What "Really" Creates Jobs

rhuarc29

Well-known member
Apr 15, 2009
9,903
1,737
113
Demand.

Not "job creators". So long as there is demand, there will always be someone working to fill that demand. In a time when the richest individuals and richest corporations (aka the "job creators") are sitting on records amount of cash and the unemployment rate is sky high...I'm not even sure how you can continue to say that taking it even easier on these people and businesses is the only way to create jobs.

So how do you go about creating demand? Well, demand is created when someone feels they can afford to buy something that they desire or "require" and go ahead and buy it. So, who are the best people to create demand? The rich. Are you thinking: didn't you just say the rich aren't job creators? Actually, what I said was that taking it easier on these guys (ie lowering taxes) won't create more jobs.

Here's how I see it. The following are generalizations with taxes already out.

A family making $15,000 annually spends almost 100% of what they make each year on necessities (food, clothing, shelter, etc.). In fact, in many cases it's more than 100% through credit. That's why a credit market freeze can destroy demand.

A family making $35,000 still spends close to 100% of what they make annually, but much of that money is now going towards things that they don't absolutely require. Entertainment, travel, furniture, electronics, personal vehicles, more varied food, etc.

In both these cases, the families may try to put something small away for the future. But also, they would most likely spend more if they made more.

Now consider a family making $250,000 a year. Some of that will go towards necessities, and some will go towards desirables, but a good chunk will be saved or invested rather than spent. In this case, if these families were to make more money, they most likely wouldn't spend the additional capital, but rather invest it.

So, the economics of it act like a logarithmic scale. Poor people put the most (in terms of %) of their annual income back into the market, while the ultra rich put the least. But the ultra rich use that money to invest, right? And that investment is what drives the economy, right? Sure, but they aren't investing. There's no reason to invest because the demand for the products isn't there. They aren't going to invest unless there is a good likelihood of a return on their money.

The job creators aren't creating jobs because there's no demand. There's no demand because the job creators have all the money.

Here's the solution.

Tax the rich more, tax the poor less. The poor will have more money (money they are likely to spend immediately) to crank up demand, the increased revenue from taxes on the rich will balance the equation, and the increased demand will allow the rich to invest their money (including hiring workers) and get even richer. Get the wheels back on the track and rolling and the economy will take care of itself. As far as I'm concerned, it's the ever decreasing taxes in the States (especially on the rich) that are the main reason the world entered the recession in the first place. It was hidden by the fact that the demand was still being created by the poor...on credit. The availability of credit made it look like the poor were living the high life, demand was strong, and the economy was in great shape. One problem with that: credit isn't cash, it has to be repaid. We didn't just borrow money, we borrowed time. Payment's due.

Anything wrong with that? :biggrin1:
 
Anything wrong with that?

Yes, the rich aren't going to like it. And the rich control the government. And the government decides on tax policy. Hence it will never be implemented. We're f*cked.
 
I thought legalizing prostitution would create more jobs. I should write a letter to Harper. Hell, I'll even let him claim the idea as his own.
 
Yes, the rich aren't going to like it. And the rich control the government. And the government decides on tax policy. Hence it will never be implemented. We're f*cked.

In the US they have their own network [FOX] to brainwash the elderly & simple minded. Actually they (Fox commentators) are not allowed to use the term 'Rich' - they are 'job creators'. This is because the more personal wealth they have - the more maids and pool boys they can hire.
 
Yep according to Keynesian theory, pumping more money into the economy via the poor is supposed to jump start things via increased demand and the multiplier effect.

The poor spend and inject a greater percentage of their total income than does the rich.

Inflation needs to be controlled however.

The rich job providers who own the factors of production know very well how to manipulate them effectively as they are now going through a process of frustrating the economic processes. They have the government in their pockets and not employing people as demand increases, but instead are stockpiling money and lining their pockets well as they slave drive the existing workers to squeeze every last drop of profit out.

A main reason why so many jobs have been exported to China.

When the markets plunge like they did yesterday, the rich move in and take full advantage of lower stock prices.
 
As was said in an earlier thread, the people are the economy. If they aren't buying, the retailers aren't selling, the manufacturers are producing and raw materials aren't being sold. Who sitting on their money? The companies are, certainly not the people.
 
While I agree to an extent with the basic premise of your argument, what you are ignoring is that the richest individuals and corporations (ie. the "job creators") are sitting on records amount of cash basically out of fear of the greater global economic situation. Essentially, what we have seen previously are corporations (and individuals to a lesser extent) basing their investments on credit being made available to them easily. However, given the uncertainties with sovereign debt currently, and the spectacular collapses in the banking sector previously in 2008, existing financial institutions have become less willing to give credit to businesses, and many businesses (including the richest corporations) have focused on building their cash reserves to ride out a potential hit.

Furthermore, I'm not certain to what extent lessening the tax burden on the poor at this stage will do to build up demand because whatever tax savings will only be spent on essentials such as food or rent, or else othewise saved. I think instead of tax relief, a more effective way to stimulate the economy would be direct stimulus money for public works projects or direct subsidies/investments on key industries (the Keynesian stimulus). The investment dollars would thus provide the wherewithal for firms to hire additional workers, who in turn would have sufficient money to purchase goods & services, thus stimulating demand, which then would lead the wealthy corporations and individuals to provide private-sector investment.

Naturally, such stimulus will have to be substantial to really stimulate such demand (the key problem with the stimulus measures taken by Obama in the US previously, as has been argued by economist Paul Krugman, was that it was simply too small and too modest to really stimulate such demand). And it may mean a temporary increase in the government deficit. Some countries are in a better situation to provide such stimuli than others (Canada and the US being among them -- the governments of China and to a lesser extent India and Brazil already provide direct stimuli to ensure high growth).

Demand.

Not "job creators". So long as there is demand, there will always be someone working to fill that demand. In a time when the richest individuals and richest corporations (aka the "job creators") are sitting on records amount of cash and the unemployment rate is sky high...I'm not even sure how you can continue to say that taking it even easier on these people and businesses is the only way to create jobs.

So how do you go about creating demand? Well, demand is created when someone feels they can afford to buy something that they desire or "require" and go ahead and buy it. So, who are the best people to create demand? The rich. Are you thinking: didn't you just say the rich aren't job creators? Actually, what I said was that taking it easier on these guys (ie lowering taxes) won't create more jobs.

Here's how I see it. The following are generalizations with taxes already out.

A family making $15,000 annually spends almost 100% of what they make each year on necessities (food, clothing, shelter, etc.). In fact, in many cases it's more than 100% through credit. That's why a credit market freeze can destroy demand.

A family making $35,000 still spends close to 100% of what they make annually, but much of that money is now going towards things that they don't absolutely require. Entertainment, travel, furniture, electronics, personal vehicles, more varied food, etc.

In both these cases, the families may try to put something small away for the future. But also, they would most likely spend more if they made more.

Now consider a family making $250,000 a year. Some of that will go towards necessities, and some will go towards desirables, but a good chunk will be saved or invested rather than spent. In this case, if these families were to make more money, they most likely wouldn't spend the additional capital, but rather invest it.

So, the economics of it act like a logarithmic scale. Poor people put the most (in terms of %) of their annual income back into the market, while the ultra rich put the least. But the ultra rich use that money to invest, right? And that investment is what drives the economy, right? Sure, but they aren't investing. There's no reason to invest because the demand for the products isn't there. They aren't going to invest unless there is a good likelihood of a return on their money.

The job creators aren't creating jobs because there's no demand. There's no demand because the job creators have all the money.

Here's the solution.

Tax the rich more, tax the poor less. The poor will have more money (money they are likely to spend immediately) to crank up demand, the increased revenue from taxes on the rich will balance the equation, and the increased demand will allow the rich to invest their money (including hiring workers) and get even richer. Get the wheels back on the track and rolling and the economy will take care of itself. As far as I'm concerned, it's the ever decreasing taxes in the States (especially on the rich) that are the main reason the world entered the recession in the first place. It was hidden by the fact that the demand was still being created by the poor...on credit. The availability of credit made it look like the poor were living the high life, demand was strong, and the economy was in great shape. One problem with that: credit isn't cash, it has to be repaid. We didn't just borrow money, we borrowed time. Payment's due.

Anything wrong with that? :biggrin1:
 
Last edited:
Furthermore, I'm not certain to what extent lessening the tax burden on the poor at this stage will do to build up demand because whatever tax savings will only be spent on essentials such as food or rent, or else othewise saved. I think instead of tax relief, a more effective way to stimulate the economy would be direct stimulus money for public works projects or direct subsidies/investments on key industries (the Keynesian stimulus). The investment dollars would thus provide the wherewithal for firms to hire additional workers, who in turn would have sufficient money to purchase goods & services, thus stimulating demand, which then would lead the wealthy corporations and individuals to provide private-sector investment.

I agree with that. Although I think that in the current climate, after stimulus money failed to return us to pre-recession levels, that you'll have a hard time convincing the majority of people that it is, after all, the answer.

My main beef is with the idea that giving the rich and corporations additional capital to invest actually results in investment. It doesn't. Give an employer a tax break, he's still not going to hire more workers until the demand is there to justify it. No workers being hired, no workers making money, no money being spent, no demand to justify hiring workers.

Also, economies have hidden behind credit (consumer and government debt) in a bid to appear healthy. Demand was strong because the poor had access to additional funds that they thought they could afford to spend and the government had lots of money to spend on public works and other services, many of which they overpaid for. Creating demand with credit is false demand, because it subtracts from demand later when the credit must be repaid.

I'm afraid we're in for a rough decade because the goal doesn't seem to be to create demand.
 
Anything wrong with that?

There are many more poor and middle class than there are rich. The US government wants the people to believe that they will tax the rich and the economic woes of the world will be solved. It is a ploy to tax the rich more and and work its way down to the middle class and poor later. Everyone will have to pay more to pay off the deficit.
 
I agree in large part with your assessment. It may also be worth noting that the Great Depression (and the current economic situation in the world has much in common with that time period) lasted for more than a decade.

This is my personal assessment of what the economic climate will be (I am not an economist, so take what I say for what it's worth):

(1) While we still have a good chance to avoiding a second global recession, total global growth will likely be fairly small over the next decade, with much of the growth concentrated in emerging economies (although I strongly suspect that growth will slow considerably in China and India, since both nations rely far more on exports than on local consumer spending to drive their economies).

(2) Growth will likely be minimal to stagnant across much of the developed world for the next 5-10 years, especially in the US and the EU, and there's a good chance of a break-up of the euro zone and the end of the euro as a common currency.

(3) Canada's economy, while obviously impacted by events in the US and the EU, will likely be more resilient with stronger growth prospects (due at least in part to demand for natural resources from emerging economies).

I agree with that. Although I think that in the current climate, after stimulus money failed to return us to pre-recession levels, that you'll have a hard time convincing the majority of people that it is, after all, the answer.

My main beef is with the idea that giving the rich and corporations additional capital to invest actually results in investment. It doesn't. Give an employer a tax break, he's still not going to hire more workers until the demand is there to justify it. No workers being hired, no workers making money, no money being spent, no demand to justify hiring workers.

Also, economies have hidden behind credit (consumer and government debt) in a bid to appear healthy. Demand was strong because the poor had access to additional funds that they thought they could afford to spend and the government had lots of money to spend on public works and other services, many of which they overpaid for. Creating demand with credit is false demand, because it subtracts from demand later when the credit must be repaid.

I'm afraid we're in for a rough decade because the goal doesn't seem to be to create demand.
 
(3) Canada's economy, while obviously impacted by events in the US and the EU, will likely be more resilient with stronger growth prospects (due at least in part to demand for natural resources from emerging economies).

You vastly underestimate the ability of the Harper government to destroy the Canadian economy. In a Harper majority government, we have the coming of George Bush economics to Canada.
 
The economy runs on the spending of money; poor people have none to spend and the rich have sequestered so much they can't get it back into circulation fast enough. Even if they weren't interested in simply piling up as much as they can.

Three cubic acres of money not going anywhere = recession in Duckville.
 
This time round the depression has a second angle it didn't the first time.
Resource depletion.

water, oil, fish, arable land....
We are living through the sixth great extinction, all that combined with climate change playing havok with agriculture means we are in for a ride.
 
This time round the depression has a second angle it didn't the first time.
Resource depletion.

water, oil, fish, arable land....
We are living through the sixth great extinction, all that combined with climate change playing havok with agriculture means we are in for a ride.

Or to put it in economist speak this is not a ceterus paribus situation. I am generally in agreement that something very different is the case today and the past is no longer as a good a guide as it was. Then again, I'm just some schmoe on the Internet just like the rest of you schmoes.
 
the richest individuals and corporations (ie. the "job creators") are sitting on records amount of cash

It's more accurate to say that the "job creators" are on the demand side, not on the supply side. Financing can be arranged in many ways--say by pooling the money of the middle class into an investment fund. If there's a demand, somebody will figure out a way to supply it.

The fact that the rich are hoarding cash also would indicate that stimulus applied to the rich would be ineffective, and in fact they could take some significant tax rises without making any difference to the job situation.

The most likely reason why the rich are hoarding their cash is a lack of demand...
 
It's more accurate to say that the "job creators" are on the demand side, not on the supply side. Financing can be arranged in many ways--say by pooling the money of the middle class into an investment fund. If there's a demand, somebody will figure out a way to supply it.

The fact that the rich are hoarding cash also would indicate that stimulus applied to the rich would be ineffective, and in fact they could take some significant tax rises without making any difference to the job situation.

The most likely reason why the rich are hoarding their cash is a lack of demand...
That's if there is still any middle class after the richest few percent have snagged forty or more percent of the wealth. And the poor can't 'demand' by offering money the way the rich think of 'demand', having forgotten stuff like the sans-culottes. What's going on currently is the result of systematically plundering and impoverishing the customer base. Those toasters the factory in China makes may have sold at a price low enough even the guys who used to make them here could afford. Once. But they haven't worked much since then. There's no sign our entrepreneurial class have learned what farmers did eons ago—the smarter ones anyway—if you don't plow stuff back into the soil it won't make you rich.
 
You have it backwards, half US households pay zero or negative income taxes (and reduced payroll taxes), the top .1% pay more taxes then 80% of the population. Demand doesn't come from tax cuts but from income, which comes from jobs, which comes from investment. The instability in the global economy and anti-business policies have caused job creators (80% of thoses firms with less than 500 employees) to hold on and not invest.

OTB
 
You have it backwards, half US households pay zero or negative income taxes (and reduced payroll taxes), the top .1% pay more taxes then 80% of the population.
You have it backwards.
Globalism IS the reason households pay zero or negative income taxes! They lost their jobs which of course dropped them to this position! When they HAD jobs, before YOU sent them to those commies you pal around with, they paid more taxes!
But don't worry my obfuscating fuzzy numbers bot, things will get better when all those jobs are created by YOUR Globalism as YOU promised .....how many years ago, FFS???

The top .1% pay more taxes then 80% of the population, because they have had all the money redistributed up to them due to Globalism....which IS REALLY another name for Class Warfare! The top .1% have everything they ever dreamed for and now simply hoard cash and sit on it!

It's really this simple bottie that only fools and phony incredibly stupid professors couldn't see....:rolleyes:
 
A lot of companies are despicable. They let someone go and instead of hiring someone new to replace them, management takes that job and then splits the duties between 2 or 3 other workers. Employers will always lower their expenses by cutting salary expense first.