Why does Canadian programming (tv and film) suck ?

theycallmebruce

Active member
Nov 17, 2002
1,106
1
38
So I am watching the Canadian Screen Awards and have absolutely no clue who the actors/actresses, tv shows and movies are? WTF

is up with that?
 
Its because of the CBC. Instead of having a free market-based entertainment industry in which excellence is recognized and earns the funding need to produce, based on talent, we have an entertainment industry in which the 800 pound gorilla is run by bureaucrats. Entertainment bureaucrats, but bureaucrats all the same. So internal-to-CBC politics determines much of what gets funded. It sucks away the meagre financial resources available for Canadian entertainment, preventing true talent from getting a place in our living rooms (and it bleaches the talents of those entertainers directly employed by the CBC).

In short, because the Canadian entertainment industry is socialist, drawing everything towards the middle. Too bad.
 
It also depends what you pay attention to. If you like Brit TV and Film, you'll be aware of that industry. Same goes for French, Italian, Chinese or any other Film/TV industry.

I am quite well aware of 'War Witch' and was cheering for it's Oscar nomination last week. Brilliant though they were, "Incendies" and "Monsieur Lahzar" did better overseas than domestically.

This goes way beyond the CBC. Canadians should pay more attention to their own films and TV and not let the US ad monster swallow us all up.
 
It was simply a question?

If you look at the list of nominees,

http://www.academy.ca/awards/nominees.cfm

you'll notice many are names who were nominated in recent international competitions like the Oscars, BAFTA, Palm D'Or, or the SAG's. and many are for Quebec productions, which have always been way ahead of the english screen productions, largely because the Quebec Government historically supports the arts far more more than anywhere else in Canada, especially at the federal level.

It's clear you don't watch many homegrown films or much tv; Mr D, Arctic Air, Bomb Girls, War Witch, titanic, Rookie Blues, Murdoch Mysteries, Flashpoint.
 
I don't watch Canadian programming because it is not that good. Believe me, I would love to watch something made in Canada and be proud, but that just isn't happening. So I guess I do live in a Bell Jar :(
 
I don't watch Canadian programming because it is not that good. Believe me, I would love to watch something made in Canada and be proud, but that just isn't happening. So I guess I do live in a Bell Jar :(

As DD indicated, fortunately others outside our country think differently. Some of those TV series I listed have been award winners and syndicated outside Canada; someone likes them.
 
Its because of the CBC. Instead of having a free market-based entertainment industry in which excellence is recognized and earns the funding need to produce, based on talent, we have an entertainment industry in which the 800 pound gorilla is run by bureaucrats. Entertainment bureaucrats, but bureaucrats all the same. So internal-to-CBC politics determines much of what gets funded. It sucks away the meagre financial resources available for Canadian entertainment, preventing true talent from getting a place in our living rooms (and it bleaches the talents of those entertainers directly employed by the CBC).

In short, because the Canadian entertainment industry is socialist, drawing everything towards the middle. Too bad.

A brilliant analysis....absolutely brilliant...
 
for the record, the highest canadian grossing motion picture. Guess what it was? Bon Cop Bad Cop. Really???? This is what people see in Canada? that's a joke...
 
for the record, the highest canadian grossing motion picture. Guess what it was? Bon Cop Bad Cop. Really???? This is what people see in Canada? that's a joke...

Much that was because it appealed to both language markets in canada and did well oversea, no mystery.
 
A brilliant analysis....absolutely brilliant...

Except it doesn't wash.

In countries like Australia, which has both privately owned and national networks, the National ABS is the flagship by which all others are measured.

In Canada the Quebec industry is constantly seen as better than the english counterpart and it gets more goverment support. Free market doesn't necessarily mean better.

As far as talent is concerned, the list is endless of the personalities who have taken their skill to other market and shone brightly, succeeding in more than one. Anyone, who really who work in the industry, will tell you we, as a group, are better in the technical end than the US as well.
 
So I am watching the Canadian Screen Awards and have absolutely no clue who the actors/actresses, tv shows and movies are? WTF

is up with that?

It's that giant magnet called the USA (specifically Hollywood) that sucks up all the top Canadian talent. Let's face it, it is the dream of almost every Canadian in the entertainment business to make it big in the US. More money, more visibility, more everything.

Basically we get the leftovers.
 
many reasons why Can film is mediocre.

First, the US film industry is accessible for many with talent and connections and many go to LA to try their luck - a la Elisha Cuthbert, Neve Cambell, Mike Myers, Jim Carrey. When your top end talent leaves town, it sucks away a lot of the potential.

Second, the govt gives generous tax breaks but directs them to a handful of established companies which get rich producing B-grade shit for the local market. There is little real competition or incentive to produce decent innovative drama when you know the same 10 companies are going to get all the funding and when they have an assured market - due to CanCon - for almost any garbage they throw on the screen. Politically, the saving grace is that these productions provide jobs for an entire small army of techies and bit players who would otherwise work as plumbers and waiters respectively.

Third, more "cutting edge" drama is selected by CBC bureaucrats who choose based on connections and pretentious funding proposals. So you get the Atom Egoyan or Cronenburg bullshit productions as your "sophisticated art house film" contribution.

All in all, a sad state of affairs. Probably government intervention at its most uninspired.
 
It's that giant magnet called the USA (specifically Hollywood) that sucks up all the top Canadian talent. Let's face it, it is the dream of almost every Canadian in the entertainment business to make it big in the US. More money, more visibility, more everything.

Basically we get the leftovers.

Big money, sure, it is the US. Leftovers not really.
 
Except it doesn't wash.

In countries like Australia, which has both privately owned and national networks, the National ABS is the flagship by which all others are measured.

In Canada the Quebec industry is constantly seen as better than the english counterpart and it gets more goverment support. Free market doesn't necessarily mean better.

As far as talent is concerned, the list is endless of the personalities who have taken their skill to other market and shone brightly, succeeding in more than one. Anyone, who really who work in the industry, will tell you we, as a group, are better in the technical end than the US as well.

Don't you get my sarcasm by now?
 
many reasons why Can film is mediocre.

First, the US film industry is accessible for many with talent and connections and many go to LA to try their luck - a la Elisha Cuthbert, Neve Cambell, Mike Myers, Jim Carrey. When your top end talent leaves town, it sucks away a lot of the potential.

Second, the govt gives generous tax breaks but directs them to a handful of established companies which get rich producing B-grade shit for the local market. There is little real competition or incentive to produce decent innovative drama when you know the same 10 companies are going to get all the funding and when they have an assured market - due to CanCon - for almost any garbage they throw on the screen. Politically, the saving grace is that these productions provide jobs for an entire small army of techies and bit players who would otherwise work as plumbers and waiters respectively.

Third, more "cutting edge" drama is selected by CBC bureaucrats who choose based on connections and pretentious funding proposals. So you get the Atom Egoyan or Cronenburg bullshit productions as your "sophisticated art house film" contribution.

All in all, a sad state of affairs. Probably government intervention at its most uninspired.

You know nothing about the movie industry in Canada. Sorry but you are spreading crap based on what? I don't know.

It stems from who gives out he funding and those people are devoid of any reality associated with the US industry. The top tier of "Canadian film" industry wouldn't get a job fluffing up the grip guys in the USA.
 
Funding is run by militaristic homos, anti-white refugees and the most fucked up people you will meet in your life. If you film doesn't glorify homosexuality, or have a refugee as a hero or is just plain fucked up- it won't get funding.

They hate white. They hate outspoken. The industry hates anything "edgy". It's a joke and will be for the next decades.

Go pitch an Anti- Catholic, pro homo movie that has a Indian female (dot or feather- doesn't matter) as a hero and you'll get funding. As a bonus make it boring and every white guy is a pedophile and you will get millions to make that movie.

Riiiiiiight!! Perhaps you can supply us with a few names that fit your profile? Somehow i doubt it.

How did the divorce go?
 
It washes, and it is a brilliant analysis. Are you guys industry insiders? CBC part-timers? It would explain why you are defending the beast that is preventing Canadian talent from bursting forth. Nay say all you want, CBC is crap. Unless your tastes are grossly pedestrian or you 'work' there. Sad but true. And not sad.