What if we only criminalized the men?

whollycheeses

hung like a squirrel
Jan 28, 2006
408
7
18
Peeler Region
This does not seem like fair and objective reporting. Actually, it sounds like Mr. Malarek is angry at himself (for his own perceived guilt) for things he may have done in the past...


Prostitution: What if we only criminalized the men? TheStar.com - Insight - Prostitution: What if we only criminalized the men?
Sweden did, and with stunning success, says a new book about johns. Could it work here?
April 12, 2009
Leslie Scrivener
STAFF REPORTER

In the international exploitation and trafficking of women for sex, it's men, the customers, who have been overlooked, writes Victor Malarek, in his new book, The Johns: Sex for Sale and the Men who Buy It. One of Canada's top investigative reporters, Malarek urges governments to go after the johns, whom he calls "the users and abusers."

Some claim that women choose to work as prostitutes, but you call it the ultimate act of humiliation and desperation.

A very small number do it by choice. Studies show that the vast majority, 89 per cent in one, desperately want out. They're hungry, need to feed children or give health care to aging parents, and the only alternative is to take their clothes off and service platoons of men.

They can't get any other work?

Not in many Third World countries or where sex tourists go. For women in Moscow, Kiev, other parts of Ukraine, there is absolutely no work for young women. They are in abject poverty ... There are so many escorts, from Third World countries, you have to ask, "How did they get here?" They don't have business acumen or language skills. On the lower east side in Vancouver, the vast majority have serious mental-health issues, drug issues, or are native women tossed off reserves. They're controlled by pimps with a bag of white powder. The drug is their handcuffs.

You say men are the root of the problem, and in seeking a "moment of bliss," they deepen the misery of the women they pay for sex.

These men never ask how she is, how did she get here, is she being forced. They don't look into her eyes beyond the veneer of gaudy makeup, stiletto heels and cheap clothes. They just want to get their rocks off. When money changes hands, it's the ultimate conscience pacifier. They don't have to deal with guilt.

Most johns you encountered express entitlement, like the one who urged his fellow "mongers" to get out there and "enjoy what man was put here for." Do johns know what women really think of them?

They delude themselves into believing that every moan and groan is because of their magnetic masculinity. They want to believe it, and the women are trained to do this.

The story of Norm, a john who confesses his capacity to "ignore" the effects of his hobby, is revealing. His insight was rare?

When anyone on the world (online) sex sites raises the question about conscience, they are immediately asked, "Are you a feminist, a fem-Nazi, a fundamentalist? Who are you?" They don't want anyone to raise the question.

You have no patience with what you call the "happy-hooker lobby," which claims that these are pros who take pride in their jobs and exercise choice.

The happy-hooker crowd is shilling for the porn industry, the strip clubs, pimps and escort services. The big hot button is health. Women carry health cards to show they are disease-free. Why just women? Why should they be the ones playing Russian roulette every time a guy comes in? Guys are the vectors of disease. On those sites they say, "I like to go `bareback.'" It's the men who go home and transfer it to their significant others. Then there's harm "reduction." They don't say "elimination." They can never guarantee a woman will not be beaten up by her next john.

Many people think it's safest for women to legalize prostitution. Why don't you?

In Amsterdam, the mayor is saying, "What a big fricking mistake." Women are still controlled en masse by pimps, beaten, trafficked, forced. They are on drugs. Organized crime is all over this. Unions never happened. Escape clauses for women who wanted to get out – they didn't put in place the measures they were supposed to. When a country legalizes prostitution, it lives off the avails of prostitution through taxation and in effect becomes a pimp.

If johns are charged, as you recommend, how would women be protected?

I strongly believe the vast majority of women are victims and shouldn't be charged or picked up in vice raids. You should pick up the men. They are demanding it, doing whatever they want. Sweden decriminalized the women and criminalized the men. They know it is a human-rights violation, that you'll never have equality and dignity and respect for women as long as this is allowed. Sweden is a beacon. The number of prostituted women has been reduced by half. Norway just introduced legalisation in January.

Would it work here?

I believe it would. We have a mishmash of laws that don't seem to make sense. Sweden is concerned with equality of women ... and an option for women to be retrained, to seek psychological help, all the safety valves. Here, there is certainly no protection for women.

Why do you say we can't "give up" and say prostitution has been part of life and likely always will be?

You hear clichés that prostitution is the oldest profession. I counter that it's the oldest oppression. I don't live in a dreamland. I know it will always exist, but we have to put breaks on what has become an absolute sexual calamity around the world. Look at the planeloads of men arriving in Thailand, or Costa Rica, bars filled with Canadian men, and think of millions of young women around the world servicing from three to four to 20 men a day. This seems to be more and more accepted. Traffickers, pimps and brothel owners can't find enough local women, so they hunt down petrified girls who have never wanted to do this.

Can you see any circumstance where you'd understand why a man would visit a prostitute – invalid wives, sexless marriages, and men with disabilities?

I tell them, "Go look for a relationship." There are a lot of men who are extremely lazy. They say they don't want the drama, they don't want to invest in relationships.

You've written about your own difficult youth. Did you ever have any such encounters?

No ... I was in a hotel talking to a prostitute, she said, "By the way, I normally charge $175, but because you're good-looking I'll charge you $100." My jaw dropped. I didn't know what to say ...

I walked away.
 
First, I thought that people who are paid to write for a living might actually be expected to know how to construct a valid argument. Instead we have a random collection of fragmented thoughts.

My thoughts are this. We already have laws that prohibit sexual slavery, human trafficking, rape, extortion, pimping, drugs etc.....Those laws shoud be enforced.

After that the government should have NO say in who I have sex with. Whether i offer a financial reward to that person is nobodys business. In fact the reason that women in the industry are so vulnerable to criminal elements is because the law has marginalized them
 
Please identify the country you're—or Victor is—referring to. In Canada men are only in danger of criminally offending as pimps, as guys stupid enough to try to get hookers on the street or as guys patronizing incalls. While we could deal with number two and three as lesser, ticketable offences, don't you think the neighbours would still want the law's help rousting the sort of nuisance un regulated prostitution can be? Exploitive pimpsing we would likely still want to be a crime, though perhaps with a less catchall definition.

He's a great guy for passion and conviction in the interests of the helpless and exploited, but logical argument was never Victor's strong suit. Still, for places where every aspect of sex-for-money's some sort of crime that case needs to be made. Like drugs, the offence is nuisance level, not criminal.
 
The thing that bugs me about the "story" is that the Star's staff reporter didn't do anything really that take exerpts from the book. Where's the reporting? Where's the investigation? She's simply a pimp herself for flogging this guy's concepts.

The line that lost me was when he wrote: "These men never ask how she is, how did she get here, is she being forced. They don't look into her eyes beyond the veneer of gaudy makeup, stiletto heels and cheap clothes. They just want to get their rocks off. When money changes hands, it's the ultimate conscience pacifier. They don't have to deal with guilt."

I for one OFTEN ask about her, how'd she get into the biz, what's her exit plan, etc etc. The second anyone says "These men..." he knows not of what he speaks. Sure there are some who are just looking for a hole to blow their load in and treat the women as such (and these guys are the lowest of the low) but thankfully there are a LOT of guys who are the direct opposite.

I wonder, did the author talk to a wide range of working girls? Or are these just his suppositions? I for one asked a popular EE lady (who has since retired) about leaving the industry and settling down. Her answer? HELL no. She said "I have tried the relationship route and I get bored after a week and I have yet to meet a single guy who can keep up to me in bed....".
 
whollycheeses said:
This does not seem like fair and objective reporting.

A very small number do it by choice. Studies show that the vast majority, 89 per cent in one, desperately want out. They're hungry, need to feed children or give health care to aging parents, and the only alternative is to take their clothes off and service platoons of men.



Can you see any circumstance where you'd understand why a man would visit a prostitute – invalid wives, sexless marriages, and men with disabilities?

I tell them, "Go look for a relationship." There are a lot of men who are extremely lazy. They say they don't want the drama, they don't want to invest in relationships.


Oh yeah, 89% want out....sure and 89% of us would like to win the lottery and quit our jobs...


Have to agree with that being lazy in relationships :D
 
I don't think you can judge prostitution in the world by the standards of prostitution in Canada.

It's a picnic here compared to many places in the world.
 
My post on this topic from another thread on April 4:

Victor Malarek is a moron who understands nothing about the business. I read reviews of his book and his claims are not applicable to the mainstream Canadian industry at all. He is one of those "All Johns are evil slashers" types who think clients set out on an evil mission to dehumanize women by destroying their lives. What he writes about sex slavery in the Balkans, etc is nasty stuff, but that is not what happens in the mainstream Toronto industry. He only interviewed 16 clients and took a selective bit of content from SP/client website boards.

One review of the book makes note that the author needs to be taken to task for presenting a one-sided picture to further his own political agenda of banning all prostitution:

http://www.quillandquire.com/reviews...review_id=6477

"Malarek must also be taken to task for his claim that “prostitution – all prostitution – is not about choice.” The six-year-old Thai girl forced to administer to sex tourists, or the Moldovan teenager who’s kidnapped and shipped to Serbia for repeated raping, inhabit a world far different than the high-society pros who serviced Charlie Sheen and Eliot Spitzer for thousands of dollars an hour. It has to be acknowledged that some prostitutes do exercise significant agency in their lives." Malarek sees all prostitutes as victims requiring saving by the law.
 
What is he advocating, a religious police to enforce morality?:mad:

We do not need police here to establish "morality/virtue" division that perform or function similar to those in Saudi Arabia (Sunni Islam), Iran (Shia Islam), Pakistan western frontier (Al-Qaida) or shockingly some parts of Israel where the Haredis run the community. That's dangerous to set up Christian, be Catholic, Protestant or Orthodox equivalent here.

Doing so will set up an ominious precedence to enforce policies that are detrimental to both men and women's rights. Legalizing mandatory female circumcision and honour killing to uphold morality, anyone??

What we need is legalizing prostitution that set it up right the first time, consistent, fair enforcement thereafter and fix the loophole when necessary.

Don't get me wrong, he is very good at investigative journalism on most reports but this one is too biased. Regarding the female staff reporter who printed this article, I am disturbed as a right wing article like this should be printed in G&M or National Post, instead of leftie newspaper like the "Red Star".

Unless she believes all the gender feminist rant that some in NDP and Iggy's party are truly believe in. Wonder why the star stops people posting comments on their website once the article got circulated.

BTW, this article is essentially shilling Victor's new book, on sale soon. It's essentially a marketing ploy to dramatize and sensationlize the issue. The strategy is identicial to people like Nouriel Roubini, Eric Sprott, Meredith Witney, Ian Gordon, Nissim Taleb and Harry Dent who repeatedly feed the public the doom and gloom message or bluntly the end of capitalism/world as we know it, while simultaneously rigging generous sums of money from the roadshows, speaking and book signing engagements and worst pimping scared people to invest on their expensively managed funds!

One has to question what's the author's hidden agenda behind these dramatic, sometimes sensational claims and Victor Malarek is no different.
 
poonhunter said:
What next, cigarettes users to be "criminalized", how about we criminalize some staff reports for their articles.

Cigarettes users could not be "criminialized" as like it or not, in the eyes of all levels of governments, they are loyal customers/indispensible to feed expansive, expensive government runs programs and pay hefty perks to unionized government workers via heavy taxation.

Governments are equally "addicted" to smoking, except they see those smokers as annuity. The politicians and "ambulance chasing" litigation lawyers only love to bash the tobacco companies routinely when,

-the politicians are pimping for votes from everybody, including lobbying groups from medical association
-the governments do not want expense overrun on treating those smokers when compared to the taxation generated from selling cigarettes
-the "ambulance chasing" lawyers who see a big jackpot by suing the tobacco companies as a whole with 10 figures fine, while taking a few % cut as compensation to their "hard work". This is rare in Canada but it's a norm in the states and thank goodness somebody in the governments there have common sense to stop this nonsense :rolleyes:

Now back to the original topic and stop hijacking it.
 
The LoLRus said:
I can see how successfull that was, go read some reviews of Swedish SP's:

http://www.internationalsexguide.info/forum/forumdisplay.php?f=205

If I could recall my undergrad days when I took courses on sociology, gender studies in particular, the profs, feminist or not would always use the Swedish/Scandinavia examples to justify and lobby the causes like this one.

What they never fully explain to us based on my understanding as a layman is there're significantly more women than men in Sweden, regardless of ages and many Swedish women are quite fully aware of their rights and motivated to lobby their interests. Plus their taxation are heavy and the money generated from the taxes are allocated to policies that are friendly to women.

Again my info could be outdated and incorrect.
 
I think that they are retarded to think that this is some that can be outlawed. There is huge demand for sex of all sorts, there is limited supply for sex of that sort (women, for whatever reason, aren't generally willing to give men the sort of sex they want) and the result is that economic forces inevitable come into play.

Women like money and need it just as much as anyone else, and prostitution is the result.

There are deadly serious problems in Canada (a la Willy Pickton), but criminalising male sexual desire won't do the trick in my view. I suppose we should criminalize women's love of money (the other side of the prostitution coin after) just so the law is half assed fair.

Also, what about women who prostitute men? What are they going to do about that? Or is this a female victim only crime?

I also think that such a law would be unconstitutional if it only targetted men.

Finally, on balance, I think that prostitution in Canada is not that bad (Willy Pickton's notwithstanding). Compared to other countries it's good and women really do have other choices here. They can get job doing low level work and work their way up to whatever they want. (I mean a woman who can be a prostitute, but can't be a cashier at Loblaws? C'mon, get real! They have a choice, they chose the money).

Women have no institutional barriers standing in their way (heck they own the institutions e.g. universities are over 50% women). Just because some women can't make their way in Canada other than by selling their bodies, doesn't mean there is problem. I suspect that this will always be the case. Plus for passingly smart women (and I've met the strippers and sp's who are those smart women) who were blessed with great looks or built their great looks (gym memberships and boob jobs and some surgery go a long way...) it can simply be a business decision about how they want to live their lives.

I fucking hate these goodie two shoes who don't believe in freedom. They have no problem with people being encouraged or rewarded for being a workaholic (which is no good for the workaholic, their families and probably society in general), but oh, the minute it's about sex, it's the root of all fucking evil.

Bullshit.

People will have sex. They will have sex in ways the goodie two shoes don't like. Get over it goodie two shoes and go on with your life. Help the real victim (like prostitutes in the downtown east side) and leave the rest of us alone.
 
The sole responsibility of government is to defend a nation's territory and to protect the individual freedoms of its citizens.

Censorship and the arbitrary imposition of "morality" leads us down the slipperly slope to totalitarianism.
 
This guy cites all the reasons for desperation that may drive women to prostitution. But really, what would they then do if prostitution were NOT available as an option? Would they steal? Would they be forced into abusive relationships? It's a well known fact that over 50% of workers do not like their jobs, so with prostitutes it's higher. What would the percentage be for people that work in meat processing plants for example?