http://women.timesonline.co.uk/tol/life_and_style/women/relationships/article4114326.ece
The American counsellor, Mira Kirshenbaum, has written a book called When Good People Have Affairs. It has caused a huge fuss by daring to suggest that long term affairs can be the salvation of a relationship. Kirshenbaum's challenge is that, whatever we say at the altar, there is no finite right or wrong in relationships, just behaviour that works and behaviour that doesn't. The question is - whose behaviour? There is a growing belief that men and women think that they are using the same emotional and ethical software, when in reality they are operating on completely different platforms.
Let's take the most obvious split in behaviour that the revelation of an affair brings out. Men are far more prone to compartmentalise. They file experiences and relationships in different places with never any reason to confuse them.
The darker side is at the heart of one of the most intriguing films to appear in recent years. In Jindabyne, by the Australian director Ray Lawrence, a group of male friends go on a fishing trip. On the first night they find the dead, naked body of a young woman in the river. They secure the body with a line, then carry on with their trip. They tell the police when they get home. The rest of the film deals with the emotional fall-out as the townspeople and their own partners turn on the men.
The film is based on a Raymond Carver short story, So Much Water So Close to Home. The Carver tale turns on an outburst from one of the men, Stuart: “Goddamn it, why can't people mind their own business? Tell me what I did wrong and I'll listen!” Let's imagine a snap poll of readers. Hands up who can tell Stuart what he did wrong? I'm pretty confident that 100 per cent of females will be able to say what he did. So will a good percentage of males. But there will be also be many men who share Stuart's bemusement.
Look at the facts. The men in the fishing party did not kill the girl. They did nothing to the body other than to make it secure. They had a right to carry on with their trip and it would have made no difference reporting the death immediately.Stuart's wife watches in silent fury as he tries to explain: “He gives me what he thinks is a meaningful look. ‘She was dead,' he says. ‘And I'm as sorry as anyone else. But she was dead'.”
Helen Haste, a visiting professor of psychology at Harvard, analyses the scene in terms of the different approaches that males and females have to concepts such as “wrong”. Men are more comfortable with the abstract and the finite. So Stuart's “right” to continue his trip is inalienable. And if someone is dead, they self-evidently don't have the same rights as the living. For Stuart's wife, the issue is just as clear-cut.
Professor Haste says: “Women think in terms of relationships. She wants to drag out an emotional response. So how did they relate to the dead woman - and how did they relate to the other men in the group?” Stuart has sex with his wife before he tells her about the body: it's a dramatic evocation of men's ability to put experiences into different boxes.
I agree that Stuart did wrong. But I understand why he did: there have been too many occasions when I have been caught in the kind of tight space that Carver describes. She wants to know why I didn't say something (about that trip, that lunch). I say something lame such as it wasn't relevant. The defence, which is never good enough for any woman, is that I didn't lie. I just didn't volunteer the information. There's a difference.
As for relating to other men - this is where men are so often a disappointment. Women like you playing golf with your best mate because it is a great opportunity to talk, and that is considered A Good Thing. The truth is, you talk mainly about golf. Male bonding is a phrase that women like to use, but it doesn't mean much. You go fishing to fish, play football to play football. Let's not fly to Mars and Venus, or stray into Emotional Intelligence.
You can follow the link to read the rest. I saw the movie about the fishing trip.
The American counsellor, Mira Kirshenbaum, has written a book called When Good People Have Affairs. It has caused a huge fuss by daring to suggest that long term affairs can be the salvation of a relationship. Kirshenbaum's challenge is that, whatever we say at the altar, there is no finite right or wrong in relationships, just behaviour that works and behaviour that doesn't. The question is - whose behaviour? There is a growing belief that men and women think that they are using the same emotional and ethical software, when in reality they are operating on completely different platforms.
Let's take the most obvious split in behaviour that the revelation of an affair brings out. Men are far more prone to compartmentalise. They file experiences and relationships in different places with never any reason to confuse them.
The darker side is at the heart of one of the most intriguing films to appear in recent years. In Jindabyne, by the Australian director Ray Lawrence, a group of male friends go on a fishing trip. On the first night they find the dead, naked body of a young woman in the river. They secure the body with a line, then carry on with their trip. They tell the police when they get home. The rest of the film deals with the emotional fall-out as the townspeople and their own partners turn on the men.
The film is based on a Raymond Carver short story, So Much Water So Close to Home. The Carver tale turns on an outburst from one of the men, Stuart: “Goddamn it, why can't people mind their own business? Tell me what I did wrong and I'll listen!” Let's imagine a snap poll of readers. Hands up who can tell Stuart what he did wrong? I'm pretty confident that 100 per cent of females will be able to say what he did. So will a good percentage of males. But there will be also be many men who share Stuart's bemusement.
Look at the facts. The men in the fishing party did not kill the girl. They did nothing to the body other than to make it secure. They had a right to carry on with their trip and it would have made no difference reporting the death immediately.Stuart's wife watches in silent fury as he tries to explain: “He gives me what he thinks is a meaningful look. ‘She was dead,' he says. ‘And I'm as sorry as anyone else. But she was dead'.”
Helen Haste, a visiting professor of psychology at Harvard, analyses the scene in terms of the different approaches that males and females have to concepts such as “wrong”. Men are more comfortable with the abstract and the finite. So Stuart's “right” to continue his trip is inalienable. And if someone is dead, they self-evidently don't have the same rights as the living. For Stuart's wife, the issue is just as clear-cut.
Professor Haste says: “Women think in terms of relationships. She wants to drag out an emotional response. So how did they relate to the dead woman - and how did they relate to the other men in the group?” Stuart has sex with his wife before he tells her about the body: it's a dramatic evocation of men's ability to put experiences into different boxes.
I agree that Stuart did wrong. But I understand why he did: there have been too many occasions when I have been caught in the kind of tight space that Carver describes. She wants to know why I didn't say something (about that trip, that lunch). I say something lame such as it wasn't relevant. The defence, which is never good enough for any woman, is that I didn't lie. I just didn't volunteer the information. There's a difference.
As for relating to other men - this is where men are so often a disappointment. Women like you playing golf with your best mate because it is a great opportunity to talk, and that is considered A Good Thing. The truth is, you talk mainly about golf. Male bonding is a phrase that women like to use, but it doesn't mean much. You go fishing to fish, play football to play football. Let's not fly to Mars and Venus, or stray into Emotional Intelligence.
You can follow the link to read the rest. I saw the movie about the fishing trip.

