What are we going to do about this?

krazyplayer

Member
Jun 9, 2004
484
1
18
Conservative MP Joy Smith is getting ready to make us the target of prosecutions when it comes to prostitution. While we should be decriminalizing these acts/transactions between consenting adults there always has to be a hysteric throwing a wrench into the improved direction things seem to be heading in light of the Bedford court challenge. Do you think the Harper government will pass a law that just targets clients and pimps (the men)?

http://www.vancouversun.com/news/Backbench+Smith+aims+abolish+trade/5055416/story.html
 
No, I do not see Ms. Smith's Private Members Bill becoming law.

Child Sex Trafficking (the subject of her startling success) is quite different from Prostitution.


Practical answer to your question: Write your M.P. use reasoned arguments, don't just say "vote against it." See if someone here on TERB wants to write a model letter.
 
When I warned of this happening right after Harper`s majority, I was dismissed. "It`ll never happen" I was told. Actually, it read, verbatim from my friend Aardvark, "That just isn`t going to happen and you know it as well as the rest of us Captain."

I hate it when I`m right all the time. :frusty:

I said the same thing as you.

Haper has a majority now and here comes the right wing social values. It will be baby steps at first, but make no mistake, the Canadian moral majority is salivating this golden opportunity. The article goes on to state that she has the support of Harper and other Conservative members.
 
I don't think this is a new development; I believe this private member's bill was put forth months ago.

Every so often some media outlet goes on a crusade on this topic (the Toronto Star and Citytv a few years ago, the Toronto Sun last year). The Vancouver Sun happens to be on one now, and this story fits nicely into their agenda.
 
When I warned of this happening right after Harper`s majority, I was dismissed. "It`ll never happen" I was told. Actually, it read, verbatim from my friend Aardvark, "That just isn`t going to happen and you know it as well as the rest of us Captain."

I hate it when I`m right all the time. :frusty:
It is still a private members bill, they very, very rarely become law. The principle reason her last private members bill did was who was going to argue against or vote against increasing the penalties for Sexual Trafficking in Children!!!!!
 
I might add if this project does get a model letter or at least discussion points have it posted on MERB and PERB as well.
 
It is still a private members bill, they very, very rarely become law. The principle reason her last private members bill did was who was going to argue against or vote against increasing the penalties for Sexual Trafficking in Children!!!!!

The conservatives have a track record of putting their moral agenda through as private members bills that in reality have the full support of their caucus. It allows them to pander to their radical right base while pretending that it isn't policy, even though it is.

Many of us predicted this.
 
I'm not worried. They won't pass it because it will get overturned in court. The Conservatives will also look like sexually repressed idiots if they push this. Canadians have matured and changed. If worse comes to worse, escort agencies and massage parlours can just start publishing names of MP's who support the legislation and their major contributors that are their customers.
 
Last edited:
in sweden and norway where they pass this similar law it is still easy to hobby.
 
Her first private members bill became law.

Do you really think that there is a single Conservative MP that is going to publicly support the sex trade? The best that we can hope for is that enough Conservative MP's are not in the House when the 1st Reading takes place.
 
Harper kept his "moral majority" types in check with the promise of a majority government. Well it has come time to pay for the silence of his caucus.
 
Her first private members bill became law.

Do you really think that there is a single Conservative MP that is going to publicly support the sex trade? The best that we can hope for is that enough Conservative MP's are not in the House when the 1st Reading takes place.
As mentioned before I believe there is a HUGE difference between Sexual Trafficking of Children and the Hobby.

There are I believe a fair number of M.P.s who will agree that this is a Nations bedroom issue unless the bill is narrowly tailored to address soliciting on the street alone.

As said before, if members are truly concerned write your M.P. don't bitch here on TERB.
 
Courtesy of Fuji in another thread: One point for a letter: Adultery has been decriminalized, there is even a website which promotes adulterous relationships and which has gotten much attention in the mainstream press. If Adultery is not to be re-criminalized, why should either procuring the services of a prostitute or soliciting for prostitution remain criminal acts? What logical difference is there between the two.
 
Courtesy of Fuji in another thread: One point for a letter: Adultery has been decriminalized, there is even a website which promotes adulterous relationships and which has gotten much attention in the mainstream press. If Adultery is not to be re-criminalized, why should either procuring the services of a prostitute or soliciting for prostitution remain criminal acts? What logical difference is there between the two.
Adultery is different because it's gender neutral while johns are 99% male.

Males in so-called first world countries are lately surrendering their territory left, right and center. It would be quite logical if males right to buy sex was denied.
 
Last edited:
Courtesy of Fuji in another thread: One point for a letter: Adultery has been decriminalized, there is even a website which promotes adulterous relationships and which has gotten much attention in the mainstream press. If Adultery is not to be re-criminalized, why should either procuring the services of a prostitute or soliciting for prostitution remain criminal acts? What logical difference is there between the two.

You are preaching to the converted here on terb, this is an escort review board, of course the majority here are going to think that it's ludicrous to criminalize prostitution.

The question is whether the majority of MP's can be persuaded of that, in a Commons now dominated by the religious right's favorite party.