Why are some countries more advanced than others?

solitaria

New member
Jun 1, 2005
737
0
0
I was reading that "Live 8 - Long Walk of Justice" thread where Shake is trying to free KKKathleen's mind from her racist notions and conceptualizations but she has her big-time blinders on thinking she can argue a boxed argument of nationalistic pride to defend her position, wrongly thinking that the arbitrary divisions of political geography is meaningful enough to define humanity and its potential and destiny. I couldn't imagine not questioning my reality on a deeper level than that but I guess that is why politicians have such a fun time with the masses since they have such a shallow perception of a much deeper reality.

I like Shake's argument about why the people on the African continent can't lift themselves out of poverty and it is true that 1st world nations such as the United States purposely suppress the progress of 3rd world nations in the name of capitalism and to exploit and control resources. His realization that most of our opportunities and successes in life arise from the "accident of birth" is very true and I have felt the essence of that observation many times when I was living in a 3rd world country for a period of 6 months.

I would like to ask a slightly different question though to understand the origin of poverty in a more meaningful way. Most of us know why poverty is perpetuated but how does it start? Why have some societies developed at a faster rate enabling them to exploit others and gain a stranglehold on them? I have my own answers but I would like to hear other people's perspectives to gain a better insight on the matter.
 
define "advanced"

It depends, I think, on what one means by "advanced." In a purely materialistic sense, then the West has it. But if you mean culturally and historically, then probably India or China is the most advanced.

So it helps to be a little clearer about the terms, especially when seeing the world from an admittedly Western perspective.
 
happygrump said:
It depends, I think, on what one means by "advanced." In a purely materialistic sense, then the West has it. But if you mean culturally and historically, then probably India or China is the most advanced.

So it helps to be a little clearer about the terms, especially when seeing the world from an admittedly Western perspective.

Okay I will define "advanced" by freedom to pursue goals/dreams without repression/restrictions of some kind. Obviously there is no such thing as total freedom within any society just degrees.
 
I think there are 2 reasons.

First So many of these countries have repression of the people through corrupt governments or wars that have been going on for decades. The concept of individual rights has not been put in place stifiling crativity and quite often ambition.

Second. This kind of relates to the first point. Because of the repression, many countries have not gone through an industrial revolution. Europe went through it during the rennissance, and it took decades to achieve. Most technologies that third world countries have, have been brought in from more advanced countries. Educational systems are lacking, jobs are nearly impossible to come by, and because of this markets are stagnant.

Wealth breeds wealth, this is not a new concept. If a factory opens in a new town, jobs are created not just in the factory, but in other businesses as well. Construction of new houses, food stores, retail outlets, etc. In my opinion the G8, Live Aid and the charities are going about solving the problems the wrong way. What should be foucsed on is industry, which will generate it's own capital and increase living standards just by the fact of existence.
 
a 1 player said:
In my opinion the G8, Live Aid and the charities are going about solving the problems the wrong way. What should be foucsed on is industry, which will generate it's own capital and increase living standards just by the fact of existence.

A1, you may be right, but I think you're putting the proverbial cart before the horse.

In order for a home-grown industry to develop, a country needs an educated workforce, infrastructure, regulations, an absence of corruption and a host of other fundamentals.

The best analog I can come up with is this: One doesn't teach a drowning person to swim. First, you throw them a life ring. Once they're safe, then you teach them to swim.

I believe what the G8 needs to do is to fix the immediate short-term needs first, then look at ways that these countries can re-invent their social norms to support a wealth-growing industry.
 
Try Jared Diamond's Guns, Germs, and Steel. He gives a very believable account of how and why civilization developed in a historical and geographical context. (Some time this summer I'll pick up his new book on why civilizations fail)

As for why there is poverty, simply because enough people with power don't want to share. I also think that economic support for development won't be enough to power the undeveloped world without creating conditions that allows the culture in those contries to develop to a point where they are ready for capitalism.
 
solitaria said:
I would like to ask a slightly different question though to understand the origin of poverty in a more meaningful way. Most of us know why poverty is perpetuated but how does it start? Why have some societies developed at a faster rate enabling them to exploit others and gain a stranglehold on them? I have my own answers but I would like to hear other people's perspectives to gain a better insight on the matter.

Just a thought, most of the third world countries are in hot climates so food was easier to gather and their development was slower while the first world nations had to develop at a faster rate b/c they require shelter to survive and food supply was more scarce. We went through the industrial revolution while some 3rd world countries never. Now we abuse those 3rd world countries for our consumption.
 
simple answer

Certain countries rob and pillage other countries for money and power.

Would we be talking about the Middle East if they did not have oil.

Would be talking about Africa if they did not have the largest resources in the world.

Some people call it colonialism.

Look at the history of "Great Britain", that should answer your question.
From India to China to Africa to the Middle East they have applied there Divide and Conquer techniques, time and time again.

Personally, I think Live 8 is a joke. Bob Geldof obviously needs money.

Talking about Africa is like talking about World Peace, ain't never gonna happen. :mad:
 
solitaria said:
I would like to ask a slightly different question though to understand the origin of poverty in a more meaningful way. Most of us know why poverty is perpetuated but how does it start? Why have some societies developed at a faster rate enabling them to exploit others and gain a stranglehold on them? I have my own answers but I would like to hear other people's perspectives to gain a better insight on the matter.
I think the answer to 'how does it start' is power and greed and the effect that has on societies priorities.

In looking at ancient times, the power bases in the then 'civialized world' were the city kingdoms. And through wars they became nations - to control their environments.

In other areas such as Africa and North America the indigeonous cultures had grown to live with nature; to respect nature's power instead of trying to control it.

Through our greed, the decendents of the old European cultures have convinced themselves that "wealth" is meassured by material posseions and power; and have over time brainwahed others into believing it too. After all, most people regardless of their culture, are just trying to build a better life for themselves and their families.

Unfortuanelty by now, the 'poor' nations are about two hundred years behind the '1st world' nations and can't make up for the time difference without a lot of help, growing pains and time.
 
happygrump said:
I believe what the G8 needs to do is to fix the immediate short-term needs first, then look at ways that these countries can re-invent their social norms to support a wealth-growing industry.

Unfortunately, in the 20+ years we have been supporting these countries, very little has gotten any better. It is true a bowl of rice might make a child live another day, but it is an ongoing money pit in my opinion (not trying to start a war with anyone here). The problem with most charities is that they look at the effect and not the cause. You know, catch a man a fish and feed him for a day, teach a man to fish and feed him for a lifetime.

I do not believe that higher education is totally necessary in the short term for most of the workers. I am not talking about building mammoth computer corporations or the like. Mining, forestry, manufacturing, tourism, smelting, light assembly. All can be done with very little eductaion if any at all. There are many, many investors that would be more than happy to run organizations from other countries if they thought they would get a good ROI. In fact, most of these jobs have been done by children (and in some cases still are) at some point, and in some countries.

(I know this will piss some people off), but I have no issues making purchases from companies that use child labour in developing countries, so long as it is not slave labour. This give a person an opportunity to get paid, no matter how meager, a chance to buy food, a chance for survival. We are blessed in Canada to be in a country where the poorest of the poor is infinately more rich, and has a better standard of living than the average person in a third world country. In fact the standard is so good here, we do not allow children to work. We have social programs, minimum wages in place; Canada really is the land of milk and honey!

I guess what I am saying is that we need to find new solutions to old problems. The old ways are just not working, and the way things are going, there is no end in sight that I can see without radically changing what we perceive support to be.
 
a 1 player said:
I guess what I am saying is that we need to find new solutions to old problems. The old ways are just not working, and the way things are going, there is no end in sight that I can see without radically changing what we perceive support to be.

Quite true, actually.

An interesting (but rarely talked about) problem with food aid is that it undercuts local markets. In theory, Africa should be able to feed itself (there are obvious exception, primarily related to drought-impacted nations). One of the reasons that basic agri-business is not developing in Africa, though, is because it is cheaper to bring in food from Western Countries rather than grow it domestically. In fact, countries such as Canada and the United States often make food importation a requirement of they aid that they provide (essentially subsidizing their own farmers). Not surprisingly, it creates situations of long-term dependency.

Your "teach a man to fish" comment is rather trite & simplistic. The lack of clean drinking water and the impact of treatable/preventable diseases (notably malaria) have to be addressed before broader economic development can occur. To their credit, there are a number of NGO's (including several funded by the Canadian government) that have focussed on these basics in contrast to the traditional "fill the beggars bowl" approach. In some countries, Tanzania for example, the results are encouraging.

That said, your overall message is reasonably sound. Simply throwing money at the situation will not ever solve it. New ideas, including greater accountability by African governments, are needed if the problem is ever to be solved.
 
Winston said:
...
But one has to sit back and ask, are we any happier, driving in our SUV's and watching the world through the distorted window we call TV, then someone in Africa?

I agree. I often think if it is helping to go to some undeveloped nation, tell them their poor, and "help" them by trying to make them like us. It seems to be just the continuation of the imperialist era "White Man's Burden" to make the world a better place.

The movie The Gods Must be Crazy is a good example. We go in and give them things they don't need just so we feel that we've been helping them.

Yes, it is sad to see famine and disease wipe out a population but all that the medical and food aid are doing is perpetuating the problem. If we insist on changing others way of life, the first step would be to change their culture so the western democratic/industrial ideals will work instead of just trying to feed people.
 
The rich countries are rich because they speak English and those who speak English were "civilized" by William of Orange who brought the Dutch Republic culture to Britain. So in essence, the Glorious Revolution of 1688 is what marked English supremacy in diplomacy. And since the Americans are off-shoots of the English, they have taken over their role. From Pax Britannica to Pax Americana.

But, had Louis XIV won his wars and had Napoleon defeated Russia, we would all be speaking French. And as you all know, French was the language of diplomacy. To push the point further, had Hitler won the war, we would all be speaking German.

What is ironic is that the defeated Axis Powers from WWII remain great powers (not super powers) in Germany and Japan and Italy barely making it thanks to her fashion and auto industry (just joking). I mean, those Germans and Japanese definitely have their shit together. Perhaps it has something to do with their culture and they way they do things? Perhaps it is the British way of doing things that has made her, her colonies and her children (eg. Canada, Australia) and off-shoots (USA) rich?

The Brits are generalized as a nation of Protestant shop keepers and the Americans as Calvinist and Lockeans. Perhaps there is a common thread which runs through English culture that makes their country/countries rich or advanced?

Nonetheless, I totally agree with the poster who said that advancement means more democracy because, after all, the end goal of human history is freedom.
 
holden said:
Just a thought, most of the third world countries are in hot climates so food was easier to gather and their development was slower while the first world nations had to develop at a faster rate b/c they require shelter to survive and food supply was more scarce. We went through the industrial revolution while some 3rd world countries never. Now we abuse those 3rd world countries for our consumption.

holden is correct. Necessity/Need forces more innovative ways to survive. If you live in an environment where food is scarce, you need creative ways to produce food. You development technologies to survive (crop rotation, plows, tractors, etc..). Not just food. If the environment is cold, you develop ways to keep yourself warm. The "unfit" is weeded out quickly. In a more comfortable environment, the need to be creative is not needed. Think of the body... if you live a comfortable, relaxed life, the body goes soft and weak. If you push it hard, stress it, work it, you get in better shape. Another example is how during war, many technological innovations happen. The competition and the desperation to get that edge.

So some countries develop quicker giving them the edge that makes it so hard for the slower developing countries to compete against
 
Don said:
holden is correct. Necessity/Need forces more innovative ways to survive. If you live in an environment where food is scarce, you need creative ways to produce food. You development technologies to survive (crop rotation, plows, tractors, etc..).


Food is scarce in Ethiopia and I would hazard a guess that they are not known for technological advancement. Sometimes nature has delt a region the double blow of arid land and heat.

I agree with the observation that poverty seems to be much more prevalent the closer you are to the equator. Exceptions are oil producing regions I guess.

Add political, religious and ethnic/tribal instability to the mix.
 
train said:
Food is scarce in Ethiopia and I would hazard a guess that they are not known for technological advancement. Sometimes nature has delt a region the double blow of arid land and heat.

I agree with the observation that poverty seems to be much more prevalent the closer you are to the equator. Exceptions are oil producing regions I guess.

Add political, religious and ethnic/tribal instability to the mix.
It is the struggle for food/water/shelter (the basics of life) that drove the formation of tribes - groups beyond the single family unit.

Everything else is driven by the desire to control others - power over competetors/enemies; and greed - own more land, more cattle, more resources.
 
Winston said:
In the state of nature, life is nasty brutish and short.

Aid does more harm than good. And the policies of the western countries towards the third world is always done with an eye on self interest.

The US is selling genetically modified seed to the third world, seed that will not produce seed bearing plants, so the farmer becomes dependant upon the US agribusiness. Almost all "aid" is tied to buying goods and services from the "donating" country.

But one has to sit back and ask, are we any happier, driving in our SUV's and watching the world through the distorted window we call TV, then someone in Africa?

Why do you have to bring the USA as the only example?

Most European nations have provided foreign aid much longer than the USA.

Foreign aid is misguided charity, because all foreign aid assumes or presumes, that "these people should be like us".
This is were it has gone wrong. with the aid send we are trying to force our way of live on to a complete different culture.
How do we meassure progress?What is the success scale for it?
Should everybody in Africa have an SUV?a nice house?be catholic?have a 401K? a cottage by the lake? or what?
isn't it a little arrogant of us to expect that they embrace the our values?

Another problem created by foreign aid is, that most of the money goes to the goverments. This creates an artificial "goverment economy' that flourishes seperate from the economy of the people. In fact the foreign aid money makes the goverment independent from their own people.
 
holden said:
Just a thought, most of the third world countries are in hot climates so food was easier to gather and their development was slower while the first world nations had to develop at a faster rate b/c they require shelter to survive and food supply was more scarce. We went through the industrial revolution while some 3rd world countries never. Now we abuse those 3rd world countries for our consumption.


I also believe this is why we are ahead of other nations in the world at this point in time. However, in human history, different regions of the world have been in many ways ahead of the now western world, including some regions that are close to the equator. It could be that it is just our turn to be leading the pack at this one point in human history.

In many African countries they seem to have the technology to produce food, which allows for the populations to increase. Problem being when the technologies fail, it is a big problem for the people who do not have the money to buy food from other parts of the world.
 
langeweile said:
Should everybody in Africa have an SUV?a nice house?be catholic?have a 401K? a cottage by the lake? or what?
isn't it a little arrogant of us to expect that they embrace the our values?

YES! YES! YES! and YES!

If everyone in Africa had an SUV, think about the potential sales? Not only that, the after sales services is what really generates long terms profits!

If everyone in Africa could have a nice house, think about the spin off industries the housing market can produce.

They aren't all Catholic, but spreading Western faiths such as Christianity and Catholicism is always a top priority! Colonize for the flag and the cross!

401K? Damn straight man! That's another investment market. Think about all the money that is being pooled in?!?!?!

Cottage by the lake ... oh yeah baby ... CHING $$$ CHING $$$ CHING ... build a community around a golf course and charge premium prices, another huge money maker!!!

Think about all the money and profits!!!

isn't it a little arrogant of us to expect that they embrace the our values? - It's not arrogance ... it's winners of wars who decide what is moral. I am surprised you mentioned this considering you quote Nietzsche in your signature line. Dr. Nietzsche also wrote "as long as it is life advancing, specie preserving ... it is beyond good and evil" which means, if it is advancing Western civilization and culture, preserving Western civilization and culture, it is beyond good end evil. So why would it be "arrogant"?