Why conservatives deny global warming

TOVisitor

New member
Jul 14, 2003
3,305
0
0
A fascinating argument, one that I wish I had articulated.

The question was asked yesterday why conservatives deny global warming. To help answer the question, readers were pointed to an interesting piece over at Balloon Juice (http://www.balloon-juice.com/?p=9096) hypothesizing that the energy industry has blockaded the sunlight of truth in a fashion similar to that done by the tobacco industry decades earlier.

In that post, Tim F. correctly noted that science is really non-partisan, and that confronting and averting disaster should be in everyone's best interests, including that of conservatives.

The only question is why the right wing felt such a compelling need to get behind it this time. Is there something inherently liberal about avoiding catastrophe?

Unfortunately for Tim, for conservatism, and for the world, the answer is, sadly: yes. In this case, yes there is something inherently damaging to conservatives about avoiding this catastrophe.

There were many alternative explanations presented for this: some speculated millennarian religious reasons for failure to care about the future health of the planet, while others postulated that the international cooperation necessary to mitigate the problem was seen as a threat to American sovereignty; still others postulated simple contrarianism against anything promoted by liberals, while yet others hypothesized fear of economic troubles associated with taking action on global warming. And, of course, there were the standard appeals to simple greed and corruption in catering to energy industry interests.

Yet none of these theories seem to be adequately satisfactory in explaining why Republicans would stand in the way of action on an issue that is so critical to the future of the human race, and likely to be such a huge issue in election after election from this day forward. Not every Republican leader is a nutcase, yet they all deny manmade global warming; it seems unlikely that the same President that tried to give our ports to Dubai and ram an "amnesty bill" down his own party's throat would stand against global warming for reasons of national sovereignty; the last 7 years should tell any serious observer that the Republicans don't give a hoot about long-term health of the economy; sheer contrarianism won't cut it either--just look at the way the GOP backed down on Social Security when they realized they couldn't win that battle.

So why keep up the fight? Why do they do it?

The answer, in my view, is as simple as it is profound: the need to take climate change seriously is a threat to the entire premise of modern conservative thought--specifically the deification of untrammelled free markets.

The ideology most under threat from worldwide acceptance of the necessity to act in mitigating global warming is the idea of the "Free-Market." This baleful philosophy holds as its guiding principle the idea that--given enough time--corporations in a free-market system unfettered by governmental (i.e., consumer and labor) regulation will provide the greatest variety of products and services at the lowest prices to the greatest number of people. It also holds that unswerving allegiance to this principle will result in greater worldwide prosperity, increased jobs, and a brighter future for the world's citizens.

Most arguments against this Friedmanist view of the world are made from an economic standpoint: the unregulated free market has led to ever-wider income inequality, the strangulation of the middle class, massive personal and governmental debt, and a host of other economic problems detrimental to the healthy function of democratic society.

But the problem with this ideology is much deeper than these outward symptoms suggest. The fundamental problem is that free markets left untended by the hand of government tend to be extremely greedy and short-sighted; left unchecked, they can produce an effect not unlike that of the islanders who chopped down every last tree on Easter Island without a thought for the morrow.

Global warming is a problem that not only points to an utter failure of the free market system, but also cannot be assuaged by appeals to fear or to a continued stay of patience on the part of the world's increasingly suffering population.

The fact that a problem of such momentous impact has gradually arisen under the watchful eyes of our quarterly-report-obsessed Wall Street bureaucrats with nary the movement of a little finger to stop it is itself proof of the myopic blindness (not to mention selfish greed) that afflicts a purely market-driven system. It is proof of a failure of long-term thinking and visionary planning in pursuit of higher and higher record corporate profits.

But the fact that global warming is an autocatalytic process--i.e., one whose negative impact will increase, feeding off itself--means that there IS NO MORE TIME. The threat is upon us NOW--and if nothing is done to stop it NOW, soon nothing will be able to stop it.

And the corporations in the free market certainly won't be able to stop it themselves.

It could, in fact, be argued that the entire move toward environmental sustainabiliity is a threat to capitalism itself--as understood by conservatives, at any rate. A system of all individuals acting solely from momentary self-interest and demanding incessant growth, without the interference of a more far-sighted governmental authority, is anathema to the needs of mankind and of the planet in the 21st century.

Consider the policy implications of taking climate change seriously. "We have always known that heedless self-interest was bad morals," said F.D.R. "We know now that it is bad economics."

These words apply perfectly to climate change. It’s in the interest of most people and especially their descendants that somebody do something to reduce emissions of carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gases, but each individual would like that somebody to be somebody else. Leave it up to the free market, and in a few generations Florida will be underwater.

Simply put, conservatives cannot afford for the climate crisis to be taken seriously. If it is, their ideological goose is cooked.

And much as Republicans are willing to stand on such a precarious footing as opposing health care for children, just so that Democrats cannot have the opportunity to prove that government-provided health care actually works, so much more so must they stand their ground on opposing action to mitigate climate change. Their very existence as a viable ideological entity depends on it.

After all, if unbridled greed and self-interest brought us to this pass--and united governmental effort throughout the world helps solve it--what Reaganesque arguments for the evil of "big government" will conservatives credibly be able to ply in the future?

The climate crisis is, in a very real sense, the most significant of many issues from nuclear proliferation to globalized economics that are stretching the credibility of the conservative movement to offer any meaningful solutions. The politics of radical self-interest have no role to play in solving problems that are global in scale and horrific in consequence.

Unfortunately for the world, conservatives hell-bent on maintaining what is now a thoroughly outmoded ideology will stop at nothing--even environmental or martial holocaust--to preserve that ideology at all costs.
 
Last edited:
Or maybe...

Conservatives are just funamentally stupid???:rolleyes:
 
I think there are conservatives who deny global warming.

I think there are conservatives who question how much of global warming is caused by man.

I think there are conservatives who question how over-hyped global warming is.

At the end of the day if you drive a car with more than 4 cylinders, live in more than 1,500 sq ft, fly private jets.... you don't really believe in global warming, or at least you don't believe about doing anything to change it.

OTB
 
I don't like to pigeonhole my political views to a particular ideology. On some issues I have a left leaning point of view but, for the most part my politics tends to lean to the right. So, for arguments sake, let's call me a conservative.

I believe global warming is a real issue and that humans are contributing to the problem.
 
onthebottom said:
I think there are conservatives who deny global warming.

I think there are conservatives who question how much of global warming is caused by man.

I think there are conservatives who question how over-hyped global warming is.

At the end of the day if you drive a car with more than 4 cylinders, live in more than 1,500 sq ft, fly private jets.... you don't really believe in global warming, or at least you don't believe about doing anything to change it.

OTB

Shorter BOT:

"Who cares anyway? Might as well get all that I can. I want mine, so f**k everybody else."
 
TOVisitor said:
Shorter BOT:

"Who cares anyway? Might as well get all that I can. I want mine, so f**k everybody else."

The title of your post is inaccurate. Not all conservatives deny global warming.
 
TOVisitor said:
Shorter BOT:

"Who cares anyway? Might as well get all that I can. I want mine, so f**k everybody else."

I'll take a moment and treat you with more civility and temperance than your maturity or intelligence warrant and respond:

I didn't mean that at all, what I meant was that wringing your hands about global warming and waiting for someone else to fix it, while living a lifestyle in conflict with your view, is at best disingenuous.

OTB
 
onthebottom said:
I didn't mean that at all, what I meant was that wringing your hands about global warming and waiting for someone else to fix it, while living a lifestyle in conflict with your view, is at best disingenuous.

OTB
No, I'd say it's more like realizing the car you're in is headed for a cliff and the brakes don't seem to be working all that good.
 
The republicans are for big businesses, this global warming talk could cost them $$$ if they have to make changes to stop global warming.

Thats how I see it, profits always come first for the republicans.
 
Asterix said:
No, I'd say it's more like realizing the car you're in is headed for a cliff and the brakes don't seem to be working all that good.

But how do you know the brakes don't work if you don't try pushing them yourself.....

OTB
 
onthebottom said:
But how do you know the brakes don't work if you don't try pushing them yourself.....

OTB
What, now you're channeling old Kung Fu episodes? Look, until governments stop jerking around and agree to cooperate in a real way to address climate change, we're toast. The number of coal burning plants China plans to have on line in the next 4 years alone, stand a good chance at burying us.
 
Asterix said:
What, now you're channeling old Kung Fu episodes? Look, until governments stop jerking around and agree to cooperate in a real way to address climate change, we're toast. The number of coal burning plants China plans to have on line in the next 4 years alone, stand a good chance at burying us.

Abdicating any personal responsibility? Canada, a well meaning country, signed such agreements, how have Canada's emissions changed since that agreement was signed?

OTB
 
onthebottom said:
I think there are conservatives who deny global warming.

I think there are conservatives who question how much of global warming is caused by man.

I think there are conservatives who question how over-hyped global warming is.

At the end of the day if you drive a car with more than 4 cylinders, live in more than 1,500 sq ft, fly private jets.... you don't really believe in global warming, or at least you don't believe about doing anything to change it.

OTB

How about those of us who drive small 4 cylinder cars (ie with 1.5 - 1.8 litre engines), live in small (ie 1200 sq ft) semi-detatched houses but who insist on taking a couple of flights a year? BTW, for a trip to Seattle or San Francisco from Toronto, does air travel emit more carbon than driving? Lets say you drive 3000 miles instead of flying 3000 miles? Which is worse?
 
slowpoke said:
How about those of us who drive small 4 cylinder cars (ie with 1.5 - 1.8 litre engines), live in small (ie 1200 sq ft) semi-detatched houses but who insist on taking a couple of flights a year? BTW, for a trip to Seattle or San Francisco from Toronto, does air travel emit more carbon than driving? Lets say you drive 3000 miles instead of flying 3000 miles? Which is worse?

I was flipping through the channels last night and came accross a show on HGTV called "Living with Ed". The program has been around for a while but it was the first time I've seen it. If you haven't seen it, it's worth a watch.

http://www.livingwithed.net/

I gained a lot of respect for Ed Beggly Jr. He's certainly more deserving of praise than Al Gore.

The program is very well done and quite funny. His wife Rachelle is very hot too. :D
 
onthebottom said:
But how do you know the brakes don't work if you don't try pushing them yourself.....

OTB

Here you have the problem in a nutshell.

According to BOT's philosophy, this is all a problem of personal responsibility and government has no role in helping to create a solution. That is exactly the point of the starting post of this thread.

Conservatives expect people alone to solve the problem, when it is more than just individuals that are creating the problem -- business has a role to play in the creating the problem and in finding a solution, and yet we do not hear anything from BOT about that.

Governments must get business to cooperate on a solution, but THAT would be against all conservative principles -- that governments can be the solution, rather than the problem (as Saint Ronnie would claim).
 
Whether global temperature increase is due to human activity is controversial.

However, some are claiming that the debate is over. I think that these people are using global warming as an excuse to try to increase statism.

I think that Global Warming is the Democrat version of the War on Terror and is just another excuse to increase the size and scope of government.

While the debate continues, I see no problem with individuals taking personal responsibility for conservation.
 
At the end of the day if you drive a car with more than 4 cylinders, live in more than 1,500 sq ft, fly private jets.... you don't really believe in global warming, or at least you don't believe about doing anything to change it.


In other Words if your Al Gore...... ,
 
slowpoke said:
How about those of us who drive small 4 cylinder cars (ie with 1.5 - 1.8 litre engines), live in small (ie 1200 sq ft) semi-detatched houses but who insist on taking a couple of flights a year? BTW, for a trip to Seattle or San Francisco from Toronto, does air travel emit more carbon than driving? Lets say you drive 3000 miles instead of flying 3000 miles? Which is worse?


Are you really flying private jets.... I doubt it.

OTB