What the hell...another car buying thread

opieshuffle

Well-known member
Oct 30, 2004
803
835
93
So how about this: I am coming to the end of a 4 year lease and am interested in buying it. However. I began my lease back before the dollar hit parity the first time and all the manufacturers started slashing some car prices. The car I leased (Mazda 6 GT) was selling for about 5gs more when I got it than a year later for the newer model. Which means...the buy-out on the lease is a few grand more than what they're going for on Autotrader now. (when you factor in the mark-up on used cars by dealers the difference could be MORE than a few grand)

My question is this: based on the difference between what they want and the perceived value by doing some research, how much negotiating can I expect to do when it comes time to buy the car? Lots of variables at play I know, just looking for input on those who've gone through this process since I've always given cars back.

Thoughts?

Opie
 
I went through this exact same thing last year at the end of my truck lease.

What happened up until now is vehicles were leased with a buy back at a rate that was higher than the actual resale value of the vehicle so basically, the OEMs were losing their shirts on all these vehicles.

No, the dealer won't haggle over the buy back on your vehicle because it isn't their vehicle to sell, it is the leasing company's. The buy back is the buy back.

I know when I turned in my old truck the buy back was $4 - 6000.00 more than they were selling for, even on the dealer lot. Which is why so many end up at auction. I can't remember the exact price but I was considering buying the truck even at a slightly higher price because I knew it's history but it just wasn't feasible.

In addition, unless you have the cash to buy it outright, it is far cheaper to buy another new one than purchase a used one. This is due to the interest on the loan you'd have to take out. I think on used vehicles now it is around 7, 8%? something like that. On a new one you can probably get zero or 1%. Again, when I was turning in my vehicle I shopped around and with interest, it would cost me the same per month on a new vehicle as a 3 yr old one. Same money down, everything.

For eg: $30,000.00 new truck at 0% cost of borrowing over 5 yrs? Zero
or
$20,000.00 on 3 yr old truck at 10% over 5 yrs $30000.00 cost of borrowing? about $10000.00.

Now I know, interest rates are compounded and you do pay off some of the principal over the term but the difference is negligable at best. For $2,000.00 it is FAR better to have a new vehicle than a used one.

Now if you're planning on leasing your next vehicle, be prepared: the OEMs have wisened up so now the buy backs are more realistically priced and you'll pay more per month than in the past. I know with my new truck it was far far better to purchase than lease. It amounted to about $150.00 per month less to buy than less. At the end of 3 yrs the value of the vehicle would be the same as the buy back so I could trade it in on a new one if I wanted and still be ahead of a lease. I was worried about repairs etc for the 4 wheel drive system and from the dealer, he said: keep it until things start breaking out of warrant, THEN trade it in lol.....

Bottom line is I know you'd like to buy your vehicle because you've maintained it and know it's history but it will be more than the others selling there now.....a LOT more..
 
Thanks T-boy. A few factors: we were going to use my wife's car as a trade in to knock the final price down (since we only need one car these days), and based on that we COULD buy it outright (no financing) But the thought of paying 4gs more for the car than the "street value" isn't making me happy. I know it's Mazda Finance's car, but it seems odd they'd send it to auction (getting the street value) instead of negotiating with me...bummer.

Opie
 
I mean, imports are always a little different than domestic, you could always talk to the dealer and see about buying it outright, maybe mazda is different?

And as for it being strange sending it to auction, a LOT of things businesses do are strange. Makes you understand a bit why the makers are in trouble......