Wealth Tax - Consider This

Maybe elimination of RRSP's is on the table. Only a few people know for sure. The lefties will argue that only "rich" people contribute to RRSP's.
 
Maybe elimination of RRSP's is on the table. Only a few people know for sure. The lefties will argue that only "rich" people contribute to RRSP's.
Not likely. RRSP is just a deferral of taxes. And you end up paying full tax on capital gains and dividends.
 
RRSP is just a deferral of taxes. And you end up paying full tax on capital gains and dividends.
Yes, but the deferral could be as much as 50 years, if someone starts contributing at age 21. Even longer if they convert to a RRIF and make only minimum yearly withdrawals.

How about raising the gasoline tax because only "rich" people drive cars?
 
My father left home before he turned 18 with a grade 9 education and couldn't speak tete carre, only pea soup. [yeah this was a while ago]
He was literally a hobo sadly without a shotgun for a while. He had to sell a nice jacket he managed to buy to eat. He has relied on Sally Ann.
Managed to better himself in the land of the tete carre even before joining the RCAF. Even taught himself the language. In an era where there was much less supports.
I don't know how he did it, but I know plenty of minimum wage people and dole people and they are usually but not always their own worst enemy. The stories I could tell. But then you can't do much for stupid and unreasonable.

Yes, 50 years ago upward mobility was much higher.
How do you do that in a city with million dollar housing on minimum wage?
 
You best not be thinking you are qualified to mess about like that in the tax code

Any party that proposes a capital gains tax on the principal residence of any Canadian Citizen needs to make it part of their election platform
And any party that proposes a capital gains tax on the principal residence and is upfront about it will get destroyed in the election
Middle class home owners / voters can recognized a slimly slippery slope when they see one

Of course the liberals will only promote the bribes of more spending and foolishly trot this abomination out post election

If they do it for luxury homes people will not at all object. Why should they make it part of their election platform? That you would suggest that shows you are clueless. You don't talk about new taxes in elections, only a fool would do that or suggest it.
 
Yes, but the deferral could be as much as 50 years, if someone starts contributing at age 21. Even longer if they convert to a RRIF and make only minimum yearly withdrawals.

How about raising the gasoline tax because only "rich" people drive cars?
Govt does not care about 50 years, they do will on RRSPs. They get liquidated on death in many cases and govt gets full tax rate. You think the govt does not know the total value of RRSPs and their projected tax rate? Lots of non-rich drive cars, but they have raised gas taxes for a lot of reasons. Notice gas was almost 1.40 in ON when oil only hit less then $75? Last time it was this high oil was north of $100
 
Last edited:
If they do it for luxury homes people will not at all object.

What part of "Middle class home owners / voters can recognized a slimly slippery slope when they see one " is giving you such a comprehension problem?


Why should they make it part of their election platform?
It is called being open and honest with the electorate
That you would suggest that shows you are clueless.
Your response shows how untrustworthy you are

You don't talk about new taxes in elections, only a fool would do that or suggest it.
The NDP has a new wealth tax right upfront as a center piece of their platform.
Despite the obvious moral and economic problems with this proposed theft , to their credit they are not resorting to the slimly liberal tactic of intentionally deceiving the electorate about new taxes

Only a fool thinks he can constantly view the electorate as fools
 
Govt does not care about 50 years,

You mean a irresponsible government does not care about 50 years


they do will on RRSPs. They get liquidated on death in many cases and govt gets full tax rate.

Yep the bloody ghouls have their hands in your pocket even after you kick the bucket
And now Justin has ensure there is a massive and crippling tax burden awaiting every newborn Canadian for many generations
And obviously you are fully intent on increasing the cradle to grave burden


You think the govt does not know the total value of RRSPs and their projected tax rate?
Justin does not think about monetary policy, why would he know the value of RRSPs and their projected tax rate?

My guess is he has never completely read any of his governments budgets.
They are irrelevant to him and all that reading would cut into his photo op schedule


Lots of non-rich drive cars, but they have raised gas taxes for a lot of reasons. Notice gas was almost 1.40 in ON when oil only hit less then $75? Last time it was this high oil was north of $100

You are confirming the inflationary impact of Justin the fools policies.
You do understand that affordability is the primary concern for the electorate this election, correct ?
 
You mean a irresponsible government does not care about 50 years




Yep the bloody ghouls have their hands in your pocket even after you kick the bucket
And now Justin has ensure there is a massive and crippling tax burden awaiting every newborn Canadian for many generations
And obviously you are fully intent on increasing the cradle to grave burden



Justin does not think about monetary policy, why would he know the value of RRSPs and their projected tax rate?

My guess is he has never completely read any of his governments budgets.
They are irrelevant to him and all that reading would cut into his photo op schedule




You are confirming the inflationary impact of Justin the fools policies.
You do understand that affordability is the primary concern for the electorate this election, correct ?
Are you for real? I mean are you a human being?

I could easily write a program to spew out nonsensical platitudes like this.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Frankfooter
Yes, 50 years ago upward mobility was much higher.
How do you do that in a city with million dollar housing on minimum wage?
Well, for one, don't live in a place with million dollar housing.

Also the government was much smaller back then. Think that might be a connection?

Also he lived in a time when
Governments didn't bend over backwards making landlords bitches for their tenants.
Where you could actually build for density without some Nimby group of cunts stopping you
You know before the 70's when plenty of apartments were being built and one could live in them.
The housing and apartment crisis if you look at it, is fully the fault of the government trying to solve a problem and ending up making it worse.
I live in a house that is way to big for my needs, but I can't afford to move out, and even if I could, every apartment in town requires applications. 50 years of not building apartments and this is the result. So this 4 bedroom house of mine will stay off the market.

Also in terms of upward mobility, a wealth tax doesn't help that at all. Not a lot of chances for upward mobility when you are trying to make TVs or provide phone sex services in an open field with no equipment.
 
]Are you for real?
Quite real
I mean are you a human being?
My birth certificate confirms I am
Do ya think anyone would bother to program a bot to make spelling mistakes?

I could easily write a program to spew out nonsensical platitudes like this.

Or course you could spew out nonsensical demands, you already have

Me?
I am just pointing out the facts

Any government which does not carefully consider the long term impacts of it policy's is just plan irresponsible
It is a fact all newborns in Canada have a future tax obligation (a real big one now). A tax obligation that will be with them for all thier days
It is also a fact the tax man takes a massive bit after you die
It is a fact Justin is not really a numbers sort of guy. So he just ignores them
I truly believe he has never once properly and fully read one of his budgets. let alone reviewed any of them with the critique and care as demanded by the responsibilities of his office

It is also a fact that has inflation has jumped up , as predicted
It is a fact his policy's are very inflationary, as predicted
It is also a fact that affordability is the primary concern for the electorate this election


You just ignore the facts which do not fit your view.
So to turn your question around
are you for real ?
 
YOu can do certain things, like eliminate the capital gains exemption on all homes greater then $3m for example (maybe 5M) Capital Gains tax rates only available for 25K/year all the rest taxed at FULL income rates. (unless in RRSP). Or alternatively eliminiate capital gains taxation rates altogether and give people a one time 500K allotment at 25% tax. This will allow the middle class to build wealth faster and fully tax capital gains from the rich. Of course there are no tax polices that can really help the poor as they pay no tax mostly and have no savings. But I would lower the rate for the first tax bracket by 5% and increase the top the appropriate amount to make it neutral. Of course this would all have to be run through modeling to see what the predicted impact on the economy is.

You understand what it will lead to, right.

1) People will invest abroad and do not realize their capital gains until they retire
2) When they retire, they will move abroad, become non-residents for tax purposes (or even renounce their Canadian citizenship) and then live on their investment without paying any taxes in Canada

So, basically, it will reduce both domestic investment and tax revenue. Capital is much more mobile then labor, so, when capital gain tax is large, the capital goes to another country.
 
Drive by a food bank line and look at all the devices the people are on
So anywhere from $500-$1200 for the device ( or you pay extra each month to pay for it) monthly phone plan probably anywhere from $60-$150 depending on who you’re with what you have
That is because people like you swarm the food banks to avoid poor people getting free food.
 
That is because people like you swarm the food banks to avoid poor people getting free food.
Yeah nice try
It’s usually guys like yourself who claim they pay more taxes than anyone else on the board and donate more than anyone else that are the first ones in the food bank line

please back up your accusation against me you can’t because you’re full of hot air

stick to the topic
 
Yeah nice try
It’s usually guys like yourself who claim they pay more taxes than anyone else on the board and donate more than anyone else that are the first ones in the food bank line

please back up your accusation against me you can’t because you’re full of hot air

stick to the topic
That hit a nerve, Eh?

I never claimed to donate much, because I don't. I mostly donate to animal welfare causes, because I believe welfare for people is the responsibility of our governments and not the responsibility of old religious ladies.