Which One is the Pit Bull?

Which dog pictured is a Pit Bull

  • Dog 1

    Votes: 9 30.0%
  • Dog 2

    Votes: 3 10.0%
  • Dog 3

    Votes: 1 3.3%
  • Dog 4

    Votes: 1 3.3%
  • Dog 5

    Votes: 15 50.0%
  • Dog 6

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Dog 7

    Votes: 1 3.3%

  • Total voters
    30
Sheik said:
Neopolitan Mastiff


that has to be the smallest one in the world then if its purebred or is it a puppy?. or the pictures are very bad in terms of scale.
 
they cant...thats the whole point. this ban is not going to even be passed lile it is now. i have this from the "inside". they are already working to change wording. i imagine they will fuck it up even worse this time around.

liberals...cant live with them, cant sick your pitt on them . what are they good for?
 
Nice survey. Why didnt you include the right answer as one of your options?


Morgan Ellis said:

So, congrats to all - none of them were Pit Bulls. You just voted to put the wrong dogs to death.

Morgan
 
Morgan Ellis said:
Dog One - Staffordshire Bull Terrier

Congrats if you picked it - you just put some child's pet to death.
So, congrats to all - none of them were Pit Bulls. You just voted to put the wrong dogs to death.

Morgan

Geez Morgan easy on the dramatics. You asked to vote on what we thought was a pit bull. If I knew you were going to make some personal judgement on me and accuse me of killing some kids pet because i took part in your friggin poll, id have thought twice. I dont mind talking about issues but dont get all pissy and dramatic. Not that it isnt a topic of emotion but ease up
 
Morgan, I think you took the cake with this one!

Morgan Ellis said:
...What if it's your dog? What if you return from holidays, and learn that your dog ended up being put to death accidentally, because it was mis-identified? Think it can't happen? Tell that to the people in the US and Canada who have faced this very issue. Tell it to the people in Germany.

Morgan
Morgan Niemoller, I presume? :p

jwm
 
mtl_guy said:
Nice survey. Why didnt you include the right answer as one of your options?

Nothing stopped you or anyone else from posting 'none' - and in fact, someone did.

The point is/was that identifying breeds is an inexact science.

"The onus of identification of a dog will be put on the owners who will have to prove it's not a pit bull, Bryant said. "

Since there's no DNA test for dogs, how do you propose owners who don't have papers for their dogs do this? And what if the dog is picked up as a stray?

The shelters will be doing exactly what this quiz did - looking at dogs, and guessing. And sometimes, they're going to guess wrong.

-- Morgan
 
The point is that your far from scientific survey is further plagued by problems by not putting the correct answer.

If I put up 3 pictures of women and asked which one is a man, a large majority would pick one of the 3 pictures. A few people might realize its a trick and that theres no correct answer.

Thats exactly what trick you did.


Morgan Ellis said:
Nothing stopped you or anyone else from posting 'none' - and in fact, someone did.

The point is/was that identifying breeds is an inexact science.

"The onus of identification of a dog will be put on the owners who will have to prove it's not a pit bull, Bryant said. "

Since there's no DNA test for dogs, how do you propose owners who don't have papers for their dogs do this? And what if the dog is picked up as a stray?

The shelters will be doing exactly what this quiz did - looking at dogs, and guessing. And sometimes, they're going to guess wrong.

-- Morgan
 
I'm out of the country right now so I haven't studied this ban...however, it's my understanding that they are not going out and killing dogs.

Dogs that are classified as 'pit bulls' that have no owners (i.e. housed at animal control or in the humane society) will be euthanised (which happens quite often anyway)

However, 'pit bulls' that currently have owners will not be killed but will be spayed or neutered and will not be allowed outside without a muzzel. If any of these dogs should attack someone, they will then be killed (which I think should be the case with any dog that attacks a human)

If I am correct in these assumptions then why are we repeatedly seeing posts that are seeming to encourage mass hysteria as if everyone is going to have their dog killed if they own one of these?
 
tzahal said:
... liberals...cant live with them, cant sick your pitt on them . what are they good for?
Nice!!! Once again you have shown what a "class" act you are! CAD! A shame to your claimed profession.


galt said:
... However, 'pit bulls' that currently have owners will not be killed but will be spayed or neutered and will not be allowed outside without a muzzel. ...

If I am correct in these assumptions then why are we repeatedly seeing posts that are seeming to encourage mass hysteria as if everyone is going to have their dog killed if they own one of these?
Exactly!!!
 
No Kiarra. She asked us to pick which one was a pit bull in our opinion. She didnt say our answer would result in us being labelled as pet killers and in agreement with the breed ban law. If we got it wrong all it proved was that we are not able to properly identify a pit bull. Shes making it out that anyone that got it wrong is for the ban.
 
tompeepin said:
Nice!!! Once again you have shown what a "class" act you are! CAD! A shame to your claimed profession.



Exactly!!!


once again you have shown how thin your skin is. a shame to all men that arent whining wussies everywhere.
 
tzahal said:
... you have shown how thin your skin is. ...
Thin skin? hahaha I was just "calling a spade a spade"! :p I could care less if you are such a "tough" "bad ass". I am sooo impressed by your "manliness".
 
People prefer to look at things like breed 'bans' in eumphamistic terms, or as some sort of amorphous solution that will result in banned breeds just disappearing into the ether.

Few people want to deal with the reality that breed bans are enforced through death - like it or not, someone, someplace is going to have to make a decision about a puppy, and decide whether or not it gets a needle stuck in it to (euphamistically speaking yet again) 'put it to sleep'.

And they're going to make that decision based on what the puppy looks like - is it a Pit Bull? Is it something else? Your guess is as good as that of the shelter worker faced with making this kind of decision.

So you can be as annoyed as you want, but the reality of this is harsh - breed bans kill dogs. Dogs of lots of breeds other than the ones they are aimed at. You go tell some owner faced with a euthanasia order for their puppies how sorry you are when they get the breed wrong, and see how much those words mean to them.

Do you really think this is about propagating hysteria, as opposed to countering a completely illogical piece of legislation meant only to pander to the easily soothed masses?


-- Morgan
 
Morgan Ellis said:

Do you really think this is about propagating hysteria, as opposed to countering a completely illogical piece of legislation meant only to pander to the easily soothed masses?
-- Morgan

It shouldnt be but you seem to want to make it that with your puppy killing rants. Your poll may have been intended to prove a point of which i tend to agree, however your reasoning afterwards leaves alot to be desired!
 
tzahal must not be a vet

Sorry tzahal but your language is not the one a vet uses, and your spelling is even worse. You may say you are a vet but I really think you are just a phony. And if you really are a vet why aren't you attending the front office or doing some kind of surgery (maybe an OVH or a Castration or maybe inducing an animal with Thio or Valium ketamine , I imagine you know what i'm talking about) instead of making everybodies life miserable.

And If you really are a vet is this the way you treat your clients and their animals?? may my lord have mercy on them
 
Well Kiarra she did when i picked #1. so thats what im talking about. She has a point but is totally going about proving it the wrong way IMO.


see?

Dog One - Staffordshire Bull Terrier

Also known as the 'nanny dog', and voted by the Kennel Club of England as one the most 'reliable' of breeds and as 'best with chidlren'. Congrats if you picked it - you just put some child's pet to death.


So, congrats to all - none of them were Pit Bulls. You just voted to put the wrong dogs to death.
 
Look... so you proved that most people cant tell pitbulls apart from other breeds. Then who needs pitbulls. You could kill off the entire breed and no one would ever notice because at least 5 or 6 other breeds are interchangable.