While we're at it, let's decriminalize sex work.

SADVOCACY

New member
Apr 5, 2017
73
0
0
Toronto
www.sadvocacy.com
Great piece about decriminalizing sex work.

"The social science evidence from Canada and throughout the world clearly indicates that criminalization of the sex industry - whether clients, third parties or sex workers - continues to send the sex industry into the shadows, restrict sex workers' access to important safety mechanisms and has significant and profound negative consequences on sex workers' health, security, equality and human rights."

C-36 is an abomination.

 
so when will the liberals repeal c-36?
 
So Caryma, how do you think sex work law reform could take place?

I'd think that "repealing" C36 is a non-starter as the absence of a law would put everything back into limbo.

I also can't think of any Charter grounds to bring an appeal as the sex workers are immune from prosecution and therefore would not be charged.

I can't think of any infringement on the Charter rights that a customer who might be charged with.

Is there some mechanism whereby a group representing sex workers could bring a challenge although they have not been charged? It is my understanding that a party must have 'standing" to bring a motion/Notice of Constitutional question (?) that their rights (in this case Section 7 right to security of person) have been infringed by the law. And usually these applications flow from a defence to a criminal or other enforcement action from the government.

But it would seem a reasonable argument to make and consider that sex workers Section 7 right to security of person is being infringed by the criminalization of the industry and therefore having it driven underground again.

Or would the "sex industry" have to try to lobby the government to change the laws in the absence of a court challenge?

Or something else?
 
Justin Trudeau: "Prostitution itself is a form of violence against women."

so when will the liberals repeal c-36?

Never. Before he was elected Trudeau made his position on prostitution very clear, as explained in this January 2014 CBC article:

...Justin Trudeau is keeping a wary distance from a Liberal proposal to legalize, regulate and tax prostitution just like any other commercial enterprise.

A resolution to legalize the sex trade is being pushed by the Liberal party's youth wing and is to be debated at the party's national policy convention next month in Montreal.

But the Liberal leader, who has enthusiastically embraced a resolution passed at the last convention to legalize marijuana, signalled Thursday that he doesn't favour taking the same approach to prostitution.

He played down the importance of the resolution and indicated that he views prostitution as a more complicated issue than pot...

"The priority of the Liberal party ... around our policy convention in February in Montreal is on economic success for the middle class. That is the centre of our focus," he said during a campaign stop with a provincial Liberal byelection candidate in Thornhill, Ont...

"For now, I'm just very, very mindful that the Supreme Court came down very clearly that the current approach is not protecting extremely vulnerable women and sex workers and we need to make sure that we are finding a way to keep vulnerable Canadians protected from violence that surrounds prostitution but also is intrinsic to prostitution," Trudeau said.

In French, Trudeau went further, saying it's important to recognize that "prostitution itself is a form of violence against women." He called for a "responsible, informed debate" on the issue.

Trudeau also said Liberals are "certainly going to look at" the so-called Nordic model, which penalizes those who purchase sex, not those who sell it.

Given Trudeau's statements above, the inaction on this issue by Trudeau and his party since they were elected, and the support Trudeau enjoys from women, there is no chance that the Liberals will take on the issue of prostitution. On the contrary, C-36 is the one law passed under Harper that Trudeau really loves.
 
https://nowtoronto.com/news/ndp-liberals-greens-commit-to-repealing-anti-sex-work-law/

SEPTEMBER 27, 2015 5:40 PM

At Thursday night's Proud to Vote debate, NDP, Liberal, and Green representatives pledged that their respective parties would repeal Bill C-36, the Conservatives' anti-sex-work law, if they form government. The issue, which had barely been mentioned in this election, is apparently a matter of importance for all three of them.
 
"While we're at it, let's decriminalize sex work."

Let's make it mandatory.
 
If that is what justify anti-sex-work law then why not legalize
sex work provided by male escorts.

Because those male escorts would be exploiting those poor women for their money, and therefore reinforcing the patriarchy.
 
So Caryma, how do you think sex work law reform could take place?

I'd think that "repealing" C36 is a non-starter as the absence of a law would put everything back into limbo.

I also can't think of any Charter grounds to bring an appeal as the sex workers are immune from prosecution and therefore would not be charged.

I can't think of any infringement on the Charter rights that a customer who might be charged with.

Is there some mechanism whereby a group representing sex workers could bring a challenge although they have not been charged? It is my understanding that a party must have 'standing" to bring a motion/Notice of Constitutional question (?) that their rights (in this case Section 7 right to security of person) have been infringed by the law. And usually these applications flow from a defence to a criminal or other enforcement action from the government.

But it would seem a reasonable argument to make and consider that sex workers Section 7 right to security of person is being infringed by the criminalization of the industry and therefore having it driven underground again.

Or would the "sex industry" have to try to lobby the government to change the laws in the absence of a court challenge?

Or something else?


Since C-36 targets the buyers but grants immunity to the SW, couldn't a charter challenge arise from the deprivation of the SW's right to make a living? Not sure if that falls under "security of the person", but surely that's gotta be one beef to make?
 
They are too busy trying to fix the wage gap....they dont have time meddling with the oldest and most profitable profession for women in the world.
 
Is there some mechanism whereby a group representing sex workers could bring a challenge although they have not been charged? It is my understanding that a party must have 'standing" to bring a motion/Notice of Constitutional question (?) that their rights (in this case Section 7 right to security of person) have been infringed by the law.

Don't know if you can do in Canada, but in the U.S. you can bring a declarative action without being charged. You have standing if you can show you have a reason to challange the law that may affect you. In the current ESPLER case now at the 9th Circuit Appeals they Planitffs included a women that was a legal escort in Nevada but wanted to move to California. Her income would be impacted if the Calf prostitution law prevented her from working. That was enough for standing to challange the prostitution law. Another plantiff was going to be used who had a disablity and wanted the right to have sexual pleasure via prostitution since unable to other ways. Sadly, he died before the case was filed. If this kind of action is allowed in Canada it would seem to have to come from the client side.
 
Why did he [Trudeau] vote against it [C-36] then?

Trudeau voted against C-36 because it was a law designed by the Harper government. Once Trudeau realized how popular C-36 was with his feminist and left wing constituency he changed his mind.

Trudeau is a consummate politician with no firm beliefs in any fundamental principles (as such he is like many politicians on both the left and the right). His government could easily overturn C-36 but he would alienate many voters on both the left and the right. Other than the votes of some (but not all) escorts and most clients, there are no votes to be gained by overturning C-36. It will never happen under Trudeau and I don't think it is likely to happen under any other government.

The only chance to overturn C-36 is another Supreme Court decision against it, but as others have pointed out, it is hard to imagine who would start such a case and on what grounds. C-36 is here to stay. Thankfully, in major Canadian cities, city rulers and the police choose to mostly ignore the law and not try to enforce it. Count your blessings.
 
Since C-36 targets the buyers but grants immunity to the SW, couldn't a charter challenge arise from the deprivation of the SW's right to make a living? Not sure if that falls under "security of the person", but surely that's gotta be one beef to make?
A Charter challenge that succeeds is the only hope for a C36 repeal. If Trudeau was to face the situation Harper dealt with so punitively we could imagine decriminalization through constructive inaction, somewhat like abortion after Morgenthaler. But there's just no vote-getting upside to initiating a repeal all on his own.
 
So Caryma, how do you think sex work law reform could take place?

I'd think that "repealing" C36 is a non-starter as the absence of a law would put everything back into limbo.

I also can't think of any Charter grounds to bring an appeal as the sex workers are immune from prosecution and therefore would not be charged.

I can't think of any infringement on the Charter rights that a customer who might be charged with.

Is there some mechanism whereby a group representing sex workers could bring a challenge although they have not been charged? It is my understanding that a party must have 'standing" to bring a motion/Notice of Constitutional question (?) that their rights (in this case Section 7 right to security of person) have been infringed by the law. And usually these applications flow from a defence to a criminal or other enforcement action from the government.

But it would seem a reasonable argument to make and consider that sex workers Section 7 right to security of person is being infringed by the criminalization of the industry and therefore having it driven underground again.

Or would the "sex industry" have to try to lobby the government to change the laws in the absence of a court challenge?

Or something else?

I say decriminalize prostitution entirely and treat sex work as work.

Decriminalization is the first step towards reducing stigma against the industry, and make it easier to redress wrongs; as it currently stands, there is limited recourse when SPs or their clients have their rights infringed.

C-36 criminalizes aspects of the industry that make sex work more dangerous by limiting the ability to clearly advertise their services and screen clients. Scrapping it entirely solves the problem. There are already Criminal Code provisions to deal with serious issues such as assault, sexual assault, forcible confinement, etc., and human trafficking it its own separate offence.