behaviour that works and behaviour that doesn't. The question is - whose behaviour? There is a growing belief that men and women think that they are using the same emotional and ethical software, when in reality they are operating on completely different platforms.

Let's take the most obvious split in behaviour that the revelation of an affair brings out. Men are far more prone to compartmentalise. They file experiences and relationships in different places with never any reason to confuse them.

The darker side is at the heart of one of the most intriguing films to appear in recent years. In Jindabyne, by the Australian director Ray Lawrence, a group of male friends go on a fishing trip. On the first night they find the dead, naked body of a young woman in the river. They secure the body with a line, then carry on with their trip. They tell the police when they get home. The rest of the film deals with the emotional fall-out as the townspeople and their own partners turn on the men.

The film is based on a Raymond Carver short story, So Much Water So Close to Home. The Carver tale turns on an outburst from one of the men, Stuart: “Goddamn it, why can't people mind their own business? Tell me what I did wrong and I'll listen!” Let's imagine a snap poll of readers. Hands up who can tell Stuart what he did wrong? I'm pretty confident that 100 per cent of females will be able to say what he did. So will a good percentage of males. But there will be also be many men who share Stuart's bemusement.

Look at the facts. The men in the fishing party did not kill the girl. They did nothing to the body other than to make it secure. They had a right to carry on with their trip and it would have made no difference reporting the death immediately.Stuart's wife watches in silent fury as he tries to explain: “He gives me what he thinks is a meaningful look. ‘She was dead,' he says. ‘And I'm as sorry as anyone else. But she was dead'.”

Helen Haste, a visiting professor of psychology at Harvard, analyses the scene in terms of the different approaches that males and females have to concepts such as “wrong”. Men are more comfortable with the abstract and the finite. So Stuart's “right” to continue his trip is inalienable. And if someone is dead, they self-evidently don't have the same rights as the living. For Stuart's wife, the issue is just as clear-cut.

Professor Haste says: “Women think in terms of relationships. She wants to drag out an emotional response. So how did they relate to the dead woman - and how did they relate to the other men in the group?” Stuart has sex with his wife before he tells her about the body: it's a dramatic evocation of men's ability to put experiences into different boxes.

I agree that Stuart did wrong. But I understand why he did: there have been too many occasions when I have been caught in the kind of tight space that Carver describes. She wants to know why I didn't say something (about that trip, that lunch). I say something lame such as it wasn't relevant. The defence, which is never good enough for any woman, is that I didn't lie. I just didn't volunteer the information. There's a difference.

As for relating to other men - this is where men are so often a disappointment. Women like you playing golf with your best mate because it is a great opportunity to talk, and that is considered A Good Thing. The truth is, you talk mainly about golf. Male bonding is a phrase that women like to use, but it doesn't mean much. You go fishing to fish, play football to play football. Let's not fly to Mars and Venus, or stray into Emotional Intelligence.

You can follow the link to read the rest. I saw the movie about the fishing trip.
 
Men have sex with other women simply for the thrill of it all. A new body, a new pair of hips, something different, to see if she's good in the sack. We generally don't want to cash in our current relationship because we know that unless the current one is really bad, it won't be worth it. Too much bullshit, too much grief. It's simpler just have sport sex and try to keep it uncomplicated. Besides, the new one will probably just end up like the old one.

Women fuck around largely because they think there is something better out there, or they feel like they are lacking something in their current relationship. Hence why you can't trust women. They are constantly analzing and reanalyzing their relationships.

2 thirds of all divorces are initiated by women.

Monogamy is over rated.
 
Monogamy...

james t kirk said:
Men have sex with other women simply for the thrill of it all. A new body, a new pair of hips, something different, to see if she's good in the sack. We generally don't want to cash in our current relationship because we know that unless the current one is really bad, it won't be worth it. Too much bullshit, too much grief. It's simpler just have sport sex and try to keep it uncomplicated. Besides, the new one will probably just end up like the old one.

Women fuck around largely because they think there is something better out there, or they feel like they are lacking something in their current relationship. Hence why you can't trust women. They are constantly analzing and reanalyzing their relationships.

2 thirds of all divorces are initiated by women.

Monogamy is over rated.


...is GROSSLY over rated.

However, happiness isn't, so....since it will make her happy...and her being happy makes ME happy...I am going to (again) give it (kind of) a try....
 
So then let me ask you guys something....

Why is okay for men to cheat because of all the reasons ever list.....{variety, lack of it at home, etc.} but if a woman cheats, men throw a fit?

Monogamy only seems to be over-rated when it is the man cheating, but the little woman better stay in the house, and her legs closed?

Now of course not all men feel this way but many do. Many, many, many do.

Anyone care to share the reason why?

I can tell you that alot of woman in this world are not sexually satisfied at all. This is not an understatement either. Lord knows I am not. I don't get it near as much as I need or want.

Other woman, many woman don't even get the big "O" from their partners at all. Men wonder why their wives don't want sex... well sorry to tell some of you, if you are not making them cum, why should they waste the 5 minutes laying their back to give you a place a cum? So they don't both wasting time, and the hubbies go and pay an escort who will fake it for the money. Now he is happy because he got the BBBJTCCIMWS, so why can't she go out, find a guy who loves to DATY and a tongue that can move better then a vibrator with 4 brand new batteries, and get her "O" on?

I am not trying to sound in anyway negative, man hating, etc. I swear. Believe me, I understand that many men are in relationships where women don't even care about cumming themselves and have just closed up shop period down there, so I get the struggle that some men go through.

I just want to know why some men, alot of men actually, don't feel that cheating should be an equally acceptable thing for both men and women?
 
Because we expect women to be better than us. We are ruled by raging hormones and women are the cradle of our future, whereas most of the male population is disposable and will be largely forgotten.
 
Because...

KWI said:
So then let me ask you guys something....

Why is okay for men to cheat because of all the reasons ever list.....{variety, lack of it at home, etc.} but if a woman cheats, men throw a fit?

Monogamy only seems to be over-rated when it is the man cheating, but the little woman better stay in the house, and her legs closed?

Now of course not all men feel this way but many do. Many, many, many do.

Anyone care to share the reason why?

I can tell you that alot of woman in this world are not sexually satisfied at all. This is not an understatement either. Lord knows I am not. I don't get it near as much as I need or want.

Other woman, many woman don't even get the big "O" from their partners at all. Men wonder why their wives don't want sex... well sorry to tell some of you, if you are not making them cum, why should they waste the 5 minutes laying their back to give you a place a cum? So they don't both wasting time, and the hubbies go and pay an escort who will fake it for the money. Now he is happy because he got the BBBJTCCIMWS, so why can't she go out, find a guy who loves to DATY and a tongue that can move better then a vibrator with 4 brand new batteries, and get her "O" on?

I am not trying to sound in anyway negative, man hating, etc. I swear. Believe me, I understand that many men are in relationships where women don't even care about cumming themselves and have just closed up shop period down there, so I get the struggle that some men go through.

I just want to know why some men, alot of men actually, don't feel that cheating should be an equally acceptable thing for both men and women?

...as the piece said, women (as a general rule, and I think even you'd agree...if you're the sort of woman who can be an escort, then you aren't a "general" woman) do not compartmentalize things such as this in quite the same way. In other words, for the TYPICAL woman (so, if you are an escort and jumping up and down in protest...you don't count...) such am act is MUCH more than just physical. And the older the woman, the more likely this is to be the case.

That said, I personally think monogamy is overrated for BOTH genders...I think women would be happier (at least prior to marriage) if they dated (and by associated fucked) around more.

However, I have never known...NEVER...a woman who could be COMPLETELY casual about sex. Again, I suppose that is an absolute requirement for an escort, and yes, I know a great number of women have had some one night stands and other said type encounters. I fully recognize this.

But I have never known a woman who could have repeated sex with the same person am not be impacted emotionally on some level, nor have I ever known a woman who could have LOTS of casual sex and not be impacted. Just as valid as you think your stereotype is about men (and it is), this stereotype about women is also valid.

Accordingly, the primary relationship, the marriage, is likely to be impacted. And while I honestly don't care who my wife fucks, I DO care that MY life is not impacted. And that, my dear Kiarra, is the difference.
 
KWI said:
So then let me ask you guys something....

Why is okay for men to cheat because of all the reasons ever list.....{variety, lack of it at home, etc.} but if a woman cheats, men throw a fit?

Monogamy only seems to be over-rated when it is the man cheating, but the little woman better stay in the house, and her legs closed?

Now of course not all men feel this way but many do. Many, many, many do.

Anyone care to share the reason why?



Cultural inheritance...reliable birth control has only been around since the 1960's. The mindset prior to this was that if a woman cheated, she could easily get pregnant. Traditionally a lot of guys wanted children to continue their family line...if a wife cheats and gets pregnant by another man, her husband is perhaps denied the opportunity to continue his line with her (she might only have 1 child since there was little in the way of medicine back in centuries gone by) and will be responsible for paying for the other man's child (no DNA tests in centuries gone by) even though the child is not 'his'. Chastity belts, chaperones, etc were all attempts to prevent sex in order to prevent pregnancy.

In the days of arranged marriages, if the girl escaped the watchful eye of her parents and had sex with a handsome beau, society considered her 'lessened' in some way and that would effect her future marriage prospects. Hence the old 'Is she a virgin?' thing...some cultures still go for that...rember the story from Europe a few months ago about the groom that wanted his marriage voided becasue he found out on his wedding night she wasn't still a virgin - no blood on the sheets or some such nonsense?

So, post 1960's (the sexual revolution was indeed a revolution) women can fool around if they want without the pregnancy risk. Thus, women should have the same right to fool around as men now. However, evolution is slow and a lot of people still have ideas that a woman should keep her legs crossed, while guys are...well, guys. We sow the wild oats and get away with it. Writers have recently tried to come up with derrogatory terms for men who are players, but it never works. "Player", "man-whore", "cad", "rake", etc...they all become meaningless terms without much attachment of stigma. But a woman gets female-specific terms like "slut", "fluzzie", "whore" that carry a lot of stigma in society. There shouldn't be this gulf.

That said, if I ever married (unlikely) I would not want my wife to sleep around, and I would assume she wouldn't want me to sleep around either. But I don't see how my hypothetical sowing of wild oats would be any less or more bad than her hypothetical sexual adventures. Maybe we both would want sexual variety and would chat about our recent conquests and adventures over crumpets and tea on a lazy Sunday afternoon. Or not.
 
MLAM said:
...But I have never known a woman who could have repeated sex with the same person am not be impacted emotionally on some level, nor have I ever known a woman who could have LOTS of casual sex and not be impacted. Just as valid as you think your stereotype is about men (and it is), this stereotype about women is also valid.

Accordingly, the primary relationship, the marriage, is likely to be impacted. And while I honestly don't care who my wife fucks, I DO care that MY life is not impacted. And that, my dear Kiarra, is the difference.


This is also a good point.
 
KWI said:
Why is okay for men to cheat because of all the reasons ever list.....{variety, lack of it at home, etc.} but if a woman cheats, men throw a fit?


Because men want to have the power. ;)
 
KWI said:
Why is okay for men to cheat because of all the reasons ever list.....{variety, lack of it at home, etc.} but if a woman cheats, men throw a fit?

Monogamy only seems to be over-rated when it is the man cheating, but the little woman better stay in the house, and her legs closed?

women will always know who the mother of their baby is. Men can only hope that the baby is theirs. Instinctively men want to ensure that the genes being spread are theirs. They want to ensure that they are spending finite resources rearing and spreading their genes. Men may not understand why they don't want to raise another man's children but they don't. Take a look at a pride of lions as a classic example.

Men are also less likely to share anything. Any toy, any computer, any vagina that they consider "theirs". Women are more prone to share.
 
Compromised said:
women will always know who the mother of their baby is. Men can only hope that the baby is theirs. Instinctively men want to ensure that the genes being spread are theirs. They want to ensure that they are spending finite resources rearing and spreading their genes. Men may not understand why they don't want to raise another man's children but they don't. Take a look at a pride of lions as a classic example.

Men are also less likely to share anything. Any toy, any computer, any vagina that they consider "theirs". Women are more prone to share.


Good point. There will continue to be a double standard until it is 100% mandtory that EVERY child is paternity tested at birth. That way Paternal fraud (& more importantly in this context the Fear of it) is completely eliminated. It HAS to be universal & mandatory or else there will be an air of suspicion whenever a man has to ask for it. No chance for bluffing on the woman's part & no pussying out on the man's. It just gets done every time & there is no judgement implied by the process.

This will Greatly level that playing field because:

- A man who cheats had better not get the other woman pregnant or it Will Come out

- A woman who cheats had better not get pregnant with the other man's kid, because there is No way she'll be able to hide it her little bundle of someone else's love

- Either partner will either think twice about cheating
OR take more thorough precautions (which may also lessen STDs)
OR if they do neither THEY WILL GET CAUGHT



It will be difficult to totally eliminate the double standard.... but after a few decades of that the cultural issues behind the double standard should lessen. Once a couple generations go by were Men no longer had a rational cause for suspicion that any kid of thiers wasn't.... Then I think we'd possibly see a more liberal attutide towards female infidelity.
 
I think just as many women cheat as men.

Maybe even more so. I remember the Hite Report on Female Sexuality claimed that the rate of infidelity between the sexes was approximately equal and in the area of 70 percent. She (Hite) was roundly criticized for that statistic, however, I firmly believe it to be true.
 
Everything I have read...

james t kirk said:
I think just as many women cheat as men.

Maybe even more so. I remember the Hite Report on Female Sexuality claimed that the rate of infidelity between the sexes was approximately equal and in the area of 70 percent. She (Hite) was roundly criticized for that statistic, however, I firmly believe it to be true.

...says women cheat less than men...but A LOT more than men think they do.

Something like 60 to 70% of married men have cheated at least once, and 40 to 50% of married women.

Like I said in another thread...so many guys want to BELIEVE their wives are frigid, and thus justify their fucking around by saying they dont' get it at home. Reality is, somewhere between 25 to 50% of you guys are just fucking lame in bed, and your wives are tired of faking it, so they give you the cold shoulder and fuck someone else....

Man...I am kind too old and fat for that shit now...plus I have enough going on...but let me tell you...MWFs used to be my FAVORITE "hobby"...LOL
 
KWI said:
So then let me ask you guys something....

Why is okay for men to cheat because of all the reasons ever list.....{variety, lack of it at home, etc.} but if a woman cheats, men throw a fit?

SIZE]


Do you really think that women get less upset about men cheating than men do about women cheating ?

On an individual level I think it's the other way around. On a general level it's less of a surprise perhaps that a man cheated but that is the extent of it.