I don't like any of the DP, anal, ATM, domination, or fetish stuff.
As for the rest, it's mostly about the girl, not the specific action.
What I like to see is a hot fit, athletic girl, long brunette hair, full lips, with a firm bubble butt ass, shapely firm breasts, landing strip pubic hairstyle, large protruding labia minora. Before the sex scenes, she'll be wearing hot sexy clothes (before getting nude) like a classy mini-skirt, skin-tight jeans, and some nice one-on-one sex that showcases her body. A sexy strip-tease before the actual sex scene is nice. A hot girl performing fellatio or getting fucked turns me on.
As for the "money shot", I want the girl to "finish him off" with her hand and lips. I hate watching the guy jack off.