Who is responsible for contractor cleanups

spankingman

Well-known member
Dec 7, 2008
3,639
321
83
So I hired a contractor who did work for the Ins.Co. wglhen had a basement flood in JULY. Culprit was a broken cast iron pipe leading out to the city sewer system. House is 73 hearts old. He" seemed like a great guy and his work seemed pretty good
He repaired the damaged ceiling and was doing some minor patching in the walls etc. Due to injuries and surgery I can't do this type of stuff anymore.

I did fi d him pushy aggressive money grabbing trying to cut corners .traits he did NOT show when doing the work for the Ins. Co.
I've fought with him re clean ups after jobs as my house is a dust bowl. It's in our eyes nose mouth hair EVERYFUCKING WHERE!! It came to. a head today with this mess and this is good compared to yesterday. I fired his ass out here today fed up with delays late everyday or no-show .Likely working 2-3 different jobs at the same time. My question is WHO does the job cleaning up. We are getting the house ready to sell in June July iin Hamilton.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_20230307_151651119.jpg
    IMG_20230307_151651119.jpg
    56 KB · Views: 38
  • IMG_20230307_151641325.jpg
    IMG_20230307_151641325.jpg
    49.4 KB · Views: 41
  • IMG_20230307_151641325.jpg
    IMG_20230307_151641325.jpg
    49.4 KB · Views: 39
So I hired a contractor who did work for the Ins.Co. wglhen had a basement flood in JULY. Culprit was a broken cast iron pipe leading out to the city sewer system. House is 73 hearts old. He" seemed like a great guy and his work seemed pretty good
He repaired the damaged ceiling and was doing some minor patching in the walls etc. Due to injuries and surgery I can't do this type of stuff anymore.



I did fi d him pushy aggressive money grabbing trying to cut corners .traits he did NOT show when doing the work for the Ins. Co.
I've fought with him re clean ups after jobs as my house is a dust bowl. It's in our eyes nose mouth hair EVERYFUCKING WHERE!! It came to. a head today with this mess and this is good compared to yesterday. I fired his ass out here today fed up with delays late everyday or no-show .Likely working 2-3 different jobs at the same time. My question is WHO does the job cleaning up. We are getting the house ready to sell in June July iin Hamilton.


Typically the contractor but doesn’t sound like hired a 5 Star kind of guy.

Can also depend on arrangement you make with him.

When dealing with contractors of any star amount of stars you should put everything on the table and decide specifically what’s going to happen… from nails to garbage etc
 
  • Like
Reactions: LTO_3
Yes the contract must state that Contractor must clean everything up and lay tarp on the floor.
Since he is fired you are fried.
5 star contractor is a crap shoot. Sometimes they won't serve certain parts of a city if to busy.
 
Agree with what's already been said. Hopefully you didn't pay him the full amount since it sounds like he didn't complete the job, including cleanup. Often there's always some mess such as dust - drywall dust is the worst! - that can't always be cleaned up but if the contractor does it right that should be kept to a minimum.


LTO_3
 
Last edited:
I hired a guy to do weeping tiles, and waterproofing in an old house. He knocked out the bottom 3 basement stairs, and part of my deck...and it was all on me to fix all the shit once him and his idiot step kids left
 
If you sign an agreement with a contractor there should be a clause there that states that he's responsible for all Cleanup that's usually the way its works there should also be a 15% holdback till the completion of the job
 
If you sign an agreement with a contractor there should be a clause there that states that he's responsible for all Cleanup that's usually the way its works there should also be a 15% holdback till the completion of the job
Lien holdback must be 10%. You can add another holdback for warranty, etc. Most residential contractors will balk at both.
 
I have never hired a contractor that didn’t clean up their own work and I have had entire homes remodelled a couple of times now. And lived in the renovation as it was being done.

Everything was taped off, plastic put up for dust when doing big things like sanding the mudding on the drywall. And even then it still gets everywhere with foot prints but he would clean that too on his way out there door

I admit I am lucky I think in the contractor that I found. I used him in the beginning of his career. Over 15 years ago and will be using him again for a project hopefully being able to be done next year. I can’t imagine him not cleaning. His quality of work is outstanding. My house looks exactly the same as it did when we were finished the reno. Just a little lived in of course.

You need to research and check with past jobs. Don’t just take testimony. Actually see if you can contact past customers.

Now that you have fired him; you are kinda screwed.
 
As a retired electrician we always. Cleaned up whatever mess we made. You can't get into walls without making a mess. We always had shop vac and contractor bags with us. When I was an apprentice I was told always do you best to leave someone's house they way you would leave yours. If you don't they will always remember the mess regardless of the quality of the work.
 
It is a hit and miss game , unless you have a proven contractor that has worked with you a few times.

Reason being, they know that most of us would not pursue it in courts due to the expense, time and inconvenience to us.

My approach is a good research, go to their current jobs, speak to the customer, and if they don't want to sign a detailed contract, be aware.

Also the week, or few days ate critical, of their performance os lacking in that period do not hesitate to fire them.
Although I do most of the stuff myself, in the last major project in which a contractor was involved, I fired 2 during the first 2 weeks of the project.

Of course a cost is in-cured, so keep the initial downpayment, low and a close set of eyes at the beginning .
 
It is a hit and miss game , unless you have a proven contractor that has worked with you a few times.

Reason being, they know that most of us would not pursue it in courts due to the expense, time and inconvenience to us.

My approach is a good research, go to their current jobs, speak to the customer, and if they don't want to sign a detailed contract, be aware.

Also the week, or few days ate critical, of their performance os lacking in that period do not hesitate to fire them.
Although I do most of the stuff myself, in the last major project in which a contractor was involved, I fired 2 during the first 2 weeks of the project.

Of course a cost is in-cured, so keep the initial downpayment, low and a close set of eyes at the beginning .

Should have been “the first days and week are critical “
 
Usually if you have a great contractor - they will clean it up and leave it in great condition as they will want that referral after the job is done. I never understood these fkrs doing half as jobs - do they not need the work? - do they have enough jobs to keep them going? You would think they would want to do an awesome job to continue to grow their business.
 
Did you include the cost for cleanup in your contract? I'm going to guess no.

From my point of view, he's responsible for a cleanup of his immediate area. Not your whole house. Doesn't matter if it's his demolition dust or not. That's collateral damage. As someone who has spent allot of time renovating my own homes and others, I can absolutely assure you there is no fucking way on the planet to eliminate dust in a major construction project. You can mitigate it at best.

So his immediate area yes, your whole house spotless, no.

I would suggest you hire a professional cleaning service to come in and clean the place spotless. Your contractor is a tradesman, not a maid. If he did a good quality job on his subject work, consider yourself fortunate. Even Holmes on Homes hired a professional cleaning service.
 
Lien holdback must be 10%. You can add another holdback for warranty, etc. Most residential contractors will balk at both.
Agreed, Its pretty standard with commercial work but with all the demand for residential out there today contractors can afford to have a take it or leave it attitude for now. most legit companies will agree to leave the site clean and ready for use.
 
So I hired a contractor who did work for the Ins.Co. wglhen had a basement flood in JULY. Culprit was a broken cast iron pipe leading out to the city sewer system. House is 73 hearts old. He" seemed like a great guy and his work seemed pretty good
He repaired the damaged ceiling and was doing some minor patching in the walls etc. Due to injuries and surgery I can't do this type of stuff anymore.

I did fi d him pushy aggressive money grabbing trying to cut corners .traits he did NOT show when doing the work for the Ins. Co.
I've fought with him re clean ups after jobs as my house is a dust bowl. It's in our eyes nose mouth hair EVERYFUCKING WHERE!! It came to. a head today with this mess and this is good compared to yesterday. I fired his ass out here today fed up with delays late everyday or no-show .Likely working 2-3 different jobs at the same time. My question is WHO does the job cleaning up. We are getting the house ready to sell in June July iin Hamilton.
I had some contractors doing work in my house including drywalling which generates a ton of dust and debris. They did the basic cleanup but I hired a cleaning service to do the deep clean
 
I had some contractors doing work in my house including drywalling which generates a ton of dust and debris. They did the basic cleanup but I hired a cleaning service to do the deep clean
Was the girl in your sig pic on the cleaening crew?
If so I would be buying drywall duts by the bagfull!
Especially for all the low spots.