Why All the Shooting Threads on TERB?

Keebler Elf

The Original Elf
Aug 31, 2001
14,845
507
113
The Keebler Factory
I've noticed a trend of postings reporting shootings.

Why?

Is this supposed to be some kind of political statement? Or more fear mongering? Or just a race to be the "first" to report it?
 
I've noticed a trend of postings reporting shootings.

Why?

Is this supposed to be some kind of political statement? Or more fear mongering? Or just a race to be the "first" to report it?

Unfortunately they often have a racial and/or police element, and this tends to attract the likes of Skyrider and nottyboi and their ilk, in much the same way that a turd attracts flies. No disrespect intended towards turds.
 
I started one to-day (don't think I started any other ones) about Christie Pits because it has a bit of a personal connection as I sometime go there to watch the Maple Leafs play and see the MLB oldtimers on opening day. I have no idea about the race of the victims or the shooter(s).
 
It seems some posters are wanna-be journalists and seem to think that board members don't have access to news sites. So as soon as a news story hits, they rush to post it on terb, hoping to be the first one and thus get the "scoop". I suppose they get some satisfaction out of this.
 
I can't avoid these thread sometimes. I think people assume my politics are far left leaning but the reality is that I just don't care for generalizations when it comes to race.

Unfortunately I find often generalizations are thrown about in these threads.

I also find that people oversimplifying social problems is insulting to those facing the problems.

These two types of attitudes pose major barriers for change.

I'm all for social change and to make the place a better world for future generations and I think it really has to start with empathy and not dismissing other people's problems.

I think it's easy for some to think well it's not my problem "they" are just shooting each other but the social cost to us is immense. Let's say the person is caught each year it costs us 100K to house one prisoner...... that doesn't even account for all the costs that get the person to that point.
 
Terb is the place to be to learn of traffic problems as well. :dance:
Also, discussing health issues (e.g. cracked rib, prostate, laser eye surgery, etc.). There's also one member who is constantly asking if he is overpaying for cable.

There will be shooting threads as long as there are shootings in society. Two more men shot in Dodge City last night --- Dundas Square this time.
 
I can't avoid these thread sometimes. I think people assume my politics are far left leaning but the reality is that I just don't care for generalizations when it comes to race.

Unfortunately I find often generalizations are thrown about in these threads.

I also find that people oversimplifying social problems is insulting to those facing the problems.

These two types of attitudes pose major barriers for change.

I'm all for social change and to make the place a better world for future generations and I think it really has to start with empathy and not dismissing other people's problems.

I think it's easy for some to think well it's not my problem "they" are just shooting each other but the social cost to us is immense. Let's say the person is caught each year it costs us 100K to house one prisoner...... that doesn't even account for all the costs that get the person to that point.

I think that's a great place morally, but it's a terrible place to actually solve anything.

The problems that these shootings illustrate are not individual problems: they're societal or cultural problems. By that token, you HAVE to approach it from the generalization point of view.

Person X got shot by the police.

Generalizations: they're very likely to have a criminal record. They're very likely to have been acting in at least an irresponsible fashion, if not an illegal fashion. They're likely to have had mental problems.

If you look strictly at race, they're more likely (as a percentage of population, not in absolute numbers) to be African American. OTOH, if you're looking at the population of those with criminal records (a strong secondary indicator of someone who would be shot), they're actually less likely than other races. That's the stat that isn't getting enough attention.

Are there white kids with no criminal record who are acting in a 100% responsible and legal fashion who get purposely (ie- not hit by a missed shot) shot and killed by the police? I'm sure it has happened at some point. And while individually tragic, that isn't something that rises to the level of national crisis. Given the reporting on police shootings right now, I think it's reasonable to consider the other shootings to be at a crisis level.

So: if you have a demographically consistent population that is getting shot by the police, I think it's worth exploring what is happening from a demographic, big picture POV. Don't you?
 
I've noticed a trend of postings reporting shootings.

Why?

Is this supposed to be some kind of political statement? Or more fear mongering? Or just a race to be the "first" to report it?

Because it's in the news a lot, and people on Terb like to discuss politics when they're not PMing other members with "so, what did her pussy lips look like?" questions.
 
Something is not right with the world. The SJW craze is sparking racial debates, maybe there is something in the water supply or its a trend.
 
Because it's in the news a lot, and people on Terb like to discuss politics when they're not PMing other members with "so, what did her pussy lips look like?" questions.

But many of these "news reports" are posted without comment, opinion or observations - just a link to a news site. If the primary motivation were to discuss, one would think that the thread starter would offer a comment or an observation. But when all that is posted is a link to a news site, it's a little bit like playing news anchor, to keep the terb community informed (as if we don't have access to news sites on our own).
 
But many of these "news reports" are posted without comment, opinion or observations - just a link to a news site. If the primary motivation were to discuss, one would think that the thread starter would offer a comment or an observation. But when all that is posted is a link to a news site, it's a little bit like playing news anchor, to keep the terb community informed (as if we don't have access to news sites on our own).

Because a lot of the people posting them already have an established position in the debate, so just posting the link is their way of saying "See! Like I was saying before!!!"
 
Two more men shot in Dodge City last night --- Dundas Square this time.


Thanks SkyRider. Like most TERB'tes (except you) my internet only connects to TERB and I have no access to news. And my TV and radios also do not get news stations.

I also rely on you for weather reports! Just cancelled my flight to Hong Kong! Thanks again!

 
But many of these "news reports" are posted without comment, opinion or observations - just a link to a news site. If the primary motivation were to discuss, one would think that the thread starter would offer a comment or an observation. But when all that is posted is a link to a news site, it's a little bit like playing news anchor, to keep the terb community informed (as if we don't have access to news sites on our own).

I usually like to add a comment/question or two to start the conversation. Of course, almost every subject we discuss in The Lounge comes from public sources. The exception would be the personal questions like: "I caught my wife fcuking my best friend. What should I do now?"

For example, did we really need all the posts on the Forcillio shooting or the Marco Muzzo DUI? Everything is already covered in the media.
 
I think that's a great place morally, but it's a terrible place to actually solve anything.

The problems that these shootings illustrate are not individual problems: they're societal or cultural problems. By that token, you HAVE to approach it from the generalization point of view.

Person X got shot by the police.

Generalizations: they're very likely to have a criminal record. They're very likely to have been acting in at least an irresponsible fashion, if not an illegal fashion. They're likely to have had mental problems.

If you look strictly at race, they're more likely (as a percentage of population, not in absolute numbers) to be African American. OTOH, if you're looking at the population of those with criminal records (a strong secondary indicator of someone who would be shot), they're actually less likely than other races. That's the stat that isn't getting enough attention.

Are there white kids with no criminal record who are acting in a 100% responsible and legal fashion who get purposely (ie- not hit by a missed shot) shot and killed by the police? I'm sure it has happened at some point. And while individually tragic, that isn't something that rises to the level of national crisis. Given the reporting on police shootings right now, I think it's reasonable to consider the other shootings to be at a crisis level.

So: if you have a demographically consistent population that is getting shot by the police, I think it's worth exploring what is happening from a demographic, big picture POV. Don't you?

The generalizations you have made are completely reasonable.

I'm not saying ALL generalizations are bad.

One that particularly bothers me is when people say things like "the black community supports crime." To me there is a big difference between fearing coming forward to help vs supporting.

Anyways, that was quick and off the top of my head. I agree with you that if generalizations come from stats that's one thing (and fine) but there are others which I find are based more on stereotypes and assumptions.

As someone else pointed out sometimes I find the posting of news by certain people has the "see I told you so" vibe to it where they seem to want to paint Muslims, Feminists, Blacks in a certain way.

But again not all news sharers act like that. I mean when there was the boxing day shooting I think it was posted pretty quickly but I think in that case it was more a sense of shock that got people talking.

I referred to this finding in the past but it doesn't seem to change people's views on carding, racial profiling etc

But in 2001, the Legislature asked for a racial profiling study and it fell to Kearney, then at the Institute on Race & Poverty at the University of Minnesota Law School, to conduct it. His study, using information supplied voluntarily by 65 law enforcement jurisdictions in the state, found a strong likelihood that racial and ethnic bias played a role in traffic stop policies and practices. Overall, officers stopped minority drivers at greater rates than whites and searched them at greater rates, but found contraband in those searches at lower rates than whites.