Care to quote any more from that thread? Or any of the others I posted on around that time?
LOL
No, I thought not.
"1. Leafs won in seven games. How's that for a statistic? The Leafs scored more goals and allowed fewer. It doesn't get more basic than that."
Win-Loss is a good statistic. The most basic. Total offense and total defense are slightly more detailed. These are both statistics. What's your point? This is a good argument that I think statistics are important.
"Shots don't win series, or even games. Goals do."
Seems clear to me. What about this do you disagree with?
You were arguing that because one team *outshot* another, that they must have played better. This is a good example of how NOT to apply statistics to analysis. LOL The whole point of my argument, which you evidently STILL fail to grasp, even after a couple of years, is that hockey is a game of both offense AND defense. Shots is a good measure of overall offensive output, and it also says something about the calibre of the defense that you're playing. BUT, it can't say ANYTHING about the opposing goaltending of a team. The fact that A outshot B 50-25 tells you NOTHING of the respective goaltending. Does it? If you look at that game, and see that B won, you can say "B outplayed A because of goaltending". Getting clearer? (No, no hope of that, after all this time.)
This is sorta like arguing that the best indicator of overall team play in baseball is hits. The team that outhits the other has outplayed them. Uh, well, no. Hits are useful, but it's RUNS that count. And, in the end, even RUNS don't tell the whole tale. It's runs scored vs. runs allowed. This is called "the final score". It almost always tells you who won a game - who *outplayed* whom. (My definition.)
" new2game, you're absolutely right on about the scoreboard being the final arbiter and these guys just not getting it.
I could point out some useful references on sports analysis to these guys - statistics as they pertain to hockey, comparing players, the usefulness and applicability of various stats, etc. I'm afraid they wouldn't have a clue what was being talked about, though."
The scoreboard IS the final arbiter of who outplayed whom.
And, in what universe does my offering to refer people to sites ABOUT STATISTICS imply that I don't think statistics mean anything? LOL
Nice try, Goob. Well, actually not.
I know you'd love to TRY to take all my statements out of context - which is what you did here - this may be the only way you have of actually winning an argument with me.
I certainly hope people look at that thread. The whole point, which I made many times, was that *when you're trying to determine who *outplayed* whom, the final score should tell you*. Shots is a failure, because it tells you nothing about goaltending. Which, last time I checked, was a pretty important indicator of success in hockey.
Anything else?
LOL