tboy said:
If your papers are in order you will have NO problem getting in.....
Not true tboy, really, not true. I've entered the US many times, for work. Many times I've just been waved through, but also, several times, I've been pulled aside for extra questioning. I always had the correct paperwork. I always got through. That didn't mean I had no problem, though, they'd treat me like shit, glare at me, insult me, intimidate me, and all for what?
In the story the woman makes an understandable mistake. Yes, it's a mistake, and the rules are the rules, she had to go back to the UK. It could have been handled oh so much better. There's NO REASON to be an asshole in a situation like that. You can be polite. You can be friendly. You can be considerate. You can be firm, and send the person back, telling them to return with the right paperwork next time.
No need to be an asshole about it, but US agents are ROUTINELY assholes, not just to those who don't have the right paperwork, but also to those who do.
As I mentioned other countries have even stricter procedures (the UK deals with far more terrorists than the US does) and yet manage to do it without being jerks.
Similar situation with British immigration and you'd also be on a plane home with your entry denied, but you'd be treated like a human being, offered tea, made to feel as pleasant as possible under the unfortunate circumstances of your deportation. No-one would insult you. No-one would intimidate you. They'd politely point out that you don't have grounds to enter and turn you around and send you home.
And these are guys who DO deal with terrorists, and who work at an airport where there have been more attempts at bombings, at blowing up planes, etc., than any US airport. Honestly they have a better track record of stopping threats too, proof positive to me that you can be security conscious, and follow the rules, all the while being nice.