Welcome to America

Damn, that's scary.

I HATE going through the US immigration and customs. The people who screen you can be extremely rude and threatening. I think there were numerous complaints about the way they search your baggage because last time I came back, the person was very friendly and at the end they gave me a survey asking how friendly they were!
 
Fart in a bottle, put on the lid, and pack it in your checked luggage. Mark it in some way so you can find out whether they opened it and had a good whiff.
 
WELL, before all the US haters come out of the wood work let's review that article to see what she did wrong:
1) She falsified an official US immgration document
2) She did NOT have the correct visa in order to enter the US to "work"
3) She (by her own admission) raised her voice more than once to an official US immigration officer

For the record, immigration officers are taught to look for the slightest thing OUT of the ordinary. In this case, it was the author who erred by not knowing the new rules for journalists entering the US and falsifying her immgration papers.

From what she wrote in her story, I DO believe she wasn't mistreated in any way and from the sounds of it, the guards/officials she came into contact with were for the most part, courteous.

Handcuffing is standard procedure when transporting "detainees" not only to protect the guards, but to protect the detainees too. What do you think would happen if she was put in a room and no one was handcuffed and someone attacted her? She'd scream blue murder.

Sorry, if you don't know the rules, and break them, accept your situation and do NOT be beligerant about it.

For the record: I got the gist from reading her article that she has the attitude that because she's a journalist she should be treated differently because she is MORE important that anyone else......sorry, that doesn't fly in my eyes.

I just wonder what would have happened had she falsifyed immigration documents going into Russia or North Korea? She'd probably STILL be in a dungeon somewhere......

Just a quick story:

After 9/11 I was crossing over the detroit windsor border with a co-worker (on business). We had some commercial goods with us so we had to go into the office to see if there were any duties or whatever to be paid (my co-worker's last name was Hossein lol). While we were there another male came in all bluff and bluster pushing his way through the line. He had to be repeatedly told to get back in line and wait his turn. He finally pushed his way past and rushed the counter screaming "i'm an american citizen and...." was cut off by the immigration officer yelling "so am I an if you DON"T get back in line this instant you'll be handcuffed to that bench over there..."

He finally made it up to the window and because I was at the next window, I overheard him say that he was sent into the office because he didn't have ANY form of identification. I also heard him roar once again "I"m an american citizen and do not deserve to be treated like this...." The immigration officer said very calmly "well, that remains to be seen because as it stands now, you have NO proof of your citizenship and it is up to YOU to prove who you are not up to ME to determine it....."
 
tboy said:
WELL, before all the US haters come out of the wood work let's review that article to see what she did wrong:

That's all true, and I agree she basically got what she deserved. They do follow rules.

However, they're still assholes. I follow the rules, and always get through, but that doesn't stop them from being rude and aggressive and condescending, all of which there is no call for.

Canadian agents are OK. The best I've ever encountered are the British. They are just as thorough as anywhere else, actually more so, but they are polite and friendly the whole time, they smile, they make jokes, but they don't let you go until they've carefully checked everything. Amazing.

Once clearing UK customers I was missing some paperwork. When the agent realized this, he sighed, and said in kind of a joking way, "Oh, these situations are the bane of our existence. Well mate, better settle in because this is going to take some time, but we'll get through it." Practically offered me tea. US agents in the same situation start insulting you, glaring at you, demanding to know what you think you're doing there, etc.

No need for customers officers to be assholes.
 
tboy said:
WELL, before all the US haters come out of the wood work let's review that article to see what she did wrong:
1) She falsified an official US immgration document
2) She did NOT have the correct visa in order to enter the US to "work"
3) She (by her own admission) raised her voice more than once to an official US immigration officer

For the record, immigration officers are taught to look for the slightest thing OUT of the ordinary. In this case, it was the author who erred by not knowing the new rules for journalists entering the US and falsifying her immgration papers.

From what she wrote in her story, I DO believe she wasn't mistreated in any way and from the sounds of it, the guards/officials she came into contact with were for the most part, courteous.

Handcuffing is standard procedure when transporting "detainees" not only to protect the guards, but to protect the detainees too. What do you think would happen if she was put in a room and no one was handcuffed and someone attacted her? She'd scream blue murder.

Sorry, if you don't know the rules, and break them, accept your situation and do NOT be beligerant about it.

For the record: I got the gist from reading her article that she has the attitude that because she's a journalist she should be treated differently because she is MORE important that anyone else......sorry, that doesn't fly in my eyes.

I just wonder what would have happened had she falsifyed immigration documents going into Russia or North Korea? She'd probably STILL be in a dungeon somewhere......

Did we read the same article? :rolleyes:
 
Fuji is right. I've encountered some of the worst officials on the windsor/detroit border and they don't see to care about how they treat people. There is no excuse.
 
Mao Tse Tongue said:
Did we read the same article? :rolleyes:

Sure we did...but did you read it with neutrality in mind or did you read it with the mindset that she was used abused and maltreated worse than you'd treat a dog?

Sorry, but what everyone has to realize is that after 9/11, the border guards have a HUGE fire under their ass for letting the terrorists in so easily EVEN the ones on the "no entry" list.

I personally would rather have assholes guarding our border and catch all terrorists than the ones we have who let them in without so much as a second look.......

If your papers are in order you will have NO problem getting in.....

As the popular saying goes: walk a mile in their shoes before you comment on how they act.....
 
Yikes. I remember going to the States once to visit a friend and they grilled me about how I know this person, how long I had known them, why I was going to visit them, if I had a sexual relationship with this person. Yeesh!
 
God bless America!
 
While Tboy makes a good point, this just goes over board. I've been to many countries, including "third world" type places and none have immigration/customs officlals as unpleasant to deal with as the US.
 
tboy said:
If your papers are in order you will have NO problem getting in.....

Not true tboy, really, not true. I've entered the US many times, for work. Many times I've just been waved through, but also, several times, I've been pulled aside for extra questioning. I always had the correct paperwork. I always got through. That didn't mean I had no problem, though, they'd treat me like shit, glare at me, insult me, intimidate me, and all for what?

In the story the woman makes an understandable mistake. Yes, it's a mistake, and the rules are the rules, she had to go back to the UK. It could have been handled oh so much better. There's NO REASON to be an asshole in a situation like that. You can be polite. You can be friendly. You can be considerate. You can be firm, and send the person back, telling them to return with the right paperwork next time.

No need to be an asshole about it, but US agents are ROUTINELY assholes, not just to those who don't have the right paperwork, but also to those who do.

As I mentioned other countries have even stricter procedures (the UK deals with far more terrorists than the US does) and yet manage to do it without being jerks.

Similar situation with British immigration and you'd also be on a plane home with your entry denied, but you'd be treated like a human being, offered tea, made to feel as pleasant as possible under the unfortunate circumstances of your deportation. No-one would insult you. No-one would intimidate you. They'd politely point out that you don't have grounds to enter and turn you around and send you home.

And these are guys who DO deal with terrorists, and who work at an airport where there have been more attempts at bombings, at blowing up planes, etc., than any US airport. Honestly they have a better track record of stopping threats too, proof positive to me that you can be security conscious, and follow the rules, all the while being nice.
 
So as long as you have your paperwork in order you've got no problem, correct? I remember how the US Goverment and Media reported on how all of the people involved in the 9/11 attack had come in through Cananda.

Guess What, they were all let in LEGALY with all of their paperwork in order, and nobody snuck in from Canada.

Should she have been detained, sure. But I would have released her after confirming that she was a journalist through the British Counslate and her paper.

Funny how the US is getting flooded with illegal aliens all along it's southern boarder and the goverment is doing NOTHING to stop it because who's gonna cut the grass, clean their houses, etc...

Was she a threat to US Security, no. She should have been warned, applied for and granted a visa on the spot. Think of the spin that story would have generated! Instead short sightedness has begot this.
 
WinterHawk said:
Should she have been detained, sure. But I would have released her after confirming that she was a journalist through the British Counslate and her paper.

To be fair they probably didn't have that option. Customs agents have only limited discretion despite the way they sound. They follow rules. They do what the rules tell them to do. Stupid rules maybe, but those were likely the rules.

None of which means they had to be abusive in following those rules, and having experienced it first hand myself, I have no doubt whatsoever that they were abusive. (Luckily in my case after suffering the abuse the rules said they had to let me through, and they did.)
 
don't get blacklisted.

hey - you don't want to be blacklisted.

i've been blacklisted, because I got a dickhead customs agent who got me talking at 5:30am one morning. now every time I go through I treated like some like kind of thug. i have legitimate business, paperwork, credentials, the whole 9-yards, but they just toy with you for the hell of it, i swear.

...and unfortunately, i have to travel to the US at least a couple times per month. i like amercians, but their gov't i could do without.


gavin.
 
Hmmm...

Interesting how everyone jumps to the conclusion that everything she said is what occured verbatim.

I'm sure journalists never lie or embellish for a story. :rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
biog said:
Interesting how every jumps to the conclusion that everything she said is what occured verbatim.

I'm sure journalists never lie or embellish for a story. :rolleyes:

Good point, I wonder just how beligerant she really was???
 
I've never had a problem with the US Customs or Immigration people. Behave in a civil and respectful manner and they do the same.

I suppose my natural wit, charm and sauve good looks help but that can't be the only reason.:)
 
LancsLad said:
I suppose my natural wit, charm and sauve good looks help but that can't be the only reason.

Yep, thats it, most immigration officers are male.:)