What are the Blue Jays missing?

What is the missing piece????

  • Starting Pitching

    Votes: 44 34.4%
  • Middle Relief

    Votes: 13 10.2%
  • a Closer

    Votes: 6 4.7%
  • more Offense (big bats = more money)

    Votes: 30 23.4%
  • a Short Stop

    Votes: 3 2.3%
  • Carlos Delgado

    Votes: 14 10.9%
  • someone to kick J.P. Richardi's ass ????

    Votes: 18 14.1%

  • Total voters
    128
oagre said:
What are the Bue Jays missing?

Carlos Delgado. Batting around .300 with FLA. 100 RBI's and almost 30 HR's. If he was in a Blue Jays' uniform this year, we would be leading the wild card race, no question. I mean, Hinske has about 50 RBI's. Another 50 runs would win you at least another 15 games.

50 runs does not translate into 15 games.
It translates into about 5 more wins, which is roughly what Delgado is worth.
You're waaaaaaay off base.
This team, with Delgado, would NOT be the wildcard leader. With Delgado and HALLADAY, they're getting close.
 
so you are saying thst if Delgado was here we will be better by 5 wins????

sorry i must disagree with you there BIG TIME Delgado is a power hitter as well as a dangerous hitter you put Koskie and Hillebrand around him and their numbers would have been much better i do believe that Delgado alone could have win us at least 10 games and 15 games is not unheard of

all those 1 run games that they lost, those extra innings games, leads blown.....
 
Also, having Carlos batting behind Vernon Wells would mean better pitches for Vernon to hit. One big bat would probably have helped to win around 5-7 more games.
 
Pitching wins ball games. Having Delgado doesnt mean we would win extra inning ball games. They need a legit closer.. not a swingman Escobar closer.. not a former starter turned closer.. but a real closer. The bullpen is pretty chaotic. Remember the days of Henke, Ward, Cox, Timlin, Wells. Ya David Wells in the pullpen. You only needed to score 2-3 runs to win with pitching depth. Easier said than done. No huge payroll guarentees that either. Look at the Yankees pitching. But they need to solidify pitching roles on this team and stick with it.
 
yes you need pitching to win games but you don't win games by shutting down the other team you need runs in the board to WIN games

it is not realistic to think that you will shut the door on teams like:

Yankees
Boston
Texas
Baltimore
Chicago

these are the ones that come to mind whom you need bats to win against
and 3 of those 5 teams are in our division
 
Over the course of a long season, the team with the better pitching will always beat the team with a better offence. The Jays need pitching, all kinds of it. If it was just offence, Boston would have won more World Series than they do now. Im not saying get 5 Roy Halladys. Yes, he can shut down any offence. You need serviceable arms. They have Roy and nothing. The offence isnt great either mind you, but they lost more games this year from shit pitching than a poor offence. Batista alone cost them what 5-6 games or more. You score 5-6 runs you have to win those to be a playoff team.
 
Btw.. Texas is a great example of a terrific offence that will finish last every year. Baltimore too.
 
salsamarc said:
so you are saying thst if Delgado was here we will be better by 5 wins????

sorry i must disagree with you there BIG TIME Delgado is a power hitter as well as a dangerous hitter you put Koskie and Hillebrand around him and their numbers would have been much better i do believe that Delgado alone could have win us at least 10 games and 15 games is not unheard of

all those 1 run games that they lost, those extra innings games, leads blown.....

Sorry, but this is backed up by decades of sabermetric research. One player just doesn't do that much for a team.
Also, adding a batter to the lineup, anywhere, doesn't have noticeable effects on hitters around him.
There is no way IN HELL Delgado wins this team 15 more games.
Sorry.
 
LurkerDave said:
Also, having Carlos batting behind Vernon Wells would mean better pitches for Vernon to hit. One big bat would probably have helped to win around 5-7 more games.

This is roughly accurate, in regards to the number of extra wins this team would have with a PRIMO hitter added, like Delgado.
 
stever said:
Over the course of a long season, the team with the better pitching will always beat the team with a better offence. The Jays need pitching, all kinds of it. If it was just offence, Boston would have won more World Series than they do now. Im not saying get 5 Roy Halladys. Yes, he can shut down any offence. You need serviceable arms. They have Roy and nothing. The offence isnt great either mind you, but they lost more games this year from shit pitching than a poor offence. Batista alone cost them what 5-6 games or more. You score 5-6 runs you have to win those to be a playoff team.

This is a total fallacy.
The best teams are the teams that have the best run differentials. The contributions of offense and defense are totally equal.
It's not "just offense" or "the team with the better pitching".
 
stever said:
Btw.. Texas is a great example of a terrific offence that will finish last every year. Baltimore too.

Texas is a .490 team - just a shade under .500.
They're second in the AL in runs scored. They're third last in the AL in runs allowed.
They're not finishing last this year.
They're in the middle of the pack, which is what you'd expect when you've got a second-best offense, but a third-worst defense.

Baltimore is 11th in offense, 9th in defense. This adds up to a .476 team.

Neither is in last. That honour belongs to the Royals, who are last in both runs scored and allowed.

Make sense now?
 
you forget to mention about pitchers like Randy Johnson, Curt Shilling, Al Leiter, Barry Zito, Greg Maddux, Tom Glavine......just to name a few proven winners that are having one of the worse season in their career.......as much as i like Halliday i have to admit it to myself that he has only been a "good" pitcher for the past 2 or 3 years maybe 4 i don't have his stats infront of me

the Jays won the WS in 93 because the 3 best hitters in the American League that year were wearing Jays Uniforms Olerud, Molitor and Alomar and lets not forget a certain Joe Carter...

also who could forget Alomar's home run against Eckersley that was the turning point in the ALCS that year...

i say get more offense and ONE more quality starter a proven pitcher, next year Halliday looks good so does Chacin (for a rookie) Towers coul be a number 4 or 5 pitcher but they need a number 2 pitcher in the rotation

Furthermore a guy like Delgado plays everyday and a starter plays once every fifth day so YES Delgado alone would have won 15 games (if not 20) having him around makes other hitters like Wells, Koskie, Hillebrand and Hinske better hitters....

make sense now???
 
what the jays are really missing is REAL ball fans-who will come to a game,actually pay for the tickets & act like respectful patrons
 
pretty much every pitch thrown to them!

Jays are in a rebuilding phas that will last for years..unless Ted wants to hold the trophy.

In the mean time they are making money! That's all the Board of Directors wants. Once they gained title to the stadium...it was clear sailing.

Remember, Rogers is the Canadian company that excels in not making money...so they do not have to pay taxes or dividends.
Don't expect the jays to have the budget for a world class team anytime soon. So long as the park is 50% full..it's making money.
 
salsamarc said:
Furthermore a guy like Delgado plays everyday and a starter plays once every fifth day so YES Delgado alone would have won 15 games (if not 20) having him around makes other hitters like Wells, Koskie, Hillebrand and Hinske better hitters....

make sense now???

Nope. You're just wrong. I can't say it more plainly. No player IN HISTORY has been worth 15 wins to his team.
If you'd like, I can point you to the research that's been done on this topic.
 
Ranger68 said:
This is a total fallacy.
The best teams are the teams that have the best run differentials. The contributions of offense and defense are totally equal.
It's not "just offense" or "the team with the better pitching".

Ranger is dead on. ( Did I just agree with him? )
All you need to do is look at the RedSox. Their pitching this year has been brutal yet there they are, in first place because they score runs. It doesn't really matter if you give up 5 runs a game if you score 5.6. Having said that, the Indians have the best run differential in the AL, but can't see the White Sox taillights, so run diff isn't completely definitive.
 
No, but run differential is the best predictor of actual wins and losses - FAR superior to runs scored or runs allowed.
This proves that the best teams are neither the ones that score the most nor allow the fewest.
The best teams are the ones with the best combination of offense and defense.

There is debate on what the variation between predicted winning percentage and actual winning percentage indicates. Mostly, it's just luck - teams that vary wildly in one season will usually return to form the next. It's possible that bullpen proficiency has some affect - this is the idea that a good or bad bullpen will affect your ability to win close games. That notion tends not to work all the time, though, so I discount most of it.

Finally, your statement that the Indians have the best differential in the AL but "can't see the White Sox taillights" is pretty misleading. Chicago is +89, the Indians are +112. This is not a huge difference. And Cleveland is only 4.5 games back, still well within striking distance.
 
Ranger68 said:
Finally, your statement that the Indians have the best differential in the AL but "can't see the White Sox taillights" is pretty misleading. Chicago is +89, the Indians are +112. This is not a huge difference. And Cleveland is only 4.5 games back, still well within striking distance.

Shit! I'm agreeing again. I was actually looking at Clevelands E#, not GBL.

However, saying 24 runs ( +113 to +89 ) is not a huge difference? Would 27 be a huge difference? That's the gap between the Yanks and Jays. Oakland is +112, the Yankees +86, yet the Yanks are 2.5 up on the A's for the WC. Like all stats Run differential is a great indicator of potential W/L, but "shit happens". There's a lot of intangibles.
 
Hmmmm, I think the pitching is fine. In fact, without the type of pitching they're getting, the Jays would be well under .500. I think Chacin is a legit #2 and Towers and Bush are legit 3 and 4's. I think that Lilly is dispensable at this point. (Although I think he's a far better pitcher than he's shown this year and that he has arm troubles at this point.)

What the Jays are badly lacking right now is OFFENCE. Wells is disappointing without Delgado. Hinske is disappointing period. Koskie is probably still injured. Hill needs more maturing. Ditto Rios. That leaves a bunch of journeymen hitters trying to carry the team.

My suggestion, deal Lilly for a legit major league catcher and pick up the best DH you can on the free agent market and then the Jays could make a reasonable run at the WC.
 
bigdik said:
Shit! I'm agreeing again. I was actually looking at Clevelands E#, not GBL.

However, saying 24 runs ( +113 to +89 ) is not a huge difference? Would 27 be a huge difference? That's the gap between the Yanks and Jays. Oakland is +112, the Yankees +86, yet the Yanks are 2.5 up on the A's for the WC. Like all stats Run differential is a great indicator of potential W/L, but "shit happens". There's a lot of intangibles.

24 or 27 runs usually translates into two or three wins in the W-L column - towards the lower end of that for the best teams in the league. That's not much. I say again, 24 runs in differential isn't that much.

To use the Jays as an example when looking at run differential isn't terribly useful - they have about the biggest difference between predicted and actual winning percentage this year. Luck? Bad bullpen? Both, probably. This year, the Yanks have overachieved, and the Jays have underachieved.

No stat is the be-all and end-all. You're not really grasping that point.
The point was that the best predictor of actual winning percentage is run differential. This is a proven fact. It's not runs scored (offense) or runs allowed (defense). Run differential is drastically better than both of those.

If you want to argue the point more, go look at the standings, then correlate them with Runs Scored, with Runs Allowed, and with Run Differential. Then tell me the results, and what they prove.