Where Is The Iraq War Headed Next?

Asterix

Sr. Member
Aug 6, 2002
10,015
0
0
Interesting article by Sy Hersh in the New Yorker, describing what might be expected when and if US troops begin to withdraw. A very real problem in the US switching primerily to air support for the Iraqis, is that we would be reliant on them to direct air strikes, with all the obvious risk of that being used to settle old scores, as well as increased risk to ordinary civilians caught in the way.

http://www.newyorker.com/fact/content/
 
Asterix said:
Interesting article by Sy Hersh in the New Yorker, describing what might be expected when and if US troops begin to withdraw. A very real problem in the US switching primerily to air support for the Iraqis, is that we would be reliant on them to direct air strikes, with all the obvious risk of that being used to settle old scores, as well as increased risk to ordinary civilians caught in the way.

http://www.newyorker.com/fact/content/

Yes, glad you pointed this out..I was wondering when it would surface on the board. There are a couple of unmanned posts on the top sentry wall, west side of the fort - TOV and Pecker are snoozing, probably in the mess hall.

btw..talking points in Rove's President's speech yesterday address this. It's embedded American officers that will call in the strikes - so not to worry. And they are practiced...

edited to add, standby for the right's assault on Seymore Hersh.
 
Meanwhile, Rep. John Murtha today in an NPR interview. There is likely no other person in Congress with the connections he has to those in the military, both retired and active. The administration is right to be fearful of him. He sounds pissed and also that he knows what he is talking about.

http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=5035043
 
Asterix said:
Meanwhile, Rep. John Murtha today in an NPR interview. There is likely no other person in Congress with the conections he has to those in the military, both retired and active. The administration is right to be fearful of him. He sounds pissed and also that he knows what he is talking about.

http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=5035043


oops...check your link..404
 
A-ROD said:
This will go on forever and ever.... This area of the world will always be unstable :(

Geez you mention unstable and McL posts. Got to love the poetry.
 
Odom's Laws

Asterix said:
An article by retired Lt. General William Odom and a related interview on NPR today, on his reasons for getting out of Iraq sooner than later. General Odom was the director of the National Security Agency under Reagan, is a senior fellow at the conservative Hudson Institute, and recognized expert on military affairs.

http://www.niemanwatchdog.org/index.cfm?fuseaction=Ask_this.view&askthisid=129

http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=5035613


Citing one point:


"Until the United States withdraws from Iraq and admits its strategic error, no such coalition can be formed."

This is like a law of the physics of the situation. (As in Newton's Laws of Motion)
 
usa will never attempt to withdraw peacfully

Since Iraq is occupied land by force, i find it difficult to digest that as the security situation in iraq eases the hope of usa to leave iraq increases. thats not the aim of invading iraq in the first place. its so incorrect and its a big lie by bush administration to make the world believe that its purpose in iraq is to install government capable to protect it self or at least protect the oil fields and be able to sell the oil of iraq and sent the money to usa and keep the security situation under control. In an argument with one of my friends, the invasion of iraq is a first step towards coloniziong the middle east for generations to come, i could not believe that the usa will leave iraq if peace prevailes and iraq streets and citizins are safe from daily killing or bombings.

The political stratigy is this, usa will have its political and military presence in iraq at least 40 years until such time usa start thinking of leaving iraq to sail on its own for the following reasons. Since the existance of iraq as an independant country its citizins have been fead the anti usa and anti west slogans by its rulers and they were made to believe that usa and its allies in the region are their enemies. The bath party ideologies been tought in schools for generations, iraqies know nothing about democracy and democray mechanisim. there may be a handfull of american taught politicians whom are supported by the cia know little about democracy, but the majority of the iraqi public to this moment despite their relegious beliefes still dislike and distrust usa and its allies.

If usa decided to leave iraq the only reason will make them leave is not the stabiltiy in iraq as declared by bush and his clownes, but on the contrary is the mess and out of control conditions on handling the public and controlling the masses of both shia and sunni in iraq after usa failed to fullfill its promises by bringing freedom, justice, prosperity and security to every iraqi whom been suffering under saddam regime. then and there usa find no way out but to leave the mess behind, and thats what will hapen.

The big question is, can usa stay in iraq for the next needed 40 years to cash in on its investments.

Pro419
 
pro419 said:
The big question is, can usa stay in iraq for the next needed 40 years to cash in on its investments.

Pro419


The real investment in iraq is the establisment of a free democratic society. Once democracy takes hold along with rights for all the people. Once women in a onetime islamic stronghold, show that just the simplest of rights, such as voting, education and driving are just. Then others will begin to reject the theocratic rulers. This possibilty farnkly scares the hell out of the leaders, whos power is absolute. Can you see a truly united people whos goal is equality in social, economic and educations standards? What fear it has to place in the minds of clerics who will become relegated to the role of teacher and not ruler. The ideals of freedom of choice, religion and yes even personal choice in beliefsis freightening. I would even bet by the end of the decade you will be able to get good BBQ in Iraq or even a nice pork roast in resturants.
 
papasmerf said:
The ideals of freedom of choice, religion and yes even personal choice in beliefsis freightening. I would even bet by the end of the decade you will be able to get good BBQ in Iraq or even a nice pork roast in resturants.
Right. So the whole purpose of violating international law, pissing off the world, going to war based on (take your pick) damnable lies or faulty intelligence--all this was to create a society where Islamic dietary law can be violated with impunity?

Tell you what: this will happen, once the last of the dry counties in the US go wet.

MW
 
...a despots greatest fear is that his people get a taste of Freedom.......no matter how small......
 
maxweber said:
Right. So the whole purpose of violating international law, pissing off the world, going to war based on (take your pick) damnable lies or faulty intelligence--all this was to create a society where Islamic dietary law can be violated with impunity?

Tell you what: this will happen, once the last of the dry counties in the US go wet.

MW
A dry county does not mean you can not drink there
It means ya can not buy it there. I would be happy to export Baby Back Ribs there.
 
Both Rep. Murtha, and Sy Hersh in his article, refer to the reluctance of active generals to criticize the war for fear of losing their jobs. Given how the administration tore into General Shinseki during his final year before retiring, they may have good reason. Forutunately, retired generals have no such worry to speak their minds. Two more retired generals who are calling for a withdrawal beginning early 2006, and who reiterate many of Odom's points.

http://www.armscontrolcenter.org/archives/002173.php
 
Asterix said:
Both Rep. Murtha, and Sy Hersh in his article, refer to the reluctance of active generals to criticize the war for fear of losing their jobs. Given how the administration tore into General Shinseki during his final year before retiring, they may have good reason. Forutunately, retired generals have no such worry to speak their minds. Two more retired generals who are calling for a withdrawal beginning early 2006, and who reiterate many of Odom's points.

http://www.armscontrolcenter.org/archives/002173.php

I just happened to be reading that article when you posted this, and in fact was on the same paragraph. So do you work for the underground left? and have you hacked thru my firewall? LOL..

Anyway, this is interesting:

For example, Murtha reported that the number of attacks in Iraq has increased from a hundred and fifty a week to more than seven hundred a week in the past year. He said that an estimated fifty thousand American soldiers will suffer “from what I call battle fatigue” in the war, and he said that the Americans were seen as “the common enemy” in Iraq. He also took issue with one of the White House’s claims—that foreign fighters were playing the major role in the insurgency. Murtha said that American soldiers “haven’t captured any in this latest activity”—the continuing battle in western Anbar province, near the border with Syria. “So this idea that they’re coming in from outside, we still think there’s only seven per cent.”
 
General Barry MacCaffrey, a commander during the first gulf war, saying that US troops must begin withdrawing no later than September, and that deployment levels can not be maintained past that date. While generally supportive of president Bush, he also said of the currrent situation in Iraq, "to be honest, i'm not sure it's recoverable".

http://www.dfw.com/mld/dfw/news/special_packages/iraq/13293867.htm
 
Asterix said:
General Barry MacCaffrey, a commander during the first gulf war, saying that US troops must begin withdrawing no later than September, and that deployment levels can not be maintained past that date. While generally supportive of president Bush, he also said of the currrent situation in Iraq, "to be honest, i'm not sure it's recoverable".

http://www.dfw.com/mld/dfw/news/special_packages/iraq/13293867.htm
Gen. MacCaffrey is a very well respected military analyst. Hell, I've seen him hundreds of times on CNN and he presents as very reasonable. Of course there must be a limited conditions based withdrawal before Sept. Most analysts both moderate left, moderate right and those of no leaning agree with this.
 
rogerstaubach said:
Gen. MacCaffrey is a very well respected military analyst. Hell, I've seen him hundreds of times on CNN and he presents as very reasonable. Of course there must be a limited conditions based withdrawal before Sept. Most analysts both moderate left, moderate right and those of no leaning agree with this.

He has also been an outspoken critic of how the US prepared for and prosecuted the war. It's the quote that got me. It isn't clear if he meant our own military presence, or if he was refering to the entire conflict in Iraq.
 
Asterix said:
He has also been an outspoken critic of how the US prepared for and prosecuted the war. It's the quote that got me. It isn't clear if he meant our own military presence, or if he was refering to the entire conflict in Iraq.
A case could be made against the "strategy of war on the cheap" no doubt. But a similar case could be made against "Godzilla's footprint". And a case could be made against "sitting on our asses".