Whose heads should roll and by what method in Katrina ?

maryland

Banned
Nov 18, 2004
280
0
0
The mayor in New Orleans that up to 10,000 people might be dead under the water in New Orleans. This is more than 3 times of 9/11, whose anniversary is fast approaching.
The obvious question is:
Who is responsible and should be held accountable to the world's people ?
Whose "heads" should roll and by what methods ?

Possible blame are on:

1. National Weather Service ?

2. Head of FEMA ?

3. Mayor of NO ?

4. Goevernor of LA ?

5. Rumsfeld ?

6. Homeland Chief ?

7. The press ?

8. The Internet Services ?

9. Bushie ?

10. National Guard ?

11. All of the above ?
 
I blame it on the rain
 
The National Weather Service. There's a guy in Peru named "Pedro" who needs to take some of the blame, but mostly it's the National Weather Service. They are just justifying their own existence by having all these "Hurricanes".
 
Head of FEMA should be fired immediately. Handled the disaster woefully. Does not have the competence or qualifications for the job.
 
Katrina, Katrina, Katriana! What I want to know is where the hell is Bobbi?
 
Not sure it actualy matters who messed up. But experience tells me the ones making the most noise tend to be the ones to look to for blame.
 
The storm was caused by powers well beyond even the omnipotent "Shrub."

The problem is the disparity between the "haves" and the "havenots" which to a large extent was caused by the policies of enhancing the middle class and the wealthy; policies that were entrenched by Ronald Reagan.

CNN's coverage has exposed for all the world to see, the vast and poorly treated underclass in the U.S. that has been hidden by over spending, government spinning and media partisan behavior.

This is the same underclass that has been sent to Iraq and Afghanistan to die to protect the life-style of the wealthy upper classes in La-La Land.

Democracy is a great concept.To bad it hasn't been tried yet.

God help the Yanks if the underclass ever gets self-mobilized.
 
I forget what news cast it was on but someone said that the US actually got relief to the tsunami stricken countries faster than they got aid to NOLA. That is pretty effed up.

Who's fault it is will never be finally realized or they punished for it.

If I read correctly before anyone could react the politicians of the stricken area had to 'formally' request aid before fema could react. That didn't happen as those politicians were too busy trying to get things going.

This also applied to Canadian Aid. We can't just send 3 warships and thousands of people down to render aid if it is not 'formally' requested.

Once again our governments at work. Private citizens (like that truck driver in London) is gathering up provisions and driving down but we can't just lend a hand to our neighbours......
 
Goober Mcfly said:
The National Weather Service. There's a guy in Peru named "Pedro" who needs to take some of the blame, but mostly it's the National Weather Service. They are just justifying their own existence by having all these "Hurricanes".
Yes, he's the guy that started El Nino.
Damn Peruvians!!!!
 
Some perspective from when Andrew hit South Florida:

http://www.sptimes.com/2002/webspecials02/andrew/day1/story1.shtml

So on Aug. 16, 1992, when the National Weather Service reported a tropical depression forming 3,500 miles away near Africa, few paid attention.

But by Sunday, Aug. 23, Hurricane Andrew was closing in on South Florida. Panicked shoppers jammed grocery and hardware stores. The highways clogged. More than 700,000 people evacuated, though many went only a few miles. Thousands more decided to stick it out.

...Fifteen people were killed during the storm and another 25 later died of indirect causes. Andrew demolished more than 25,000 homes and damaged another 100,000. It flattened the air base. Of the 1,176 mobile homes in Homestead, all but nine were destroyed.

...
Five days after the storm, Maj. Gen. Richard B. Griffits landed in Homestead with 23,000 troops, the biggest peacetime domestic military operation in U.S. history. The devastation stunned him.

"I had never seen a place completely leveled in all directions," Griffits later recalled. "There was a smell to it. A smell of utter destruction."

Gwendolyn Sherman, now 23, has vivid memories of those jittery, pitch-black nights. With no way to cool the house, "we left the doors open, so I was nervous with all the looting that was going on."

When George Brown spotted some thieves, he chased them away at gunpoint. "They didn't want to talk to Mr. Twelve Gauge," he said.

Sunrise brought the rumble of portable generators, the pounding of hammers and the constant whir of helicopters that scared the migrant workers who thought they were about to be strafed.

From above, the battered cul-de-sac seemed to blend in with all the other battered neighborhoods. Andrew caused an estimated $30-billion in damage and left a quarter-million people homeless.

In the first few days, no rescue agency sprang to action fast enough to help the storm's victims. People went days without water. Hungry residents queued up for hours for food that never arrived.

--------------------------

Funny, I don't remember the response to ANDREW being anywhere near as political as KATRINA, and the suffering seems very similar.
 
Girth said:
...Fifteen people were killed during the storm and another 25 later died of indirect causes. Andrew demolished more than 25,000 homes and damaged another 100,000. It flattened the air base. Of the 1,176 mobile homes in Homestead, all but nine were destroyed.

15 people died. It's a trajedy but it in no way compares to N.O.
How do you compare 15 lives to possibly thousands? It's been reported that a few hundred are already comfired dead. How do you compare a trailor park and 125 thousand homes to an entire city and most of Louisiana?
They haven't even begun to estimate the damage, monetary wise, that was left in Katrina's wake. The two hurricanes are not even comparable.
I think I see what you're getting at in terms of politics but I fail to see the similarities in this case. The only similarity is that both victims of the two hurricanes were mostly impoverished.
Was Florida under water? Did it have corpses floating around like ducks?
 
The ideal punishment for whoever is at fault is easy. Lock them is a room and bombard them with endless, idiotic posts. It's driven me insane.
 
I'm sorry, did someone put a gun to your head and make you read?
If you don't like to read the posts regarding the hurricane and aftermath, perhaps you should stay away from the threads that are talking about it.
Just a though. :rolleyes:
 
Most of the brass at the New Orleans police dept.

Instead of organizing into a cohesive force the NOPD fell apart. Instead of maintaining order, some officer participated in the looting. Those who didn't wandered around aimlessly without leadership or direction.

No doubt they were overwhelmed by the situation but they could have done a LOT more to maintain order. In some cases they appear to have lost control of the situation because they didn't have the *moral* authority to stop the looting: the other looters could see that the PD were looting too!

The PD should have used their authority to take the initiative to instill order in the "looting" process, perhaps by overseeing the removal of necessary items from stores like water/food/medicine while preventing the removal of non-necessary items like DVD's. They could have been seen to be distributing these supplies to citizens, marking down what was taken, etc., but instead they were seen to be looters.

I know their comms were down and such, but police maintained order in cities for centuries before there were radios. It is possible to act like a police force even when you don't have a radio! I suspect there are deep problems with this force that led to its collapse, and therefore, the brass should be fired and replaced by people who can actually form an organization.
 
ruck said:
15 people died. It's a trajedy but it in no way compares to N.O.
How do you compare 15 lives to possibly thousands? It's been reported that a few hundred are already comfired dead. How do you compare a trailor park and 125 thousand homes to an entire city and most of Louisiana?


You don't, the damage in the Gulf Coast is 10-20 fold the damage done in South Florida. But even in that disaster, it was difficult to react and provide aid to those affected. The lessons learned in Florida in recent years should have allowed NO and the Gulf Coast area to prepare better evacuation plans and command and control in the aftermath. If I were to play the blame game, I'd focus on the State and local officials, particularly in Louisiana rather than Mississippi before I'd beat up on the Federal Govt.

The Mayor of NO is an asshat, particularly with his remark that his police force should be treated to a trip to Vegas for their efforts in the first 6 days. Talk about a sense of entitlement.
 
Girth said:
The Mayor of NO is an asshat, particularly with his remark that his police force should be treated to a trip to Vegas for their efforts in the first 6 days. Talk about a sense of entitlement.

I totally agree with you there. The police force, a good portion of them, in NO needs to be stripped of their badges and sent to their water logged homes. It's disgraceful to see the face of law break down and resort to looting and have a "every man for themselves" mentality.
The looting could have been slightly averted had the face of authority actually acted like authority.

The only problem with the whole blame game is that nobody wants to be "it".
I think it's a federal issue especially after the fact. Yes the state was ill prepared but the citizens were well informed of the potential life threatening situation. The citizens who were able to leave but didn't are a bunch of idiots. So what if hurricanes have passed over before. Would it kill you to leave and then come back if nothing happened? After the fact, the federal government should have learned their lessons from the Florida tragedy and should've been better prepared to send help well before 5 DAYS.
 
I followed CNN closely from the beginning. Every time they interviewed that tool, michael brown (even the first day after Katrina hit), all he could talk about was getting Carnival cruise liners. You could see how excited and proud he was of this incredible idea to save lives. :rolleyes: Meanwhile the greatest human suffering seen in the US this century was being documented on the news, especially at the Convention Centre. When they asked Brown about the Convention Centre (the other venue where most survivors were), his answer was he was not even aware there were people there. The newspeople were dumbfounded "Don't you watch the news? How could you not know". His asinine answer to that was: "There' s pockets of people all over and they can't know where everyone is". I noticed on Saturday, Carnival cruise liners docking into N.O. Congratulations. You got your cruise liners. How do these people sleep at night?
 
maryland said:
Who is responsible and should be held accountable to the world's people ?

Whose "heads" should roll and by what methods ?

Possible blame are on:

1. National Weather Service ?

2. Head of FEMA ?

3. Mayor of NO ?

4. Goevernor of LA ?

5. Rumsfeld ?

6. Homeland Chief ?

7. The press ?

8. The Internet Services ?

9. Bushie ?

10. National Guard ?

11. All of the above ?

And what , no blaming on us terbites :eek: !?!
 
The place for blame is clear...

Either nuke Iran...

Or fire Dubya.

It just depends whether you are left wing or right wing. :D
 
They don't know what to say next about their attempted burial of 10,000 impoverished survivors at Superdome. The latest on CNN was some drivel about a "strategic preservation of assets to keep rescue vehicles away from the epicentre so they would be undamaged and available in the aftermath". Then of course the devastation was so vast they needed two days to plan their first deployment. The truth is obvious. They dug a mass grave for these people who refused to lay down and die. They never suspected anyone would pay any attention to them, let alone make them the centre of attention. Nothing left to do but shrug off wrongdoing and deploy a rescue. Now you see them going to the homes of people they know are going to refuse aid and rescue, so they can say they tried. Noone is going to be able to twist the authorities arms hard enough to make them cry uncle. Why try? A lifetime could be wasted in a battle of wills. It took the Vatican 60 years to apologize for the holocaust. That was cold comfort at best.