What would you do?

Ceiling Cat

Well-known member
Feb 25, 2009
30,280
2,690
113
The names and circumstances of this case have been change to protect the innocent.

Joe owns a garage, a rep from a rustproofing company offers Joe a deal to offer rustproofing at his garage. The company will supply the equipment to apply the rustproofing at no charge if Joe agrees to by all the rustproofing materials from them. The contract stipulates that Joe must not buy the rustproofing materials from another company. The contract stipulates that there is a $50,000 penalty for violating the terms of the contract. Things go well for a year until Joe finds out that he can purchase rustproofing product from another company at 1/3 the price, he also finds a company to sell him the rustproofing application equipment at a low price.

Clearly Joe is in violation of the terms of the contract. What can he do?
 
The penalty/liquidated damages provision is probably pretty damning. Easy to enforce on court. The supplier would probably move for a summary judgment if it had to sue.

Concoct a claim against the original supplier and sue for some breach of contract. Go ahead and source from the second supplier and wait for the lawsuit from supplier 1. Make an offer to settle both suits by walking away even.


Or, the right thing to do would be to ask supplier for a break in price in exchange for a contract extension.

I assume the buyer has run a differential cost analysis on the two options?
 
Aw Joe say it aint so
 
Joe agreed to the terms and needs to realize that nothing in life is free. The company provided the equipment since they were going to make up their money on the materials.
Joe is an asshole, and needs to realize you cant have free equipment and cheapest prices for materials.
 
Joe is clearly not a good businessman. he should have priced other options before signing the contract... but then he probably did not have the money to buy the equipment in the first place.


The equipment to apply the rustproofing is quite simple and not expensive. It can be bought in the US for about $400, and no duty will be paid at the border because it is made in the USA.

This is the advice I gave Joe. I told him that he should write a letter to the president of the rustproofing company explaining that it made no economic sense to buy rustproofing at three times the price when he could have the same product for a third. He would agree to return the rustproofing application equipment and they can part friends. In exchange, he would not tell other garage where to buy the rustproofing application equipment for a low price and nor where they can buy the rustproofing product for a third of the price.
I think that economically it would make sense for the rustproofing company to drop the case instead of loosing all their suppliers.
 
This is how all franchises work. You have buy a case of coke from the Franchisor at their price, you cannot buy at the corner Grocery at 1/3 the price.
 
In exchange, he would not tell other garage where to buy the rustproofing application equipment for a low price and nor where they can buy the rustproofing product for a third of the price.

CLEARLY he better not take your advice because this actually borders on extortion.

You can state it in a diplomatic manner to get the message across. If 100 garages were to find out that they can save 2/3 of the cost on product, I would imagine most if not all would leave the franchise eventually. The losses would be staggering for the franchise. Put yourself in the place of the franchiser, gain $50.000 and loose millions or make the problem go away.

 
It all depends on the income potential of this business. If Joe can comfortably make more than $50,000 by making these changes... pay the fine and move on.
 
Ya, just advise Joe to stop using the equipment, and stop buying product. Eventually, they will come get their equipment on their own.
 
Joe should never have signed that contract.

Joe needs to take the contract to a lawyer to find out how he can get out of it. ie: did he sign his company to this contract? Start a new company and have them do the rustproofing. There are always was around this.
 
The advice I gave to Joe is to let it be known that if he is sued he can no longer be friends with the franchise company. It is worth a shot to get out of deep doo doo!