While we're at it, let's decriminalize sex work.

Since C-36 targets the buyers but grants immunity to the SW, couldn't a charter challenge arise from the deprivation of the SW's right to make a living? Not sure if that falls under "security of the person", but surely that's gotta be one beef to make?

Relevant tweet by @AnthonyNMorgan: The great human rights Charter challenge would be about poverty. But of course, as a poor person, you cannot bring a Charter challenge.

IMHO economic security rights are poorly developed in Charter case law. But personally I think that the deprivation of livelihood is a strong argument against C-36.
 


I say decriminalize prostitution entirely and treat sex work as work.


I agree completely.

But how can this be accomplished?


Decriminalization is the first step towards reducing stigma against the industry, and make it easier to redress wrongs; as it currently stands, there is limited recourse when SPs or their clients have their rights infringed.

C-36 criminalizes aspects of the industry that make sex work more dangerous by limiting the ability to clearly advertise their services and screen clients.
.

Exactly! The very issue that the Supreme Court ruled infringed on sex workers rights to security of the person.

However, there was a live case at hand with (IIRC) Terry Bedford as a criminal defendant who had standing to bring the matter to the SCC.

As sex workers are now immune from prosecution, I don't know who exactly who would have standing to begin an action to have C36 struck down on the same basis the previous laws did. I am no constitutional lawyer but as I understand it, the matter is not ripe until some legal person with standing claims to have been harmed by it's unconstitutionality.

For those who don't understand the legal term "ripe", here is a definition from Wikipedia in reference to US law

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ripeness

In United States law, ripeness refers to the readiness of a case for litigation; "a claim is not ripe for adjudication if it rests upon contingent future events that may not occur as anticipated, or indeed may not occur at all."[SUP][1][/SUP]

For example, if a law of ambiguous quality has been enacted but never applied, a case challenging that law lacks the ripeness necessary for a decision.

The goal is to prevent premature adjudication; if a dispute is insufficiently developed, any potential injury or stake is too speculative to warrant judicial action.

Ripeness issues most usually arise when a plaintiff seeks anticipatory relief, such as an injunction.

The Supreme Court fashioned a two-part test for assessing ripeness challenges to federal regulations. The case is often applied to constitutional challenges to federal and state statutes as well. The Court said in Abbott Laboratories v. Gardner, 387 U.S. 136 (1967):

Without undertaking to survey the intricacies of the ripeness doctrine it is fair to say that its basic rationale is to prevent the courts, through avoidance of premature adjudication, from entangling themselves in abstract disagreements over administrative policies, and also to protect the agencies from judicial interference until an administrative decision has been formalized and its effects felt in a concrete way by the challenging parties.

The problem is best seen in a twofold aspect, requiring us to evaluate both the fitness of the issues for judicial decision and the hardship to the parties of withholding court consideration.[SUP][2][/SUP]
 
I'm not a lawyer but I feel you are wrong about this issue.

1 - Police are not enforcing the law anyhow, they are concerned with underage or physically abused women.

2 - These girls want it illegal, so they can get paid big fees, and other girls are discouraged to enter the business. Being illegal limits supply.

3 - The law is sexist, because it criminalizes men. Because the entire justice system is based on discrimination of men, on the belief that men are intrinsically more dangerous then women, then no one advocates for criminals. The criminal offence, at the core, is being a man. Or being a man is a criminal offence in Canada, because of presumption of guilt because your a guy.

4 - Too many incalls are damaging to the community, whether these people accept it or not.

1. For the most part, but not entirely. There have been some street arrests for soliciting sex & trafficking charges, if nothing else like stings involving LE online ads for adult only sex.

2. Is there evidence the supply of SP's or clients seeking them is down since Bill C-36 became law in 2014? Or that fees are up?

3. The law criminalizes any buyers of sex, regardless of gender. A recent Edmonton report mentioned a female arrested for it.

Male prostitutes have the same laws apply to them as female sex workers.
 
Last edited:
But how can this be accomplished?

I think the first step would be to repeal s. 286, so that purchasing, advertising, material benefit, procuring, and communicating are no longer offences. It's that simple! I mean, the government will have to give some thought to regulations, from occupational health and safety as well as public health perspectives. But that's doable, there's plenty of research available to develop evidence-based rules.

As for s. 279, the trafficking offences, I think those should be revisited... in a course on Modern Slavery a few years ago, I was surprised to learn that human trafficking for the purpose of sexual exploitation is a very small percentage of human trafficking overall. It's a catchy issue, but because it trafficking gets conflated with sex work it derails & monopolizes the conversation. Do you know who picks your fruit, puts together your phone, or sews your clothes? That's the bulk of forced labour and trafficking globally, and it's being ignored.

Beyond law reform, there needs to be a shift in political mindset. Bill C-36 treats prostitution as a form of sexual exploitation. It's true that some SPs are coerced or forcibly confined or beaten, and that is despicable. But we have Criminal Code offences to deal with those crimes. And not to diminish the seriousness of such cases, but exploitation is by no means the norm. We need to recognize and respect the fact that SPs have personal autonomy, just like everyone else. For whatever reason, they are making the choice to work in the sex industry. It may be a question of pleasure, convenience, necessity, or desperation. All of those are valid reasons to work a particular job, depending on an individual's personal circumstances.

P.S. I would redirect all the money currently being wasted on stings and bullshit anti-trafficking (i.e. anti-sex work) campaigns to addiction, mental health, daycare, and other areas that are underfunded and may unduly pressure someone into the sex industry.


 


I say decriminalize prostitution entirely and treat sex work as work.

Decriminalization is the first step towards reducing stigma against the industry, and make it easier to redress wrongs; as it currently stands, there is limited recourse when SPs or their clients have their rights infringed.

C-36 criminalizes aspects of the industry that make sex work more dangerous by limiting the ability to clearly advertise their services and screen clients. Scrapping it entirely solves the problem. There are already Criminal Code provisions to deal with serious issues such as assault, sexual assault, forcible confinement, etc., and human trafficking it its own separate offence.

There's and old saying. "Either you're part of the solution, or part of the problem."
Why don't you lead the charge? Get a colleague arrested under the law, and the two of you can fight it all the way up the chain. Or are you just posting here to make noise and get your name some free advertising?
 
However, there was a live case at hand with (IIRC) Terry Bedford as a criminal defendant who had standing to bring the matter to the SCC.

As sex workers are now immune from prosecution, I don't know who exactly who would have standing to begin an action to have C36 struck down on the same basis the previous laws did. I am no constitutional lawyer but as I understand it, the matter is not ripe until some legal person with standing claims to have been harmed by it's unconstitutionality.

Super interesting question. I believe there is a public interest standing of some sort, but the trouble is that it takes $$$ to get to the Supreme Court of Canada. In my opinion this is a job for Parliament, not the courts. We shouldn't need a constitutional challenge, the federal government should do the right thing and revisit the issue on its own initiative.
 
So in Canada do we vote for governments to make good laws or do we expect the courts to fix bad laws?


I don't think it was a popular vote-getting issue in countries that legalized sex industry such as New Zealand and Australia when their governments introduced bills to decriminalize sex industry.
You'd have to ask the folks who voted for Harper's government. Their punitive and regressive 'fix' to the SCC decision that actually did decriminalize sex work was entirely predictable. And it was just one of a string of his bad laws. Similarly, ask the folks who voted for Justin's sunny ways. He reneged on his repeated "solemn promise" to reform election laws as soon as it looked slightly challenging, and bungled the 'fix' for another SCC decriminalization on the simple issue of assisted dying making it trickier and more confused than ever. Again predictable, but they voted for him in droves.

Both 'leaders' <cough, cough> were clearly following what they belived to be the preferences of their voters, and there's no reason to think any ordinary pols will do differently. The situation to the south makes clear that electing a 'different kind of leader' isn't a clear-cut win for the nation. I can't speak to what happened in NZ or Oz but as close neighbours, both 'far away' from the direct influence of other English-European culture centres they may well be a little more used to figuring out such stuff on their own instead of slavishly aping others. They pioneered the secret ballot for general elections f'rinstance. I wouldn't discount influence on C36 from the elephant Canada sleeps with. perhaps you can shed light on what our cousins got up to on their South Pacific isles.
 
Super interesting question. I believe there is a public interest standing of some sort, but the trouble is that it takes $$$ to get to the Supreme Court of Canada. In my opinion this is a job for Parliament, not the courts. We shouldn't need a constitutional challenge, the federal government should do the right thing and revisit the issue on its own initiative.


Agreed.

Except the government simply won't do that voluntarily. And lobbying is as expensive, if not moreso than taking it through the courts.

I just wonder what the mechanism would be for the sex industry to start the proceedings. Funding aside, could an industry group establish standing to begin such a Charter challenge, and if so in what venue?