He could be giving her the best sex of her life. We don't know. You guys assume that the saying "Size matters" means the larger size matters. That is not true at all.
Every vagina is a different size and therefore not every cock is going to be the right size for her.
There is a size that really works for me, but I will admit I had a client who I use to see, who had a very small penis. He gave me some of the best orgasms during intercourse. Why? Because he would go down on me, tease the shit out of me and then when the main event happened, I felt like I was being being teasing tortured. It was small so it felt more like being fingered. It works for me. I like a bit of orgasm denial and the teasing nature of it all was awesome, so it worked for me.