What are the Blue Jays missing?

What is the missing piece????

  • Starting Pitching

    Votes: 44 34.4%
  • Middle Relief

    Votes: 13 10.2%
  • a Closer

    Votes: 6 4.7%
  • more Offense (big bats = more money)

    Votes: 30 23.4%
  • a Short Stop

    Votes: 3 2.3%
  • Carlos Delgado

    Votes: 14 10.9%
  • someone to kick J.P. Richardi's ass ????

    Votes: 18 14.1%

  • Total voters
    128
Most of the points Ranger has made, I see as GM mistakes. Point Blank dude!!! Lol.

(why are you so bitter and angry?)

Anyways, he can keep thinking JP is perfect, and knows how to build a winner, while finding the time to flip through exact stats while he posts here, getting his point out in bitter anger, and I'll try and get ahold of Buck Martinez to get the real scoop on JP.

We just have to see what happens next year. If after that, the Jays are not contenders, then he should be canned.

Mark Eichorn and Danny Cox were also important relievers to piece the puzzle together. Another quality a good GM has. What has JP done again? Oh I know. Not a whole lot. He has realized it takes talented young players to win a playoff birth. Pass the man a cigar!

And since you asked, I do know about power pitching mechanics. Do you? :)
 
Salsa, you're still on Ignore.
Is there something about *that* you fail to comprehend as well?
;)
LOL
 
More useful contributions.
LOL
Oh, by the way, they use a *bat* in baseball, not a "stick".
One more reason why you guys should stick to hockey.
:D
 
Next season the Jays need 2 power bats in the lineup, a bonafide closer and probably a solid #2 or #3 starter...... Plus a healthy Halladay....
 
Brownie69 said:
Next season the Jays need 2 power bats in the lineup, a bonafide closer and probably a solid #2 or #3 starter...... Plus a healthy Halladay....

That sounds pretty much bang on, except I think they can get by with a #3 or #4 starter - but that's just splitting hairs.
That's exactly what JP says, too.
Whether they can *get* all those guys is another question.
 
Chill, guys. Baseball's just a game. But seriously, Stewart's simply having an off year this year. In the past, he was a solid .300+ hitter with doubles power and a knack of hitting in the clutch and sparkplugging the batting order. And Delgado would have been back if he was offered an appropriate deal for a guy with his talent. Instead, Ricciardi figured he could save $ and make Hinske the next Delgado. (Ohh the pathos of it all!)

The team has to realize that they have to spend some $ to compete. They need a decent catcher as Zaun is having an unusually good year. They need at least one bat to protect Wells and produce runs. Pitching looks good IMHO. And Ranger is right: Lilly had a good - not great - year last year. I hope he returns to form.
 
Regarding the idiocy of condemning JP on the basis of Chris Carpenter, here's the analysis of said pitcher by Baseball Prospectus during the off-season after his surgery:
"Carpenter is coming off labrum surgery, which makes him something of an unknown quantity for 2004. Still, it's a reasonable gamble for a team that's in need of rotation help. He'll never be anything better than a solid fourth starter, but then again his minor league numbers never really portended anything greater, despite the hype."
He signed for major league minimum, then turned into a star.
Anyone who says they knew Carpenter was going to be a star is lying. They might have *guessed*, but it was, at the time, a bad guess. The guess of almost every educated, informed baseball person was that he wouldn't pan out.

Regarding Stewart, one man's off-year is another man's trend. His average dropped three years running with the Jays. It shot up when he went to Minnesota. Now it's dropped two years running with the Twins, as well as his OBP and his SLG, both precipitously. He's lost significant time to injury both years. Stewart is a man whose game was speed. It's pretty much totally gone now, at 31, and he's got not much left in the tank. This year, Reed Johnson was a superior player for a FRACTION of the cost. There never was any comparison defensively. Stewart is a poor defender with a terrible arm. This would seem to be a POSITIVE for Riciardi, although a bigger positive would be getting a slugging left-fielder rather than someone of Johnson's or Stewart's ilk. They don't need "sparkplugs". They need "sluggers". Still, the loss of Stewart doesn't hurt the team one iota. It's an improvement.

The money wasn't there for Delgado. As I posted previously, there was all kinds of (quite reasonable) pressure not to resign Delgado for anything like he was making last year. With the way the race went this year, Delgado in the lineup wouldn't have changed much. Even adding a healthy Halladay would have only got them close.

They don't need to "realize" anything. I think it's quite apparent to them that the more they spend, the more they'll be competitive. Which is why, in spring training, Rogers committed a boatload more money to the payroll. If JP can roll 15 to 30 mil into the team this coming year - that translates into a premiere FA and assorted odds and ends (shoring up the staff) - that'll be a plus.

He's got *one* year left on his five-year plan. The problem with "five-year plans" is that people expect results - since you, yourself, have essentially guaranteed them. We'll see how the cookie crumbles next year.
 
Ranger68 said:
"Carpenter is coming off labrum surgery, which makes him something of an unknown quantity for 2004. Still, it's a reasonable gamble for a team that's in need of rotation help. He'll never be anything better than a solid fourth starter, but then again his minor league numbers never really portended anything greater, despite the hype."
He signed for major league minimum, then turned into a star.
Anyone who says they knew Carpenter was going to be a star is lying. They might have *guessed*, but it was, at the time, a bad guess. The guess of almost every educated, informed baseball person was that he wouldn't pan out.

ISN'T THAT THE WHOLE POINT????? HE SIGNED FOR A LEAGUE MINIMUN AND NOW THE GUY IS A CY YOUNG AWARD WINNER (I WAS GOING TO ASK IF YOU ARE AN IDIOT FOR NOT REALIZING THIS...... BUT YOU HAVE ALREADY PROVEN TO MY SATISFACTION THAT YES YOU ARE AN IDIOT IN A PINK PIJAMA)
 
Okay, I've taken you off Ignore just to read some of your ramblings - and since you obviously can't seem to understand just what the fuck that meant - namely, THAT I COULDN'T READ YOUR POSTINGS.
LOL
Anyway, to reply to your continued rambling, MY point, since you need it spelled out for you, is this:
to condemn JP for failing to resign Carpenter would be to condemn pretty much everyone else in baseball.
Were the Baseball Prospectus guys idiots for failing to realize that Carpenter was a star-in-waiting? Because that's not what they thought.
Were all the other GMs idiots for not signing him and letting him go to the Cardinals for minimum salary? Surely, he would have signed with someone else if they'd offered him more money, no?
He was due for arbitration with the Jays and would certainly have earned MUCH more than major league minimum. So, JP could have signed the guy for a mil or two - a sub-.500 guy coming off major arm surgery - or he could have let him walk. He let him walk. The only team interested was the Cards, and only at the lowest amount possible.

Are you saying that all these other guys are idiots, too? That you're the only guy around who ISN'T an idiot? Because that's the logical corrolary to your point that JP is an idiot for not re-signing him. And that, once again, is MY point. That you're an idiot for thinking that way, and that your hindsight doesn't make you knowledgeable about baseball.

Anyway, answer, please.
 
Ranger, Ranger, Ranger....the point many people are trying to make is not whether or not all GM's are idiots or not.....is whether JP is an idiot so far i believe most people will agree that he has not done anything for the Jay's in these past 4 years and we have provided FACTS as to why WE believe he is an IDIOT....

YOU on the other hand have been kissing JP's ass ever since you entered this thread telling the whole world out there what a great knowledge you have of the game......yet many, many many times you have been asked to provide FACTS as to why JP is such a great GM and all you do is create smoke and mirrors and change the topic elsewhere.....

in other words if you think he is such a great guy, such fabulous GM then by all means let's hear what he has done (in your opinion) to make this a better team the past 4 years the Jays will finish below .500 once again this year..

so is time for you to put up or SHUT UP
 
salsamarc said:
Ranger, Ranger, Ranger....the point many people are trying to make is not whether or not all GM's are idiots or not.....is whether JP is an idiot so far i believe most people will agree that he has not done anything for the Jay's in these past 4 years and we have provided FACTS as to why WE believe he is an IDIOT....

I'm talking to YOU, not "many people". Speak for yourself.
I've totally refuted your main piece of evidence.
Or, is it that you think all those other guys I named are idiots, too?
Answer, please.
You have provided NO facts.

salsamarc said:
YOU on the other hand have been kissing JP's ass ever since you entered this thread telling the whole world out there what a great knowledge you have of the game......

Please quote where I kissed JP's ass.

salsamarc said:
yet many, many many times you have been asked to provide FACTS as to why JP is such a great GM and all you do is create smoke and mirrors and change the topic elsewhere.....

I've never said he was a great GM. I've defended him from your inane, uneducated accusations.
But, please read that URL I posted.
Funny, I thought that might have been construed as a defense. ;)

salsamarc said:
in other words if you think he is such a great guy, such fabulous GM then by all means let's hear what he has done (in your opinion) to make this a better team the past 4 years the Jays will finish below .500 once again this year..

Read the URL. Let's discuss it.

salsamarc said:
so is time for you to put up or SHUT UP

Answer my questions. Reply. Very simple.
Or, it will be very clear that you know nothing of what you speak.
That's three things I've asked you to do: answer whether you think pretty much everyone else in baseball is an idiot, too, for not thinking Carpenter was going to get better; quote where I kissed JP's ass; read that URL which contains many of my defenses of JP.
I await your reply.
If you're incapable of any of those things, let me know. Or maybe you could get help.
LOL
 
I've answered your "question".
(Though you did not post any. Learn grammar.)
My answer to what JP had done is mostly, as I've pointed out, contained in the URL I referenced. I agree with most of what was posted there. If you're incapable of clicking a URL, ask for help.
I await, still, your reply.