bigdik said:
Sabermetrics evaluates a players potential. It's a scouting tool, an excellent talent evaluator and a damn fine way to evaluate how a player might meet the needs of your team. That's all it is. It doesn't account for "human factors".
I believe Earl's philosophy was pitching, defence and the 3 run homer, not 6 walks. Getting on base is obviously part of the equation, and it doesn't matter how you get on, but Bonds got on 375 times, give or take, in 04, scored 129 runs and hit 45 homers. Discounting the runs scored by his own home runs he only scored about 25% of the times he reached. I, and many "traditional" fans believe if you put the bat in his hands more often his OBP would have decreased but he'd have both scored and driven in more runs. Isn't that the stat that measures wins and losses? Hell, he was intentionally walked 120 times. Do you really think that would happen with ARod behind him? or Delgado, or any top power hitter?
Sabermetrics is the study of baseball statistics. It is VERY useful in both a team and individual sense.
What "human factors" does sabermetrics not account for? (In fact, it doesn't "account" for any. It doesn't "account" for anything. It *counts* things. But, what "human factors" do you think are not reflected in a player's or team's statistics?) Why is this an indictment? When you buy a car, do you ever ask for the horsepower of the engine? The mileage? Why bother, when these numbers don't account for the "human factors" like how comfortable it is, or how good it looks?
What makes you a "traditional" fan? Because you don't like statistics?
How do you think Earl got his three-run homers? I'll tell you. Walks. The walk-walk-homer was the quintessential weapon in Weaver's arsenal.
Bonds scored 84 times that year when he didn't drive himself in. Out of more than 320 times aboard. Yep, that's 25%.
If you took a bunch of those walks away, he'd have driven in more and scored LESS. He would NOT have scored more, by your own admission - nobody was hitting behind him. Look, he homered once every 8.3 at bats. So, take away *all* the intentional walks (120), and he homers fourteen more times. Let's be reasonably generous and say that there's an average of a runner and a half on every time - that's 35 more RBI. But, he scored 25% of the time he was aboard - taking away 120 walks means losing 30 runs. Adding in the times he scores with a basehit of his own, not a homerun (.275 when you lose the dingers), that's seven more runs, plus the 14 times he drives himself in. He loses 9 runs (30-21) and drives in 35 more.
If you assume that he's NEVER intentionally walked, you add something like 25-odd runs to the team. That's being pretty generous, but okay. ... Now, what happens to the guy hitting behind him? You've bumped up Barry's numbers (somewhat), but there just aren't that many runners on when Mr. Protection comes up. That costs him RBI, and costs the team runs (if you assume that those runs are "Barry's"). Those fourteen extra times that BB homered mean fourteen more bases-empty situations for that slugger, rather than all those (80 or more!) ducks on the pond opportunities (Barry being walked, on average, with one and a half runners on).
Even a weak hitter is getting another 80-odd PAs with the bags juiced or nearly so. Let's make him a .250 hitter, .400 slugger. That's pretty poor. You can run the numbers yourself, but that guy drives in somewhere in the neighbourhood of 20 more runs with Barry being walked than with Barry swinging away. Even a *weak* hitter.
You see how it's close to a zero-sum game? Even in the most fantastic circumstances - 120 intentional walks - you can't come up with 20 extra runs. Sure, if Carlos Delgado had been hitting behind Barry, let's say he's not walked 120 times. He's still walked a BUNCH, and the team doesn't score that many more runs, if any. Are Barry's numbers any better? His homeruns are. His OPS? Not much, and the team's offense is about the same. See how it works?
Sabermetrics is what it is. OPS is a good measure of the offensive value of a player, and in a team setting it's a valuable predictor of how well a team is going to score runs. To deny EITHER part of that sentence is not to have studied baseball.
Finally, the stat that measures wins and losses is called "wins and losses". Run differential is a good *sabermetric* predictor of that number. If you don't like "sabermetrics" you should just stick to ... well, watching. Don't even bother with statistics. None of them reflect any "human factors".
