salsamarc said:
nope just you and JP are idiots for not keeping him to a league minimun....
your URL is total bullshit the question was put to YOU what he has done for the Jays and you are still hiding your head in the sand
*sigh* It's sad. It really is.
But, to explain things .....
You see, in baseball, there's this thing called "arbitration". And, it just so happens, that after Carpenter's scintillating 2002 season (4-5, 5.28 ERA, 73 IP), in the middle of which he blew out his arm, he was due for the arbitration-thingy from the Jays. His final salary was 3.5 million, up from 2.6 the previous year. And, you see, there are enough idiots like you and TP hearing arbitration cases (or, maybe that's just the way the system is constructed), that they were bound to say "Boy, look at that guy's potential! Look at his stuff! Look at his mechanics!", and promptly give him a decent raise. Or, at least, NOT cut his salary to the league minimum.
The Jays might then have been stuck with a 3.5+ million dollar pitcher with no right arm. The odds of being able to trade him at that point would seem to be rather small.
Some people might think that's a bad thing, especially for a team that has to cut payroll.
The Jays COULDN'T sign him for league minimum. The best they could do was cut him outright, and let him test the market. The market yielded major league minimum from one club. The Jays weren't that club. Neither were thirty other teams.
Again, you've dodged my question TOTALLY - is everyone else an idiot for thinking Carpenter was done? It's very simple. It really requires a very simple answer. One you're obviously not capable of either grasping or admitting.
As for defending JP, I guess you're also totally incapable of reading simple web pages. I know, it's tough - some of them don't have pictures of naked ladies (men?) on them.
Here's how I defend JP, in a nutshell:
"When JP Ricciardi took over as the Blue Jays’ new GM in November 2001, this was the starting lineup that greeted him, along with the present-day status of those players:
Darrin Fletcher RET
Carlos Delgado Fla
Homer Bush RET
Tony Batista JPN
Alex Gonzalez Tam
shannon stewart Min
Jose Cruz Los
Raul Mondesi RET
Brad Fullmer RET
Chris Carpenter StL
Esteban Loaiza Was
Joey Hamilton RET
Steve Parris RET
Chris Michalak RET
Billy Koch RET
That team finished 3rd, 2 games below .500, and cost about $72 million. Nine of the 16 starters are out of North American baseball; only Delgado and Carpenter are still solid players, the latter thanks in no small part to Dave Duncan. ...
What Ricciardi has done, and it should not be overlooked, is to assemble a respectable roster every season since 2003 on a very limited budget — a budget that was, until this season, hamstrung by the Carlos Delgado contract. I do include 2004 in there, because the roster was competitive on Opening Day that year – it was, however, subsequently shredded by injuries, and while $50M spent intelligently can buy you a decent starting 16, it won’t buy you depth, as Dave Berg and Howie Clark can attest. ...
It might be helpful, at this point, to recall just what was left in the minor-league cupboard by Gord Ash before JP Ricciardi came on board. Out of these 30 position players and 18 pitchers three years ago, there is today one bona fide star (Hudson), three regulars (Chacin, Rios, Chulk), three marginal big-leaguers (Werth, Gross, Hendrickson) and one top prospect (Quiroz). The remaining 40 players (83%) are out of baseball or are minor-league veterans. Remember that regardless of who was general manager, Paul Godfrey was under orders to chop the team’s 2001 payroll of $72M. Now try to imagine the Blue Jays of the past few years with a $50M payroll, few if any free-agent acquisitions, and many of these guys filling out the roster. ...
There's lots more, but that's an awful lot for your little brain to digest.
I'll leave it with you.
Just reply to my other two requests.