oagre said:
Okay, I agree with everybody - slightly. Carpenter was let go because his arm blew out and he appeared to be through. Otherwise the Jays would likely have kept him. St L picked him up on a minor league contract as a "what have we got to lose" and he turned out for them big-time. Chances were overwhelming he would have stayed a dead arm has-been, like Sirotka or Hamilton or Hansen or a dozen others. So IMHO not JP's fault.
Agreed. As I said, it doesn't help his resume. But, then again, *nobody* else wanted him. To infer that JP thus can't "see potential" is just TOTAL BULLSHIT.
oagre said:
I do however think the JP show is starting to look a lot like smoke and mirrors. For the first year it looked pretty good - Hudson, Phelps, Hinske were all solid Rookie of the Year prospects. Of course two didn't develop - which might just be the breaks. The ? is what do the Jays have now??
Phelps is gone - we got a warm body for him. Advantage - JP. *wink*
Hudson looks pretty damn good. He's going to collect his first GG this year.
Hinske has had a good second-half, but winning RoY unfairly promoted expectations. I think it's an organizational fault to have stuck with him so long, but he hasn't been a total loss in the second half (.290 - .354 - .450). I think he's got to go, because the Jays are desperate for power and 1B is a position where it should be easy to stick a slugger - but, I think he's one of those guys who might leave and develop into something. (Then, of course, you'd have all the clowns come in and say "I SAW his potential. JP's an idiot.")
How about Adams? He's gonna finish in the top ten for RoY this year. How about Gabe Gross?
oagre said:
The new young pitching looks pretty promising. But the new position players are underwhelming. Rios has slipped, as has Hill. Stewart and Delgado would look pretty good in the batting order about now and there's no-one to replace them. So maybe this is the shape of things: ever-lowering payroll and a permanently medciocre team.
Rios and Hill are still developing. It's WAY too early to cast Hill off. He's only 23, and has shown he can hit in the show. To say "he's slipped" is just indicative of how hot he was to start the season. The combo of Johnson and Catalanotto has been better than Stewart, and provided better defense (.280 - .345 - .415 vs. .274 - .323 - .388). And cost about FOUR MILL less. Really, this is a feather in JP's cap. (Johnson, on his own, and for league minimum, looks a lot like Shannon. I think Stewart's just about done. He's just getting injured too much.)
Delgado would look good, sure. BUT HE LEFT. He didn't let them trade him. This can really hardly be blamed on JP. There was plenty of pressure to ditch the guy who was sucking up half the team payroll. I don't think Delgado's that much of a criticism of JP. This is a classic case of a team not being able to afford a guy, who then decided that he was going to screw the team by not letting them trade him, then go for the money elsewhere.
With all that in mind, I think your last sentence isn't justified. Not at all.
oagre said:
You have to ask whether the whole Moneyball concept has just become a slick ad slogan for hyping a perennial non-contender. I don't see the Sox and Yanks playing "moneyball".
I think this team really was unlucky this year, with all the one-run losses. Historically, this proves to be mostly due to luck, and reverses more often than not. The Jays have a good RS-RA ratio. Say what you want about sabermetrics, but if you were a betting man, you'd be a fool to bet against the trend this indicates.
Still, JP needs to deliver within the next couple of years. I think he likely will. With the addition of 15 mil or more into the payroll next year, the continued development of the young pitching, and the maturation of a couple of players (Hudson, Hill/Adams, Rios/Gross), this team WILL contend for the wildcard.
If he hasn't by then, these kinds of accusations may be justified.
Now, they're just not. It's just emotion.